Solving time: 37 minutes
This puzzle seemed more like a Sunday offering, with short but gnarly clues, which draw general knowledge more into play than usual. I did manage to complete the right-hand half fairly promptly, but the left, and particularly the SW corner, held me up. There were some tricky literals here, which gives the cryptics a much stronger defense. Even when I worked out the cryptic, I couldn’t see how it could be the answer.
Music: Beethoven, Overtures, Furtwangler/VPO
Across | |
---|---|
1 | VENISON, NO(SINE)V, all backwards. |
5 | BA(TT)Y. I was trying to think of an English dialect word for this, probably something along the lines of ‘scatty’, but the real answer turned out to be quite simple. |
9 | Omitted. |
10 | ELABORATE, anagram of OR EATABLE, quite an easy one.. |
11 | CLAMOUR, CLAM + [c]OUR[t]. I wasted a lot of time trying to put something inside of CT, although this made a mess of 3 down. |
12 | TACKLED, CAT backwards + ELK backwards + D[ied]. |
13 | COTTAGE PIE, anagram of GET A POETIC. Not such an easy one for me. |
15 | Omitted. |
18 | RASH, RA’S H[oney], where hives are a disease rather than homes for bees. |
20 | DIAGNOSTIC, DI + AGNOSTIC. I’m surprised I haven’t seen this one before. |
23 | PROVERB, double definition. A gnome is a proverbial saying in one of the ancient Germanic languages; examples survive in Anglo-Saxon and Old Norse. |
24 | BOOKLET. BO(OK)LE + T[ime]. Here, ‘OK” is a verb that means ‘allow’. Thanks, aphis99! |
25 | ALLEGORIC, anagram of REAL LOGIC. Not easy for me because I had a wrong word. |
26 | SOBER, S(O.B.E)R, the Order of the British Empire. |
27 | LODGE, EG + DOL[l] backwards. You have to use ‘lodge’ as a verb, as in ‘lodge a complaint’ – then it can mean ‘present’. |
28 | HONESTY, HO(NEST)Y. A bit of guess for me, but I vaguely remembered ‘Hoy’, and it seemed like the most probable plant name. |
Down | |
1 | VAGRANT, VA + GRANT. They could also use the Veteran’s |
2 | NATIONAL, RATIONAL – R + N. An arbitrary change of first letter clue, not everyone’s favorite here. |
3 | STEER, ST + E’ER. ‘Steer’ as a noun meaning ‘a bit of advice’ is not the first meaning that springs to mind; it is most often seen in the phrase ‘a bum steer’. |
4 | NEAR THING, anagram of THEN A GRIN. |
5 | BROACH, B + ROACH, one of our favorites fishes, along with ling and ide. |
6 | Omitted. |
7 | YIELD, double definition, or maybe one and a half. |
8 | STOCK CAR, COT’S + RACK, both backwards, but separately. I don’t quite follow what ‘first’ means in the clue. For that matter, how did a NASCAR racer get into a UK puzzle? |
14 | EDINBURGH, anagram of BIRD HE + GUN, very well-concealed. I put in ‘Edinburgh’, and then erased it when I couldn’t justify it….then I saw it! |
16 | TACITURN, CAT backwards + 1 TURN. |
17 | COLOSSUS, hidden backwards (or upwards) in [worrie]S US, SO LOC[ked]. |
19 | SCOWLED, SCOW + LED. |
21 | Omitted. |
22 | LEAGUE, LE + AGUE. Rather tricky. I spotted ‘band together’ as the literal, but was puzzled by ‘fit’ for a while. |
23 | PEARL, PEA(R)L. I don’t usually think of pearl as a gem, so got briefly stuck on this. |
24 | BACON, B + A CON. I carelessly put ‘Baden’ at first, which is not even the whole surname. |
Not sure I like the clue for PROVERB, as it seems to me to be two synonymous definitions (though they do have other meanings).
I think ‘first’ just means you need to carry out the reversals before getting the solution.
I was flipping between A GNOSTIC and AGNOSTIC at 20ac and amused myself by reflecting that the clue could just as easily have started “Girl, a believer..”
Just discovered my name among the Saturday puzzle prizewinners from a couple of weeks ago – so there, the tortoises do beat the hares occasionally. Now where’s the nearest branch of WH Smith?
And btw if anybody hasn’t tackled it yet, the Saturday puzzle just gone was a beast.
I hereby resolve that in all future attempts I will ignore the clock until after submission.
The only word new to me today was STEER meaning a piece of advice. Of course I knew the expression “a bum steer” but I’ve never stopped to think what it actually means before.
On the whole I think this was quite a clever puzzle for the misdirection in a number of clues.
Had no idea at all — no nothing — not a thing — about the parsing for BOOKLET, so ta to aphis99 for pointing that one out. The “allow” = OK (not LET) went straight over my head. But there was no other possible answer. (Hate to enter answers without at least some idea of the parsing.)
My COD goes to 12ac (TACKLED) for the Bullwinkle flavours of the clue. Boris (to Natsaha): “I get cat, you get moose!”
Today’s unknowns: gnome, bole, HONESTY.
I thought 8 was bed’s (with) frame first all turned up, if somebody else hasn’t already said that.
CoD for the very smooth RASH
ak
Not a particularly enjoyable solve either. There was too much I didn’t like:
“Possibly” in 10;
“Name for a” in 13;
The already-mentioned closeness of the two definitions for proverb;
Woolly definitions for diagnostic, lodge, national, league and hunter for cat.
Bah
Cod to COLOSSUS, which I put in thinking COLS were some sort of “worries” – doh! Excellent hidden word!
Thanks for clear blog, vinyl, much appreciated.
Louise
Presumably, that’s why I noticed 19d- it needs the beginners who don’t get them all to spot the blanks that are still left. I still can’t fathom this one, even with the crossing letters, and if someone could furnish me with the answer I’d be very grateful.
If it’s any consolation, I spent a ridiculous amount of time trying to justify BOOKLET based on “trunk” = BOOT before light finally dawned.
I also wasn’t familiar with that STEER = “piece of advice”, having (like others) always assumed that a “bum steer” was somehow related to cattle.
Apart from that I agree with john_from_lancs: I found COLOSSUS easy to get but not to explain, and never saw that it was a hidden word clue, and CLAMOUR is delightful, with the “silent type” at the beginning contradicting the whole and leading one’s thoughts in entirely the wrong direction.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Old_man_of_hoy