Solving time: 17 minutes.
All straightforward, except that I couldn’t parse 18ac for a while: November Foxtrot India. Then the small coin fell. Now that I see it, a clear Charlie Oscar Delta.
Now holde your pees, my tale I wol beginne.
| Across | |
|---|---|
| 1 | S,CREAM. |
| 5 | TYPE,CAST. ‘Characters’ gives us TYPE and (acts)* gives us CAST. |
| 9 | COORDINATE. Anagram of ‘decoration’. Now I find there’s also CAROTENOID and CORONADITE. (Thank you, Chambers Anagrams.) |
| 10 | I would prefer to omit this one. |
| 11 | IN CAMERA. Double def. (Makes me wonder parenthetically: where are films [rolls of film, celluloid] more often seen these days?) |
| 12 | SHRIKE. Exchange last two letters of ‘shriek’. The name of Christie Malry’s girlfriend in B.S. Johnson’s novel. She worked for a butcher. |
| 13 | TREK. A very tight and clever clue indeed. First letters of ‘The Red’; last letters of ‘thE blacK’. |
| 15 | GLOSS(AR)Y. The filler is A, plus the last letter of ‘writeR’. |
| 18 | PARDONER. Wrote this in right away with only the D and the R to go on. Had to suffer said Tale for A-level English. But then … why? A pardoner completely forgives a debt or sentence; as opposed to merely commuting (reducing) it. |
| 19 | BO(D)Y. The def is ‘person’. |
| 21 | APAC(H)E. The wrapper is from ‘with expedition’. |
| 23 | QUARTERS. That is, 25¢ pieces. Once had an interesting exchange about the pronunciation: |ˈkôrtər| or |ˈkwôrtər|? And why? |
| 25 | SIAM. S for small, then ‘I am’ (Latin: sum). Perhaps best known from the famous Cartesian saying, “I think they’re for one a.m.”. (Thank you, My Word.) Descartes, take that away from me! |
| 26 | DEALING OUT. I call these things reverse cryptics. The answer (‘dealing out’) could clue the word ‘aligned’. Very neat when, as here, they work. |
| 27 | STRANG(L)E. The wrapper is from ‘unfamiliar’; the def is ‘throttle or choke’. |
| 28 | HIDING. Double def. |
| Down | |
|---|---|
| 2 | CROW,N. |
| 3 | EARMARKED. On the premiss that some animals have tags in their ears. Anagram of ‘are’; then ‘pronounced’ gives us MARKED. |
| 4 | Down clue omitted. Ask if it bowls you over. |
| 5 | TRAFALGAR SQUARE. Cryptic def. The National Gallery is there, sternward of Viscount Nelson, Duke of Bronte (1758–1805). |
| 6 | PRESS BOX. ‘Crowd’ for PRESS and ‘fight’ for BOX. |
| 7 | COWER. Double def; the second unlikely to be much used (a person who cows, intimidates). Add to the flow-er, butt-er, … list. |
| 8 | SNOOKERED. Anagram of ‘needs rook’. |
| 14 | REAPPOINT. Anagram of ‘Part I open’. |
| 16 | SABOTAGED. Anagram of ‘boats’ + AGED. |
| 17 | UNDERDO,G. |
| 20 | PARIS,H. |
| 22 | COMMA. Double def. |
| 24 | ROUE,N. |
So as usual, I was stuck for a while, then made a giant breakthrough and wrote in whole sections. But I’ll never be a speed demon.
The setter did miss a chance to use the Chaucerian meaning of ‘wood’ – I wonder if that would be considered legitimate or not…
I had heard of the butterfly but couldn’t bring it to mind and I was misled into thinking I needed a word inside another word to make the whole. At 25 I wasted time trying to make MITE fit.
There were some lovely clues here. I particularly liked TREK, WOOD and TRAFALGAR SQUARE because for a moment the clue made me wonder whether it had ever been a place of public execution.
Very enjoyable. Lots of pleasing clues but my COD goes to SIAM: a real sense of satisfaction when the meaning of ‘sum, classically speaking’ finally dawned.
I was sorry to see 10A WOOD omitted because it’s a well crafted clue. I don’t really understand why we omit these clues. If a person isn’t aware of this blog they phone the help line. If they know of this blog they come here and ask. Why pretend any different?
But for most puzzles, I would prefer to omit a few. If you have all the crossing letters for the easy ones, you should be able to get them.
More amusing than I thought it would be after spotting the distinctly average clues for TRAFALGAR SQ and SCREAM.
I hesitated over SHRIKE because my iffy ornithology conjured up images of a raptor rather than a songbird.
CoD to SIAM for a really nice penny drop, special commendations to UNDERDOG for the underdo bit, and PARDONER. Put me down for the vintage fortunate enough to have the gat-toothed Wyf of Bath (didn’t everybody?) for A level
… or they use one of the various other sites which share none of this blog’s scruples, cheerfully providing answers even for prize crosswords before submission deadlines etc. (I’m not suggesting the site policy on prize crosswords should be changed.)
As a relative newcomer, who has now learnt a lot from the site, I used to find ‘omits’ particularly frustrating: they were frequently the clues on which I was stumped. However, I got lots of help when I overcame my fear of looking stupid and asked ‘dumb’ questions. This, I think, is perhaps the strongest argument for retaining the ‘omits’. It has made it evident that this is not an experts-only, exclusive site but one which genuinely tries to “to help new (and sometimes experienced) solvers understand how the clues work” and hence get more enjoyment from tackling the crossword.
Despite that, I think the ‘omits’ have probably passed their ‘use by’ date. The character of the site is now well-established and most ‘newbies’ would not, I think, feel intimidated (they should be put at ease by those of us who, on a daily basis, identify our own shortcomings).
So, thanks setter. And thanks mctext for a making me laugh with your intro, where the call signs also took a while to click over my first coffee of the day.
Last in: EARMARKED .. COD: PARDONER
I was stumped by pardoner, well done to all the Chaucerian scholars. I nearly found “summoner” but it just kept eluding, and wouldn’t have worked anyway.
Was in London with work last month and saw “Nelson’s Ship in a Bottle” on Trafalgar Square’s fourth plinth – quite a spectacle.
The SHRIKE was unfamiliar, but I’m sure I must have come across it before, and COMMA completely unknown but with the checking letters it couldn’t really be anything else.
I very nearly put in NATIONAL GALLERY at 5dn. Fortunately I noticed that it didn’t fit the enumeration but I thought for a while this might be a mistake.
Thanks to mctext for a very amusing blog and for explaining the reverse cryptic in 26ac, which I’d missed.
COD to SIAM by a nose over PARDONER for a couple of lovely PDMs.
Louise
As for the omitted clues on the blog it seems revolutionary ferment is spreading – first Egpyt , yesterday Bahrain and now…….