Solving time: 38 minutes.
The right-hand side went in quite quickly; the left a bit longer, pondering 3dn which didn’t give us a lot to go on. I was sure it was going to be MOTH … something; but it was one of the others. No real complaints; but no great delights either.
Across | |
---|---|
1 | CLEMATIS. CLEAT (in the nautical sense) and IS including M (for mark). |
6 | COMICS. COSMIC with its S moved to the end. |
9 | DAMSEL. Rev of LES and MAD; then two defs, the first being the damselfly (cf dragonfly). |
10 | REVERE,NT. The American hero who had a band called The Raiders; then your standard books. |
11 | BETA. Sounds like BEATER. |
12 | SACRAMENT,O. Capital of California. Lots of US State capitals are relatively obscure places now but used to be important when the railway was king. |
14 | HARD CORE. I see two defs here (a noun and an adjective) with an implied comma before ‘of’; and a question-mark by way of apology for the looseness of it all. |
16 | I shall restrain myself from including this one. |
18 | MAGE. IMAGE minus the I. |
19 | I[’]M,PAIRED. |
21 | GOOD FOR YOU. GO (turn), then an anagram of ‘your food’. ‘Yes, I’d like my steak cooked nicely too’. |
22 | HOP,E. E being the last letter of ‘place’. |
24 | DI(ASP)ORA. The snake in the RADIO-(ana)gram. |
26 | T(R)OUGH. |
27 | STA(YE)R. The def is the being who’s in for it. |
28 | ST,RIDING. ( |
Down | |
---|---|
2 | (P)LEASE. |
3 | MUSTARDSEED. Here you need to know your MSND (vide Peaseblossom et al) and your Kingdom of Heaven from three of the books in 10ac — Matthew 13:31–32; Mark 4:30–32; Luke 13:18–19. John didn’t cut the mustard. Edit: But see ulaca’s more likely NT source. Where’s PB when you need him? |
4 | TALK SHOW. A cryptic def. NB the archaic meaning of ‘converse’ as ‘conversation’. |
5 | STRICKEN IN YEARS. NINE reversed inside TRICKY (delicate); all this inside SEARS (burns). |
6 | CAV,EAT. Cav and Pag reprised here. |
7 | Mark this one off as an omission too. |
8 | CON,STANCE. Cf Bodensee. |
13 | ENGLISH BOND. Anagram of ‘his long bend’. More toolic knowledge required; cf yesterday’s JOINTER. “A bond used in brickwork consisting of alternate courses of stretchers and headers”. |
15 | AN,ATOM,IST (of Melancholy). |
17 | S,P(L)UTTER. The putter is the small stick used by people with strange pastimes, and too much time on their hands, to get a little white ball into a hole on a patch of lawn. |
20 | CO,LOUR. Commanding Officer. |
23 | PAGAN. Light inclusive. |
25 | SHY. Two defs; the first by reference to horses and such like. |
My time was 58 minutes. I feel it should not have been that hard, and I was strangely stupid while doing it. But at least I finished correctly after yesterday’s miss. I understood most of the cryptics, too, although I had no idea what an ‘English bond’ is.
The location of US state capitals has two purposes: to be near the geographical center of the state, and to establish a separate city where only government business is conducted. I believe the original idea was to avoid the corruption that might occur if the capital was located in the same city where all the businesses are. There are obvious exceptions, like Boston and Atlanta, which predate this practice.
A minor quibble – ‘marriage’ rather than wedding is the sacrament (I’m taking ‘perhaps’ to be an indication of definition by example rather than an acknowledgement of the looseness of the clue). I wasn’t enamoured of the BETA clue either. COD to TALK SHOW.
Although spectacular Striding Edge is the more famous of the approaches to Helvellyn from the east, it is said that more accidents occur on its northern counterpart, Swirral Edge, as walkers lose concentration on their descent. A magnificent walk in all seasons.
Another unknown building term, some unfamiliar geography and I never understood what “faith” was doing in 3dn.
However the thing that really slowed me down was my complete inability to see STRICKEN IN YEARS, which was one of my last in.
I blame Cantonese, which makes no distinction between the two woolly beasts.
Edited at 2011-02-09 09:03 am (UTC)
When I ran out of time on the commute the RH was complete but I still had lots of gaps on the LH and I cheated to get MUSTARDSEED, ANATOMIST, DIASPORA and MAGE. BETA, DAMSEL and SHY then went in when I had all their checkers.
I’m afraid this puzzle exposed far too many gaps in my GK. I don’t think there have ever been so many in one puzzle before. Amongst these were ENGLISH BOND, DAMSEL (fly), BURTON (someone I’ve never heard of clued as an anatomist not because he was one but because he wrote a book with “anatomy” in the title which I’ve also never heard of), DIASPORA, STRIDING (as a place in the Lake District) and MUSTARDSEED (as a particle of faith, though I should have got it from the MSND reference).
Writing CHAT SHOW at 4dn didn’t help either.
That’s three DNFs without cheating for me so far this week and I’m blogging on Friday!
And as for STRICKEN IN YEARS, I’ve never heard the phrase.
Mike O.
Matthew: Another parable put he forth unto them, saying, The kingdom of heaven is like to a grain of mustard seed, which a man took, and sowed in his field …
I read a lot of fiction books but I gave up reading the bible when I was old enough to say no to my parents with regard to church attendance. My father was a sidesman and my mother played the organ!
Mike O
Perhaps the setter had half an eye on the KJV anniversary this year: this was definitely one where familiarity with the 1611 text was useful. Maybe the days when the Bible and Shakespeare were automatic choices are gone. What common repositories can be assumed, then?
Burton I knew as Richard the actor or the “explorer, translator, writer, soldier, orientalist, ethnologist, spy, linguist, poet, fencer and diplomat” (thanks, Wiki). Lots of -ists to chose from, but apparently neither dissected bodies or, as it turns out, melancholy. Robert Burton’s work is somewhere in a dusty corner my repository, but only as a quaint title.
I thought DAMSEL was rather oversupplied with cryptics, generous but confusing.
Striding Edge I remember from CCF days, seeing it after what seemed to me to be a long march up Helvellyn and thinking a) that looks a bit dodgy and b) I’ve walked far enough already. I declined the option to stride, or even stroll round it. Maybe one day I’ll have a go.
Cod to BETA, with a side order of TALK SHOW
20 minutes with the long 5D proving to be very illusive and my last in. With IN YEARS guessed from checkers eventually saw through the wordplay to arrive at an unknown phrase. Surmised it probably had a biblical connatation. A little surprised by the ignorance of Burton’s Anatomy.
Anyone (including some on this blog) who knows me knows I’m the anti-theist from Hell. But at our age, it must be impossible not to know some details of what tzaneria calls ’a lot of fiction books’. And, as z8b8d8k asks: ’What common repositories can be assumed, then?’ So: as far as crosswords are concerned, these things aren’t christist by strict creed. Just the stuff we grew up with. Even the great Darwin had only one formal qualification: in Theology.
Not my sort of thing at all, I can occasionally get bible references but these were way beyond my ken.
I’ve a lot of sympathy with criticisms above; but many thanks, mctext, for yet another fine blog.
This would appear to be the irreducible “size” of a proton or neutron, or collection thereof. Yang-Low seems to ring a bell.
STRICKEN IN YEARS was gettable from the wordplay, just about, but I agree with the other complainants about MUSTARDSEED. I think we should send it off to the TLS where it belongs.
Sat sitting as I am in West Yorkshire I spotted
we)ST RIDING straight away but didn’t put it in as I’m not familiar with the Lake District bit. I blame Rory McGrath.
My father was a quantity surveyor and gave me valuable instruction in the difference between English Bond and Flemish Bond when I was building stuff with Lego (TM).
I made life much more difficult for myself by putting in BARE BONE as the irreducible minimum, thus making the already tricky 3d impossible for a while.
I quite like an occasional puzzle from the rectory hearth. The intellects I most admire, believers or not, are nearly all well-versed in sacred texts among much else (I’m thinking of people like the great Paddy Leigh Fermor who will, I believe, be ninety-six this week, just by the by).
For interest, I also note that the AV is the authority for “stricken in years” – it doesn’t appear in (my edition of) Chambers and I couldn’t see it in Collins on line. Mustard seed isn’t in there either, as one word or two. AV has “grain of mustard seed” in the most appropriate passage.
What is the authority these days?
http://bible.cc/joshua/13-1.htm
On another topic, since Striding Edge is presumably sic, I thought convention would require a capital E for Edge in the clue.
>On another topic, since Striding Edge is presumably sic,
>I thought convention would require a capital E for Edge in the clue.
Interesting point. IMO it’s acceptable because the word “edge” can be used without a capital E to mean a ridge. I can see that purists could argue that “Striding” shouldn’t properly be separated from its “Edge”, but in casual conversation one might talk of tackling Helvellyn “going up Striding and down Swirral” (or vice versa), so I think we should give the setter the benefit of the doubt.