Solving time: 45 minutes
This was a bit on the challenging side, requiring good general knowledge and some tricky clue parsing. There are some easy clues that let you get started, but you won’t be finishing unless you know a few uncommon words.
Music: Ravel, Daphnis and Chloe, Monteux/LSO
| Across | |
|---|---|
| 1 | PINETUM, PINE + [s]TUM[p]. My first in, and even if you don’t know the word, the cryptic should point the way for you. |
| 5 | CLAMS UP, CLAM S[o]UP. Put in at once from the definition, as soon as I had the first letter. |
| 9 | GERMANIUM, GER(M[iniaturisation])ANIUM. I’ve seen this before, and was not fooled. |
| 10 | YOBBO, [h]OBBY backwards with O[ld] inserted. I wasted a lot of time trying to work in ‘booby’, but in the end it proved helpful because the correct answer had similar letters. |
| 11 | ACHES AND PAINS, anagram of A SPANISH DANCE. An apt anagram, but the last word is a simple anagram of ‘Spain’, so you are likely to be thinking along the right lines. |
| 13 | DRAGOMAN, DRAGO(M.A.)N. This may be difficult if you have never seen the word, although probably doable. |
| 15 | MOWGLI, MOW + G[ir]L + I. I have heard of him, although I have never read Kipling. They did have Classic Comics when I was a wee lad, fifty years ago. |
| 17 | ENAMEL, backward hidden word in [har]LEM A NE[w]. The clue provides more of a nudge than a good clue should. |
| 19 | STEENBOK, anagram of KNEE’S TO B[e]. An obscure beast and a tricky clue, this one may prove elusive. I thought it was only a partial anagram through most of my solve, but the penny finally dropped when I got the crossing letters. |
| 22 | TIME CONSUMING, double definition, one jocular. I found this quite hard, not knowing what to make of the clue. |
| 25 | Omitted, use the crossing letters and ping us if you’re still stuck. |
| 26 | ESCAMILLO, ESC + A MILL + O. Another character you may not have heard of, although the clue points strongly towards the plot of Carmen. I am getting wise to the computer keys the setters like to use, the other one being ‘alt’. |
| 27 | REARMED, REAR + MED. Stock elements in a somewhat novel arrangement. |
| 28 | NAIL SET, NAILS + E[mbezzlemen]T. Very smooth deceptive surface, fine clue. |
| Down | |
| 1 | Omitted, use the crossing letters, this should be easy |
| 2 | NIRVANA, VAN in anagram of IRAN. Not immediately obvious to me, but it should have been. |
| 3 | TRASH, T[ime] + RASH. Another fine surface reading that makes the clue a bit difficult to parse. |
| 4 | MAINSTAY, MAINS + TAY. ‘Mains’ is a UK term, and the Tay is a Scottish river, so overseas solvers may have to think a bit. |
| 5 | CEMENT, C[rat]E + ME[a]NT, where ‘to conceal a’ means ‘take out the A’, and the literal is simply ‘binder’. |
| 6 | ASYMPTOTE, A(SYMPTO[m])TE. My last in, really quite difficult. I knew where I was going, but had to work through all the signs of the zodiac first before trying other meanings of ‘sign’. Not a word that comes up much in conversation, either. |
| 7 | SIBLING, IS upwards + BLING. Should be easy for most solvers. |
| 8 | POOH STICKS, HOOP backwards + STICKS. George has nailed it, I wasted all my agonising over the wrong element of this answer, being mislead by the bridge that is used on the pool table. |
| 12 | ADVENTURER, ADVENT + URE + R. Another starter clue for you. |
| 14 | OPERCULUM, anagram of RUM COUPLE. This is far from a starter clue, I had to scour my brain for this word. It is not what I thought it was, either, but at least I got the answer right. |
| 16 | ETRUSCAN, TRUE SCAN with the ‘E’ moved to the front. This language often appears, but we are still waiting for Oscan. |
| 18 | ARMENIA, AR(MEN)IA. I carelessly put in ‘Austria’, but saw my error almost at once. Trying to be a speed solver just slows me down. |
| 20 | BIGGLES, BIG + anagram of LEGS. I had no idea he was a pilot, so just went with the cryptic. |
| 21 | UNDEAD, UNDE[r] + A[wkwar]D. An excellent clue, with a good surface and fresh wordplay. |
| 23 | IAMBI, BAMBI with a different first letter. I do not like the clues where one letter is just changed arbitrarily, they are a bit too loose for my taste. |
| 24 | MOOT, MOO + T[emperature]. Used as a verb, where the definition is ‘to raise for discussion’. |
Needed wordplay to get PINETUM, SCAMILLO, OPERCULUM and NAIL SET.
Vinyl, I think 8 down is POOH STICKS from the A.A. Milne stories (I put it in from definition, but it fits your wordplay with HOOP instead of LOOP).
Also in without complete understanding ASYMPTOTE (a word I do use regularly) and YOBBO.
Back to the crossword, as Vinyl points out, a lot of tricky stuff to go with the gimmes. NAIL SET was a guess (my DIY skills are dismal) as were STEENBOK, DRAGOMAN, GERMANIUM and ASYMPTOTE. Ran out of steam in the NW corner, getting fixated on ‘yen’ for long (somehow, ‘pine’ must have seemed unlikely as a result of having conifer elsewhere in the clue), before trying to justify ‘lengthy’ – not for ‘long’, though. Also needed to resort to aids for the clever MAINSTAY; after all of which, I finished with PAGE. COD to CLAMS UP. Very tasty.
I agree about Bambi/iambi type clues in general, but ‘animated creature’ seemed to me specific enough that I didn’t mind.
Everything except PINETUM was known (if not exactly familiar), perhaps from years of doing barred crosswords. Apart from 23 where I agree with Vinyl1’s comment I liked the clues of the short words especially TRASH and MOOT.
Pieman
There was rather too much technical stuff today for my poor brain but I also struggled with the name of the toreador at 26 which should have gone in very much earlier as I had spotted the reference to Carmen immediately on first reading.
I can understand the grumble about unspecified letter replacements, but would like to suggest a couple of mitigating circumstances in this case: First, the letter concerned is checked. Second, if you’re going to replace the B in Bambi and finish up with a real word, there seems to be only one possible choice. I have no idea whether the Times crossword editor takes either of these into account.
There is an unusual amount of tricky vocabulary in here: PINETUM, GERMANIUM, HOBBY, DRAGOMAN, STEENBOK, ESCAMILLO, NAIL SET, ASYMPTOTE, OPERCULUM, IAMBI. Some of it I knew, some of it I didn’t, but there must be something in here to trip up most people I’d have thought. Fortunately the wordplay was clear (if tricky in places) and I was relieved and surprised to find I hadn’t made any mistakes.
ESCAMILLO was a frustrating presence throughout my solve because I got the Carmen reference immediately but couldn’t remember his name.
POOH-STICKS I have played many a happy time – living in Bourton-on-the-Water helped, where there were many appropriate bridges. For memory’s sake, it’s my CoD
There’s some very good cluing here because the obscurities can be derived from wordplay. I even knew the literary and operatic characters – it made up a little for golf being frozen off yet again.
The result was an abject failure on my part. Well over two hours with much use of aids to get all the words I didn’t know, which almost seemed to outnumber the familiar ones.
Well blogged Jonathan – I’m very grateful it wasn’t my turn.
Yours untruly, Erich von Stalhein.
1dn is omitted, so the answer is presumably PAGE, since to page someone is to call them, but what’s all that stuff about seeking a knighthood? And 22ac I can’t understand either: OK it’s taking too long, but lunch?
It’s been noted by others before on this blog, and I’ve noticed a few others over the years that weren’t commented on here.
Rob
but you are, however, a little late