The received wisdom (which I believe we are told to ignore by the Crossword Editor) is that Monday puzzles, if not always easy, tend to the easier end of the spectrum, but that Bank Holiday puzzles can be especially tough. As they can’t both be true, perhaps we should listen to the editor’s advice. Even if today’s was quite a gentle opener for the week, which this deputy was once more happy to see.
There again, this may be one of those puzzles where the knowledge required was stiffer than anything demanded by the wordplay: my time (not recorded exactly, but <15 minutes) was helped on more than one occasion by dragging half-forgotten knowledge from the lumber-room of my memory, and I may have been lucky that it chimed with me – others may have been undone by their lack of familiarity with such diverse subjects as cricket, the Savoy Operas, chess, Jane Austen, and musical theory. Much more from the humanities than the sciences, of course, which suits me, but will not please all…
Across | |
---|---|
1 |
ARCH – ( |
3 | METHODICAL – THO’ in MEDICAL. |
9 |
TRANSIT – TRA( |
11 |
PHALANX – [H( |
12 | PEA SOUPER =”P. SUPER”. A London particular is one of the especially bad fogs/smogs that may be remembered by any solvers who pre-date the Clean Air Act of 1956. |
13 |
OUGHT – ( |
14 | PUT THE BOOT IN – PUTT,HE,BOO!,TIN. |
18 |
FRANKENSTEIN – FRANK + E( |
21 | OILED – sOcIaLnEeD; I carelessly wrote in CANED at first, which may explain why the SW corner was the last to fall. |
22 | HERBALIST – (THEIRLABS)*. |
24 |
FUNFAIR – F( |
25 |
OVERRUN – O( |
26 | HARTEBEEST – (BARESTEETH)*; the hartebeest is not a gnu. |
27 | METE =”MEAT”. |
Down | |
1 | ANTIPOPE – TIP in A NOPE; perhaps it’s picky, but I’m not sure that an Antipope is necessarily less holy than the actual Pope, he just has an alternative claim. After all, there have been several Popes whose behaviour was reportedly less than exemplary. |
2 |
CHAPATTI – CHA + PATTI( |
4 |
EAT UP – EA( |
5 |
HYPERBOLE – Y( |
6 | DIATONIC SCALE – cryptic def.: the key to this was remembering from long-ago piano lessons that “accidentals” had a musical meaning to do with sharps and flats. I expect one of the more skilled musicians round here can explain the principle more helpfully to the layman, if required. ETA. As pointed out by anon., this is also an anagram of I,O,ACCIDENTALS, which makes it a fantastic &lit. Brilliant and yet so subtle I didn’t even notice it! |
7 | CHARGE – triple def. |
8 | LAXITY – X in LAITY. |
10 | SMOTHERED MATE – I’ve found various ways of losing at chess in my life, but never this one, as far as I can remember. As the wiki entry demonstrates, it’s delivered by a knight, and thus not a bishop. |
15 | BUNTHORNE – BORNE round (HUNT)*; from somewhere in the recesses I recalled that Bunthorne’s Bride is the alternative title of Patience, and the answer leapt immediately to mind. |
16 | DEMIURGE – DEMI + URGE gives the Creator in Greek. |
17 | INSTANCE – IN STANCE as a batsman at the crease would be while waiting for the bowler to deliver. |
19 |
LOOFAH – A in [LO OF H( |
20 | ELINOR – ELI + NOR gives Ms Dashwood, the heroine (and “sense”) of Sense and Sensibility. |
23 | ROOTS – ROTS round O. |
And talking of the 1950s, I thought the definition for PEA SOUPER very clever. So, cobwebs dusted out of the brain, I’m off to enjoy the bank-holiday sunshine.
Particularly liked ‘Frankenstein’
Last in DEMIURGE. COD DIATONIC SCALE – brilliant stuff; hats off to anyone who figured out the wordplay unaided by crossing letters.
Re 24 I never knew biassed as an alternative spelling.
Didn’t really understand ELINOR or BUNTHORNE before I loked them up later but the wordplay was clear and I was confident they were correct. Not quite convinced by 27ac.
Completed in about 35 minutes, but completely missed the subtlety of DIA…SCALE. COD to FRANKENSTEIN, despite my not knowing of Mary Shelley’s anniversary whilst solving!
Harder than Saturday’s I thought.
Tom B.
I did like the rest, ‘antipope’, ‘frankenstein’, and ‘smothered mate’ were very clever.
I had to solve on line, for as expected the shared printer has no ink. When you print something, you are left with a piece of paper as blank as when you started.
but got there in around an hour!
thank you setter
40 minutes in two sessions. Liked FRANKENSTEIN a lot and LOOFAH and PHALANX
which I got right away.
Having checked throught the puzzle I see I made an irritating error by writing ELENOR at 20dn in spite of understanding the clue in full.
A very good puzzle I thought and an enjoyable way to wind down after a hectic bank holiday Monday. 6dn is brilliant and like others I didn’t spot the anagram.