Solving time: 30 minutes
Another two-parter. About 15 minutes for most of it, and then 15 minutes for the last three, and I didn’t make it easy for myself either. A wrong spelling for ‘ukulele’ and an ‘O’ that looked like a ‘P’ really killed my time. However, I was able to put my anagram theory for place-names to good use, even though it would have been a lot faster to have heard of that football team.
Music: Van Morrison, Astral Weeks
Across | |
---|---|
1 | KILMARNOCK, anagram of NORMAL inside KICK. This was an unknown target for me, so I had to solve it blind. I could see how the cryptic worked, and I had the crossing letters. Since many Celtic place names start with ‘Kil’, putting the ‘I’ at the beginning seemed right. That left only one place for the ‘O’, leaving ‘M’ and ‘R’. Now if it had been KILRAMNOCK, the ‘M’ would have become ‘N’ by assimilation, so it must be KILMARNOCK. Bingo! |
9 | NIGHTIE, NIGH + TIE. Elusive because of the order, otherwise not difficult. |
10 | METHANE, anagram of THE NAME. |
12 | PANELLISTS, PA(NELL IS)T’S. I was fearing something dreadfully topical that would require knowledge of UK game shows, so this came as a relief. |
13 | DOT, double definition, both a bit old-fashioned and out of use. |
15 | OLD HAT, double defintion. Since ‘Dolly Varden’ can refer to a railroad, a mountain range, a trout, or a Dickens character, there are plenty of possibilties here. I rather suspect the setter only knew the hat. I was trying to solve P _ D _ A _ for quite a while before I saw my error. |
16 | CLAYMORE. C(LAY M)ORE. Just banged in from the literal by me, so I had to examine the cryptic for the blog. |
18 | UMBRELLA. UMBR(ELL)[i]A. Another easy one. |
20 | CHIDER. C(H)IDER. Spotted early from the literal, which has been used before. |
24 | IN THE BLACK, double definition. Yes, this undertaking is profitable. |
26 | UKULELE. UK + U + LE + LE. I carelessly put in ‘ukelele’, a spelling that does seem to have gained a foothold, even though etymologically incorrect. I had to fix this to get ‘banquet’, of course. |
27 | ADAMANT, A + DAM + ANT, a legendary rock whose name has become a generalized adjective. |
29 | DEPORTMENT, DE(PORT)(ME)NT. |
Down | |
2 | LAGGARD, DRAG GAL backwards. ‘Drag’ and ‘draw’ are the first words you should try for something like this. |
3 | AT THE SAME TIME, anagram of SHE AND I MET MET. Obvious from the enumeration. |
4 | NEEDLE, NEED + LE. A bit tough for me, I was looking for a word that meant either swindle or party for the first element. Literal is the full phrase, ‘to be irritating’. |
5 | CAMISOLE, CAM + I + SOLE. Literal again is inadequately concealed. |
8 | SWEETHEART. S(W)EE THE ART. Used before, and not so long ago, I recall. |
11 | TO SAY THE LEAST, anagram of [w]E STAY AT HOTELS. I don’t like the literal in this one, but the idea is clear enough. |
14 | NO SUCH LUCK, anagram of COUCH, SLUNK. The juxtaposition of the anagram words is a bit too obvious to fool most solvers. |
19 | BANQUET, sounds like BANG + QUIT. I got this despite a wrong crossing letter, which I then corrected. |
21 | DICTATE, CID backwards + TATE. Two of the most frequently-used elements in cryptic construction. |
22 | PEDALO, P(ED)(AL)O. We have had this word recently as well. In order for the two boys to fit into the river, the river must have two letters, and there is only one such river! |
25 | STET. S + TET. ‘Tet’ is another essential bit of construction material that all solvers should know |
Adam Ant is a rock entertainer. Not so sure how legendary he is.
Barbara
That was just an inside joke, I am sure the correct explanation is exactly what I have posted. With the precision used by setters, ‘legendary rock’ cannot be used to indicate ‘legendary rock star’ – unless it’s Sunday!
Re TO SAY THE LEAST, I can accept this as a paraphrase of ‘to moderate terms’, but wonder what others feel about the use of ‘with’?
To Vinyl – you might want to fix the typo in 27ac.
I’d like to think the Adam Ant joke was intentional. I had a friend a few years back who knew Adam before he achieved his 15 minutes. I think his real name was Stuart. As a consequence, i still have a copy of Antmusic in my record collection.
The mistake – inventing LUGGARD for 2D and justifying it as LUG=pull,rev. of DRAG=dressed as a female so must match “girl” somehow.
Off to a bad start writing my first answer, IN THE BLACK, at 14dn. Both answers end with K so solving 28ac next did not draw attention to my error and it took me a while to realise why I was having problems continuing on that side of the puzzle.
I also spelled UKULELE wrong despite noticing that the first of the three Es in UKELELE was not accounted for in the clue so BANQUET remained unsolved for most of the session.
I also had problems in the NW until I thought of KIND at 1dn, then the football club came to mind and everything in that corner fell suddenly into place.
The final struggle was the 22dn/27ac intersection in the SE. I didn’t know the “legendary rock” reference so I wrote ADAMANT in without any degree of certainty.
45 minutes, but it felt like longer because I had three or four spells of about 5 minutes when nothing at all went in.
I’m not usually bothered by dodgy homophones but “bang quit” sounding like BANQUET is awful.
I can’t understand the problem with UKULELE – the word play could hardly be more laboured and obvious. KILMARNOCK the place has little to recommend it. Set in SW Scotland it is a product of the industrial revolution and has that appearance.
Things that I knew: (1) There are several spellings of ukulele so be careful; (2) Dolly Varden is a ladies’ accessory. Unfortunately that knowledge was insufficient as it caused me to bung in Old Bag.
Today’s crossword is a good example. For me, ‘Kilmarnock’ was straightforward and ‘obvious’, first in (I’m neither Scottish nor a football freak). Certainly didn’t need the tortuous exercise reflected above. However entering 6ac as ‘a son’ caused some problems; and the blog leaves out 7dn which links with 6ac.
I enjoy coming to this site, fortunately usually to check that I’ve got things right for the right reasons. Sometimes because I’m stumped and would like to be enlightened/educated (as well as entertained by the often witty comments). I’m old enough to remember the ‘Thet (sic) Offensive’ and its impact; I’m not sure that comments such as ‘Tet is another essential bit of construction material that all solvers should know’ are really helpful to those in my position.
I don’t always agree with the clues other people classify as easy, but in the context of a grid filled with the answers supplied in this report, today’s selection really are easy. And if like vinyl1 you’re a non-British solver, you have to work out Kilmarnock. The points about how it was worked out are the kind of things to think about when faced with an anagram for an unknown answer, so good advice.
If you’re old enough to remember the “tet offensive” (as spelled by ODE) then you don’t need to be told about it. But the blogger can’t guess your age and knowledge – for solvers under 30, it’s worth knowing that this snippet is one worth remembering.
If you have a question with an omitted clue, just ask. I am not sure if you are asking about 6ac and 7dn, but just in case…
6ac AS IS – A SIS(ter)
7dn SO AND SO (could be SO-SO ie indifferent)
I had “as on” for 6a which didn’t help. I’m with lennyco on the pronunciation of banquet.
15a Dolly Varden-This meant nothing to me. Should it have done?
1d I assume is kind -but in what sense does kind =character? It was a kind of meat? He was one of a kind?. Doesn’t quite fit.
Best offer on saving some time: split your available time into a couple of equal chunks a few hours apart. Forgetting ideas that led nowhere and just having a break can help a lot.
For “as on”, I’d emphasise the importance of being able to find a convincing def for a familiar phrase. I can’t see anything in the clue to define “as on” (nor a meaning for the phrase without something like “TV”). If you’ve got an idea based just on possible wordplay, it’s best kept as an idea only – if the checking letters match, then it’s worth a punt.