16 mins, so very middle of the road in terms of difficulty. That doesn’t mean I was familiar with all the vocabulary or knowledge required, but the wordplay on each occasion left me in little doubt about the fact that I was filling a gap correctly e.g. I could see that 19 across was an animal whose name I didn’t know, but having deduced it from the wordplay, I felt confident I’d got it right, even without having seen the word before.
Across |
1 |
QUANTUM LEAP – [A N(orthern) TUM] in PLAQUE*. If I remember correctly, this meaning of “corporation” i.e. a pot belly, or a quite literally growing body, usually catches out lots of people who’ve never seen it before. |
7 |
CAP – PAC(k)rev. |
9 |
MATRICIDE – R.I. C.I.D. in MATE. |
10 |
AGGRO – G(eorge)R(ex) in AGO. |
11 |
INCENSE – double def. i.e. incense would incense a Low Church worshipper. |
12 |
TARNISH – TARN IS H(ard). |
13 |
LEMUR – LE + (RUM)rev. |
15 |
deliberately omitted |
17 |
ELDERSHIP – Tree= ELDER, bark = SHIP (always good to see the word “possibly” inserted to head off those of us who don’t like definition by example). |
19 |
POTTO – POT + TO; as I said, I didn’t know this species of lemur, but the wordplay was pretty clear. |
20 |
PITIFUL – IF in [PIT U(sefu)L]. |
22 |
ORCHARD – CHAR in [O(ld) RD]. |
24 |
REEVE – double def. Again, I didn’t know the secondary meaning – a female ruff bird – but with checking letters R_E_E and the other definition, that scarcely mattered. |
25 |
SOB SISTER – B(oyfriend)S in (STORIES)*; I don’t think I’ve heard the expression before, but having seen what wordplay suggested it must be, I could see how it worked. I’m not sure who would be the archetypal sob sister, as most of the female columnists who come into my world seem to be far from sentimental, and much more of the Glenda Slagg persuasion. Arentchasickofem? |
27 |
DIM – as in DIM SUM (I like a steamed dumpling as much as the next man, but I have always passed on the chicken feet). |
28 |
HOORAY HENRY – HO(use) + [RAY in O. HENRY]. A fuller explanation of the nature of the Hooray Henry is provided, as ever, by a classic Monty Python sketch. |
|
Down |
1 |
QOM – Quartering Only Muslims. |
2 |
AZTEC – z in A ‘TEC; not sure how London’s first and greatest consulting detective would have reacted to being referred to as “a ‘tec”; possibly by saying “You have been in the United States, I perceive”. |
3 |
THINNER – double def. |
4 |
MAIDENISH – MAIDEN + (HIS)*. |
5 |
EVENT – VEN(erable) in E.T.; as I observed last time it occurred in one of my puzzles, the film may be an overused one, but to be fair, the setter probably isn’t going to get much mileage from trying to incorporate Those Magnificent men in Their Flying Machines into a word. |
6 |
PRAIRIE – R(uns) in PAIR + I.E. |
7 |
COGNISANT – (Religio)N in (AGNOSTIC)*. |
8 |
PROPHETHOOD – PROP + (THE)* + HOOD. |
11 |
ILL TEMPERED – double def., being the opposite of this sort of music. |
14 |
deliberately omitted |
16 |
EUPHORBIA – B. in EUPHORIA; even someone as botanically unskilled as I am can remember this one, if only from previous puzzles. |
18 |
REFRESH – lots of abbreviations, REF. RE. S. H. |
19 |
PECKISH – 1 in PECK‘S H(orse). |
21 |
LASSO – LAS + SO. |
23 |
ACTIN – ACTIN(g). |
25 |
RAY – double def.: the electric version looks like this. |
I associate sob sister with the US and in particular people like Barbara Walters who anchored ABC News at the time of Princess Di’s death and was excruciating to my English ears.
Loved the &lit-ish qualities of 25ac. Seems to me that “bark” is OK for SHIP, so long as “possibly” is included thereafter. The problem DBE today is in 5dn: “relay” => EVENT.
mctext’s rule for the DBE: The name of the set may be used to define the name of one of its members; but not vice versa unless suitably signalled.
There will, no doubt, be comments on “breakthrough” => QUANTUM LEAP, with the sciento-literalists giving us mini-lectures on the magnitude of change involved.
You can bypass this by reference to the Sinclair QL (anyone remember that?) which was, in important ways, a breakthrough. Pity the Mac arrived about a month later!
I don’t think “bark” needs “possibly”, as the meaning of “bark” is simply “ship or boat”. It arguably needs an indication that bark is an archaic or poetic word, though “Tree bark once possibly held …” would look rather odd. I think the “possibly” in 17 is for “held by presbyter” indictating ELDERSHIP – I’m unsure whether a presbyter is necessarily an elder.
Agree with you on “bark”
“a sailing ship, typically with three masts, in which the foremast and mainmast are square-rigged and the mizzenmast is rigged fore-and-aft”.
Last in was reeve, known only from the Canterbury Tales, although I was only guessing at the estate manager and bird DD.
I remember the QL, but more as a break down than a break through..
(1) Could someone please go into more detail on 4dn for me? I saw the answer, but was not sure how manoeuvres came into it?
(2) What does it mean when the setter uses ellipses between two clues as in 4dn and 5dn today?
As always, thanks.
The dots at the end of the clue are a throw back to decades ago and these days can safely be ignored 999 times in a thousand. The two clues when read together should create a surface reading that sort of makes sense when each clue read individually makes little or no sense. Years ago they used to play all sorts of games with clues like this but that really no longer applies.
(2) In this case it means that the surface reading is the two clues run together as single sentence or phrase. As far as the cryptic reading goes, you can ignore the ellipses and treat the two clues separately. This is the most common situation with ellipses, but other things are possible – one of the two cryptic readings may include material on the other side of the gap.
2. In this case, the two clues joined by ‘….’ form a single surface, but each clue is in fact self-contained. However, that is not necessarily the case! Sometimes, a vital bit of for solving one part will be found in the other half. Remember, all’s fair and the setter is out to fool you, so consider ALL possibilities.
Modest = the definition, i.e a synonym of ‘maidenish’
over = the cricket term, requiring you to know that an over with no runs scored is a ‘maiden’
his manoeuvres = anagram of ‘his’
(Just for future reference, in these parts, you’ll sometimes find people referring to the word or words which are to be shuffled as the “anagrist” and the word indicating it’s an angram as the “anagrind”). As an anagrind, I’d say ‘manoeuvres’ is on the uncontentious side of things – just be on the look out for anything in a clue which suggests motion, or shuffling, or breaking up, and there’s every chance you’re dealing with a full or partial anagram.
As for the ellipses, the simple answer (today at least) is that it doesn’t mean much at all, it’s simply to smooth out the surface reading of those two clues, because 4 down in particular doesn’t really have much surface on its own. Adding the ellipses makes them look more like a real sentence, for what that’s worth. Be aware it can mean that there is a literal connection, but that’s probably more likely to be the case in an Araucaria-type puzzle than this one.
Despite feeling a little deflated at not getting anything in the top half in the first ‘across’ scan (funny how getting one early, especially a long one, helps with morale and speed) I managed to breeze through in six and a half minutes.
Hold on hold on: faster than PB? For the first (and probably only) time ever. I need to go and lie down.
The UK-centric ‘chinless wonder/hooray Henry’ and ‘aggro’ no longer pose any difficulties either.
It was actually ‘event’ that gave me the most trouble. I just could not remember ‘archdeacon’ = ‘ven’, and had to go through the alphabet and get it from the literal.
First in QOM which I knew as the site of Iran’s secret uranium enrichment facility rather than as a destination for Muslim pilgrims.
Should have got QUANTUM LEAP but couldn’t think beyond QUARTER ???? which I knew couldn’t be right because of the anagrist and how could it mean “breakthrough”?
Several words were new to me: POTTO, PROPHETHOOD, REEVE, SOB SISTER, EUPHORBIA and MAIDENISH.
Six or seven went in without full understanding, and at least four others were unknown words deduced from the wordplay alone.
All in all, quite glad to have been blogging yesterday’s and not today’s!
Only new word was SOB SISTER, but a few others I only meet in crosswords – POTTO, REEVE and ACTIN.
Enjoyable puzzle that made me think a bit more than some puzzles.
z8b8d8k asked if AGGRO had appeared before this year. Only just – 6th January.
7d and 16d seemed the best in a rather mediocre bunch.
I liked Midstream; with current having a misleading meaning in the surface reading.