21 minutes today, a time which on the surface suggests a puzzle of merely average difficulty; however, it was actually a combination of some pretty straightforward clueing (including some very hoary old wordplay amongst the short words), mixed with some quite obscure vocabulary which was rendered perfectly fair by the wordplay, some of which was first class. Overall I thought the strengths outweighed the weaknesses, and this was one of the most entertaining puzzles I’ve solved for blogging purposes. Q0-E9-D8
Across |
1 |
THEOSOPHY – HE in (TOYSHOP)*; I had no idea who Blavatsky was, and the word was one of those I knew without knowing the meaning, but I’d have thought checking letters and the SOPHY suffix ought to make it easily deduced. |
6 |
GET AT – GET A(partmen)T = “mean”. |
9 |
BANDEAU – AND inside BEAU; given the nature of the garment, it’s a somewhat saucy image. |
10 |
TRICEPS – TRICE + P(ower)S(upply). |
11 |
ROAST – R(ight) + OAST. This one gave me a Proustian rush back to my first attempts at cryptic crosswords (which were of a standard somewhat less demanding than the Times) several decades ago… |
12 |
RAINDROPS – R(oyal)A(cademician) + IN + DROPS (“no longer includes”). “Shower units” to mean “the constituent parts of a rain shower” was clever. |
14 |
GAS – double def. |
15 |
COBBLESTONE – BLEST ONE after COB; another clever definition in “part of the way”. |
17 |
BUFFER STATE – BUFF + E.R. + STATE; always good when a word such as “say” turns out to be a straight part of the clue, and not a suggestion that there is a double def. to be spotted. |
19 |
COL – COL(onel). |
20 |
THEREUNTO – (hous)E in THE RUNT + (w)O(lf). |
22 |
PARKA – K(ilo) in PARA(trooper). Palm to forehead time when I’d worked my way from PARGA (clearly doesn’t exist) to PARMA, and come up with any number of ways to justify that. Before spotting the obvious. |
24 |
ESCHEAT – ESC + HEAT; brilliant. I solve online, so the answer to “key characters” was literally staring me in the face at the top left of the keyboard. Not a word commonly used in my household, mind you, the common law relating to feudal tenure tending to be low on the list of conversational topics. |
26 |
RODRIGO – ROD + RIG + 0 gives you the Spanish composer, most noted for the piece featured in the film “Brassed Off” as Concerto de Orange Juice. Even though I had to fight to ignore the non-existent composer RODKITO who kept trying to work his way in. |
27 |
NASTY – ST(reet) in NAY. |
28 |
RED SPIDER – double defs requiring some knowledge of “English” billiards, to wit, that the three balls are the red, the white, and the spot; and that there is a special (long) rest for the cue called a spider. |
|
Down |
1 |
TABOR – TAB (f)OR, a sort of traditional drum. |
2 |
ENNEADS – NEA(rly) in ENDS; without the benefit of a classical education, I’d say this might be the trickiest word to deduce in today’s puzzle. |
3 |
SPECTACLE – SPEC(k)+TAC(k)LE. Very elegant. |
4 |
PAUL ROBESON – (OPENSLABOUR)*; becoming an &lit if you know the man was not just a singer but a political activist. I think he’d definitely be counted as “Old Labour”. |
5 |
YET – YE + T(ime). |
6 |
GRIND – G(ood)+RIND. Again “Hard outside” turns out to be a definition rather than an instruction; I had to get there via GRIST and GRIFT for no particular reason. |
7 |
TREMOLO – (LOT MORE)*. |
8 |
TUSK SHELL – TELL round USK + S(ave)H(abitat); after the much discussed wentletrap comes another marine mollusc which I’d never heard of. |
13 |
ILL FAVOURED – (OLDFURAVILE)*. |
14 |
GO BETWEEN – (BEGTO)* + WEEN; “ween” = old English for “to think, supose, i,e. fancy”. |
16 |
STEPPED UP – STEPPE + D.U.P. The Democratic Unionist Party was the creation of Ian Paisley and others. Not to be confused with the Ulster Unionist Party or the Popular Unionist Party (not to mention the Popular Front of Judaea or the Judaean Popular People’s Front). |
18 |
FRESCOS – [SOC(iety)+SERF] all rev. |
19 |
CARRIED – double def, took me far too long to spot that it was “bore” as in the past tense of “to bear”. |
21 |
ELEGY – E(venson)G in ELY. |
23 |
AMOUR – sounds like A MOOR; as always, those with regional accents are free to speak up if they think it doesn’t. |
25 |
TOR – (ROT)rev. |
Helena Blavatsky 1831-1891 was the founder of the Theosophical Society (thank you Wiki). A tad obscure? Along with ENNEADS, BANDEAU, ESCHEAT, and TUSK,SHELL quite a collection of trivial pursuit answers. ENNEADS and ESCHEAT I knew from bar crosswords but the others were new to me.
However, I agree with Tim. It is a fun puzzle that kept me amused for 25 minutes and the fact that the obscurities could be derived from the wordplay is a credit to the setter.
Not so entertained as others for some reason.
COD to GRIND (le mot juste).
Instead, it was ‘frescos’ and ‘escheat’ that really threw me. There is nothing more annoying than putting in the right answer, in this case ‘frescos’.
My time was 40 minutes plus an hour for the last two. ‘Tusk shell’ proved the most difficult, since for some reason I omitted ‘k’ in my alphabet traversal.
At least I had heard of Madame Blavatsky, she was very well-known in the 20s, one of the forces behind The Wasteland.
There is nothing more annoying than putting in the right answer, in this case ‘frescos’, and then erasing it because you don’t see how the cryptic works.
Couldn’t find a youtube clip showing a spider rest in action, but here’s Steve Davis demonstrating a gizmo that can be “used as a spider” and confirming that it’s the height of the cue that makes it a spider rather than the number of legs.
I have one question:
What do comments like Q0-E9-D8 refer to?
I could hazard a few guesses, but that’s all they would be!
Thanks
Q = number of questionable items (usually a small number, happily)
E = marks for entertainment out of 10
D = level of difficulty, also out of 10
Not everyone believes in this system, so don’t take it as anything but another very personal view from the person concerned!
Thanks for clearing that up; had been mulling it over for days!
I’m not certain that the cryptic grammar of 3 works. The clue is saying: SPECK, TACKLE – when K’s come out for SPECTACLE, whereas it needs to be SPECK, TACKLE – when K’s come out – SPECTACLE or SPECK, TACKLE – K’s come out for SPECTACLE. Perhaps there’s another way of reading it to justify both ‘when’ and ‘for’, but I haven’t seen it yet.
Then had a real problem in the last pair of FRESCOES and ESCHEAT which both hoodwinked me. I wanted the latter to be ELEMENT.No complaints and some good clues alongside run of the mill sorts
At one point I actually considered ENNEADS but dismissed it partly because I never heard of it but mainly because I couldn’t get the wordplay to work. I was thinking NEA(r)inside ENDS which would require three-quarters rather than the stipulated half.
I may have met ESCHEAT before but it wouldn’t come to mind. I like to think I’d have thought of it if I’d had the missing checking letter. I should have got FRESCOS.
Did anyone else get held up by having CLOSE at 27ac? – it just about works as a double def.
Some really good surfaces made this one a pleasure. COD 9a BANDEAU
One Across Rock – Guildford electro-Goth legends The Osophy.
I look at this site daily and much enjoy it and the comments from the regulars. There must be many others like me who usually finish but sometimes have difficulty with the word play.
Barry J
I wonder how old you have to be to decscribe something as a gas these days – possibly Mick Jagger’s age, as I’m now being earwormed by “Jumping Jack Flash” At any rate, it sounds as if it belongs in the street speech of the sixties.
Step on the gas.
I think
Barry W