Solving time – in a few sessions, probably about 40 minutes.
All good fun. Struggled a bit after I’d got about half quite quickly – last two in took a while – 11 (MARTELLO) and 4 (SUBALPINE). No problem with 1 (CLIFFS): last night I’d arranged to go to Cliffs Pavillion in Southend, so the word was probably at the front of my mind.
Across
9 | S(TAT)ABLE – SABLE was straight in my mind, and TAT was probably there from the previous clue. |
11 | MAR,TELL,O – RAM reversed; William Tell,O=old. I don’t remember seeing this word before, so it took some time to unravel (last one in). |
12 | ATTILA (not ATILLA as I originally wrote) – sounds like A TILLER. |
13 | C([w]RITER)IA -spys is often CIA. |
17 | ALAR – hidden word. This was also new to me. |
19 | SEASON[g],A,L |
20 | R(EM)AKE – I don’t hear much talk of rakes and roués these days. |
21 | HIERATIC – sounds like HIRE ATTIC. |
24 | PEN(Z)ANCE |
25 | R(AND)OM or RA(NDO)M – I think I’ve seen a similar clue making use of both RAM and ROM in this way. |
Down
2 | LOTH(ARI)O |
3 | FATS,TOCK – Fats Waller and regular letters of ‘took cake’. I thought of FATS straight away, wasn’t confident because I didn’t know his first name. |
4 | S(U,BAL)PINE – U is the university, LAB is the party and SPINE is the ridge – took a while for all of this to come together. |
5 | THE POWERS THAT BE – I liked this – and not just because I got it quickly, but it certainly helps if the long ones come easily. |
6 | M(IL,IT)IA – I originally thought this was MIA (AIM reversed) with IL (the in Italian) and IT (Italian wine) inside. I don’t think that’s right as Italian is used twice, so I guess IT (Italian vermouth) is just wine. |
7 | RE(QUIT)AL |
8 | TEE,NA[g]GER |
14 | [s]INN(KEEP)ER – two different types of support in consecutive clues – I like it. |
16 | OX,Y,MORON – neat (!) clue. |
17 | AL,BAN,IAN – |
18 | ANTI-HERO. I initially thought of MALE-LEAD, thinking that Leander was unlikely to be lead by males, whatever that might mean. |
19 | ST,K,[h]ILDA – took a while, but popped up from some corner of my mind. |
I got held up for a while by having CLIFFY at 1ac (very Australian) before realising that Cliff is already a diminutive. It took me a while at 7dn to remember that Brazil has swapped the cruzeiro for the real. I expect 19dn will make George think of Melbourne rather than the Hebrides. I think 25ac is the first time I’ve seen alternative wordplay on offer!
A nice start to the week.
Pondered a pangram briefly, having seen Z X and Q, but decided that all of FGJV was unlikely in the remaining slots. 3D was the poorest effort in the corner – got confused with Waller the poet (Edmund). Good geographical accuracy at 19D where St K is the group of islands, not any one of them.
10, 17, 14 had wordplays seen before, but there was enough new stuff elsewhere.
So, a good workout for me.
GO, dumb-born book,
Tell her that sang me once that song of Lawes:
Hadst thou but song
As thou hast subjects known,
Then were there cause in thee that should condone
Even my faults that heavy upon me lie,
And build her glories their longevity.
Tell her that sheds
Such treasure in the air,
Recking naught else but that her graces give
Life to the moment,
I would bid them live
As roses might, in magic amber laid,
Red overwrought with orange and all made
One substance and one color
Braving time.
Tell her that goes
With song upon her lips
But sings not out the song, nor knows
The maker of it, some other mouth
May be as fair as hers,
Might, in new ages, gain her worshippers,
When our two dusts with Waller’s shall be laid,
Siftings on siftings in oblivion,
Till change hath broken down
All things save beauty alone.
bc
All kinds of good clues. I’ll single out REQUITAL and the great surface of TOMMY-ROT. Props to HIERATIC – a really good and uncontroversial (?) homophone clue. And to HEIRSHIP – for not being another homophone clue!
Edited at 2009-03-09 05:59 pm (UTC)
Good puzzle. 40 mins for me.
Michael H
The above may be the worst constructed sentence in the English language.
First, confidently write ATILLA (like Foggyweb did in the blog) at 12 making 7 down RE–L-AL. Second, while still thinking about where those bloody pirates could be, see an island beginning with STK and put in ST KITTS. Combine that with HE,IR,ARCH and you have a completely unsolvable corner. Way to go. Third, second-guess yourself on a perfectly-good answer, decide that the musical must be HAIR, since nothing is fitting RE–L-AL and look for —-H AIR, rendering two corners unsolvable.
So I fell for every trick in the book, and finally realised the mistakes in reverse order. 22 minutes, well-played.
Why are a bunch of islands named after a terrible footy team?
What do Attila the Hun and Winnie the Pooh have in common? The same middle name.
Well, it does, if you put it in the right place!
I quickly got Fats, never having heard of Edmond Waller.
I knew Martello from chapter 1 of Ulysses which begins in a Martello tower near Dublin. Fortunately the reference is in chapter 1 because I have tried to read it three times and have never got past page 50.
Tommy-rot was a favourite expression of my father’s. I don’t know if he picked it up during the war since it is unclear whether the derivation has anything to do with soldier tommies.
In his Slang Dict., Eric Partridge suggests possible connections with tommy=truck=wage payment by goods rather than cash (presumed to be poor-quality goods), or tommy=”bloody” – by way of the red uniforms of long-ago soldier “tommies”. (He also says that “Tommy Atkins” goes back to the early 19th C). None of which proves or stops your father having picked it up in the war – I’m sure it was much more common then than now.
I loved 25ac, never ever having seen before, to my recollection, a choice of wordplay for one solution 🙂
Not a difficult puzzle, but I was a long time over ‘militia’, believing I was looking for the name of a wine.
My COD: ‘subalpine’, tricky but fair.
There are 7 “easies” omitted from the blog:
1a Little chap’s view on sailing into Dover?
CLIFFS. Little chap presumably because CLIFF is short for Clifford? Not in the case of Cliff Richard as it is short for Harry Roger Webb.
5a Decline to be associated with musical – it’s rubbish! (5-3)
TOMMY-ROT. The musical based on The Who’s “rock-opera” album Tommy.
10a Commemorative tablet removed by dentist (6)
PLAQUE
15a House approved for curved spit of land (4)
HO OK. I only know of Hoek van Holland.
22a Line penned by English novelist with difficulty (6)
HARD L Y
23a Leading figure shaking up Interpol (3-5)
TOP-LINER. Anagram of INTERPOL.
15d He’s clued-up about Irish succession (8)
HE IR S HIP. I thought HIP was “with-it” in the fashion sense but here it infers that it can mean in-the-know?