Solving time: 27:18 (with two wrong)
Just as well the District Line was slightly slow this morning, or I would not have finished this before reaching work. And I might well have one wrong, as I am still not convinced by BLUE for 25D. (Actually I find I have two wrong – thanks to those who pointed it out. I have now corrected below: 25D which is BLOW rather than BLUE; and 28A which is WEST rather than EAST SUSSEX.)
The top, and especially top left was my main problem. Although I put in ROMP straight away, I had a (foolish) nagging doubt that the answer might be PROM, which helped to slow me up on 1D and 2D. As well as those, 3 and 12 across and 4 and 9 down took ages.
If difficult it was very good. The surfaces are excellent, and the approaches are interesting and varied. Going through marking up the clues to include in the analysis I found I had ticked every single one. So I have decided not to list the cryptic definitions at 1D and 18A.
Across
1 | ROMP, being PROM with the P moved to the end |
3 | AFTERDECKS – saw that it was DECKS quickly, but after needed the crossing F |
10 | ADHER(EN)CE, that is v(EN)t in REACHED* – it took me far too long to lift and separate “Sticking plaster” |
11 | VOCAL – reversed hidden |
12 | IS TH(M)US – for too long I was determined that only an N could fill I_T… |
13 | YE + OMAN |
15 | GET SOMEONE’S GOAT – (AMONGST GEESE TOO)* |
21 | T(RAJ)AN – the “off” is one of those unnecessary words to improve the surface. I am not sure it is entirely harmless here |
23 | FIVE-BAR, ie V(ide) in (A BRIEF)* |
26 | LE(I)T + H |
27 | SQUARE + CUT – clever to clue SQUARE by an example that looks like a newspaper |
28 | WEST’S U.S. SEX – ho-ho (corrected from EAST SUSSEX. Either works, but only one fits with the right answer to 25D.) |
29 | DO SH! |
Down
2 | MY HAT – took too long to see that the split before the two defs is just before the last word |
4 | FIN((s)ISTER)E |
5 | EL(E.G.)Y |
6 | DEVIO(U)S, ie U(rban) in VIDEOS* |
7 | COCK (A HO)OP |
8 | S(on) + ILK – held up by the cryptic definition and inability to think of a three-lettered word meaning “kind” |
9 | C+RAMBO – I put this in as a guess, and only as I typed it now saw how it works |
14 | A TA + STRETCH |
16 | TA(FF)R + AILS |
17 | NOSE-FLUTE – (STONE FUEL)* |
19 | ST JOHN’S – capital of Newfoundland and Labrador apparently |
20 | REV ‘ERE |
22 | N(EST)S |
24 | BUC + K.O., BUC being CUB(rev) |
25 | BLOW – two meanings (corrected from: ‘BLUE – it means “squander”, but I can’t see anything else’) |
For me this was the hardest for a while. Lots of tricky clues and plenty of smiles, and I especially liked 3, 26, 28 (shades of Bill Clinton) and 16.
Unusual to see “SOMEONE’S” in 15 rather than the usual “ONE’S”.
Just a couple of queries: I haven’t worked out the full analysis of REVERE at 20, and in 24 all the dictionaries I have checked give BUCKO as nautical slang, no reference to the Irish (although the answer was clear enough) – have I missed something?
50 mins all up – which makes it good value for money (like my golf – more strokes means more fun).
Dafydd.
TonyW
(e.g New York Times hack is shot (6-3)
Barbara
I’ve had that “new word learned in xwds suddenly appears in real life” experience several times.
“His bucko mate, GRUMBUSKIN, long since had disappeared,
For to the Bell at Hampton he had gone to wet his beard;”
It makes you wonder why Eliot bothered to write “The Waste Land” at all.
I messed up on ROMP, putting RAMP in desperation, and at 29 I didn’t spot the wordplay so was torn betweeen DOSH and MOTH which might have fitted if the purse’s owner happened to be miserly.
So about 45 minutes for most of it plus another 10 to finish it off with the aid of the internet on arrival at work.
Struggled with 3A in the same way as Richard, and wonder how much time anyone seeing post=AFTER would have saved by way of making FINISTERE much easier to pick out from the other 94 départements de France.
FLUE = fluff is appealing at 25D for those who know about it, but if it was the answer the clue would surely drop the “Use” and just be “Pipe for waste”. As far as I know, you can rely on the Times setters only using surplus words, like “off” in 21A, when they make a noticeable improvement to the surface meaning.
Harry Shipley
Edited at 2008-11-13 05:39 pm (UTC)
Harry Shipley
No: you need the “in” really. I don’t think “attending East End” is a very fair way of indicating what is meant in the cryptic reading: it’s too elliptical.
I agree on the east/west point.
Despite taking considerably longer than our esteemed blogmeister and most of the other contributors I did at least opt for the correct part of Sussex at 28a after using my pipe to BLOW at 25d.
There are just the 2 omissions:
15a What you get for speeding (but not corporal punishment!) (2-6,7)
GO-FASTER STRIPES. I’m not sure I follow this clue fully? Is there a connection between CORPORAL and STRIPES? Do only SERGEANTS and above have stripes or something like that?
1d Measure of progress with one’s first work, perhaps, in years (7,3)
READING AGE