Sunday Times 4472 (12 Feb 2012)

Solving time: 45:07

Since the ST has started publishing the setter’s name, I have, like many others I’m sure, gained a gut reaction to each name giving me an expectation of how much I’m likely to enjoy what follows. Indeed Jack made a comment to this effect a couple of weeks ago. I know I generally struggle to get on Tim Moorey’s wavelength, and his vocabulary often finds me wanting, so his name gives me cause for trepidation, while Dean Mayer’s I normally find tough but fair. But of the three setters, it is Jeff Pearce’s name that I look forward to the most. I nearly always find his offerings the most enjoyable to solve. Of course, this is a personal observation and others will doubtless disagree.

I did enjoy this one, as I expected to, despite rather a proliferation of double and cryptic definitions – six in total. These often seem the weakest of all the clue types available to the setter, but most of these ones seemed to work quite well. 11 would be one of my contenders for COD. This honour has to go to the rather neat &lit at 4d, though, narrowly beating 7 which was only slightly spoilt by the similarity of COACH to COUCH.

Keep it up, Jeff. Long may you continue.

cd = cryptic def., dd = double def., rev = reversal, homophones are written in quotes, anagrams as (–)*, and removals like this

Across
1 AMO + S – I only did one year of Latin at school before I was able to drop it in favour of something (anything) else, but I remember conjugating the verb ‘to love’ – AMO, AMAS, AMAT, etc. The Book of Amos is the oldest of the prophetic books of the Old Testament.
4 SEER + SUCKER
9 ASS + AI + L
10 UN + COUP(L)E – I’d not come across a COUPE, being a dessert similar to a sundae, as opposed to a COUPÉ, being a style of car.
11 CLOSE SHAVE – dd – I liked this one.
14 HOOK – dd – Captain Hook was Peter Pan’s enemy, and a hook shot in cricket is a stroke played behind the batsman on the leg side.
15 TELETHON – cd, i.e. a charity event shown on the (television) set.
17 AGOUTI = GOUT in (A + I)
18 STUPOR = (PROUST)*
20 LAY WASTE = LAY + W + A + (SET)*
22 FA(W)N
23 AND SO FORTH = (SORT OF HAND)*
25 CLUBBING – dd – the first of which is ‘gathering’ as in clubbing together, although I can’t recall having come across clubbing on its own in this sense.
27 LEAD + IN
29 F + RIGHTENED
30 PAGE – dd
Down
2 MO + SELL + waitrosE
3 SPAin
4 SALTS – &lit – Salts, as in sailors, are a vital part of any ship. The wordplay is ALT (computer key) in SS. Very neat.
5 EMUlate
6 SECRETARY = (SECRET + RY) about A
7 COUCH POTATO = (OUT + TOP COACH)* – Separation required on ‘slob out’
8 EELPOUT = (TOUPEE)* about pooL
12 SLEEPING BAG – cd
13 ANNE + LID
16 HERB + A + LIST – madder being a herb.
19 TRAILER – dd
21 TAT + TIN + G
24 sOILED
26 GINa
28 ASP – hidden in cleopatrAS Poisoning

5 comments on “Sunday Times 4472 (12 Feb 2012)”

  1. 15′ to get everything but 4d, 5′ to get that. I never had Latin (that’s why I’m not a judge), but the clue would work for Portuguese or Spanish, not to mention that the 3 singular forms show up all too often in the NY Times. ‘of the joints’ seemed an unnecessary kindness on the setter’s part.
  2. I’ve mislaid my copy at the moment so may add comments later if I find it. I know this took me about 50 minutes and I can’t recall any major problems with it.

    As for your comments about setters there’s only one that fills me with dread and in consequence I suffered again this Sunday (19th). In fact, coming on top of the Saturday puzzle (18th) I wonder why I continue to bother. I have spent 4 hours this weekend beating my brains out on puzzles I had no hope of ever solving without considerable resort to aids, and to me that’s not the point of doing them. If I wanted that, I would do Mephisto and other puzzles where one knows before one starts that the bar is going to be set extremely high.

    1. Found my notes now. The only one that gave me grief was 16dn although the answer was fairly obvious once all the checkers were in place. I didn’t know ‘madder’ as a herb nor ‘list’ as a border despite looking the word up recently with reference to jousting tournaments, a meaning that also caught me out.
  3. I finished this OK but there was a lot I didn’t really get. I put SALTS in from definition alone. Only now can I appreciate how clever it is. I couldn’t see LIST as “border” although HERBALIST was one of my first in. Whenever I see the word “madder” in a puzzle I think of the plant. (Probably because of my favourite limerick:

    When Titian was mixing rose madder
    His model reclined on a ladder
    Her position to Titian
    Suggested coition
    So he leapt up the ladder and ‘ad ‘er!

    That’s lowered the tone of this blog but it’s a goodie.)
    I didn’t see CLUBBING as a DD. I put in in from idea of gathering together to go “clubbing” on a Saturday night. I just didn’t associate “gathering” with “clubbing”. All in all, a bit of a struggle. 45 minutes.

  4. Just in case anybody is wondering?
    Old English liste “border, hem, edge, strip”

Comments are closed.