I found this one mostly quite approachable, but with three clues that I haven’t been able to explain to my full satisfaction. I don’t have an accurate time due to user error (and interruptions while solving, but mostly user error), but I’d guesstimate that this took about my average of 15:00.
The problem clues:
-
- The composer in 7a remains unidentified despite some cursory Google checking.
- I’m not happy with “rate” = “is assessed as” in 20a. I’m sure I’m on the right lines, but haven’t quite got there yet.
- Likewise with “tackling” as an inclusion indicator in 4d.
Today’s favorite clue is MEAN: you’ve got to love a three-word triple-definition clue.
I look forward to your comments on these and the other clues.
Definitions underlined, synonyms in round brackets, wordplay in square brackets and deletions in squiggly brackets.
| Across | |
| 1 | Son isn’t a very good person (5) |
| SAINT – S for son, AIN’T (isn’t). | |
| 7 | What might be playing Hart score? (9) |
| ORCHESTRA – (Hart score)* [what might be playing].
An &lit clue, as the whole of the clue is both the definition and the answer. I biffed this one, not knowing of a composer called Hart. The first Google hit for “Hart composer” is Lorenz Hart, half of the Rodgers & Hart team that wrote multiple Broadway hits, but he doesn’t quite work because he was the librettist: he wrote the words, not the music. Doing more digging, the only composer called Hart I can find who doesn’t violate the “no living people” rule is James Hart, 1647-1718. But that seems unfeasibly obscure for the Quick Cryptic, so I guess I just don’t know what was in Joker’s mind here. |
|
| 9 | One who’s back in Poirot cast? (5) |
| ACTOR – Hidden [in] poiROT CAst reversed [back].
Our second &lit in a row. |
|
| 10 | Certain about including right individual blood type. Wrong (9) |
| ERRONEOUS – SURE (certain) reversed [back] including R (right), ONE (individual), O (blood type). | |
| 11 | Cannabis finally concealed for border (3) |
| HEM – HEM{p} (cannabis) with its final letter hidden [finally concealed]. | |
| 12 | List of appalling Conservative after Conservative (9) |
| DIRECTORY – DIRE (appalling), then TORY (Conservative) after C (Conservative). | |
| 14 | Dark and mysterious planet in far edge of universe (9) |
| SATURNINE – SATURN (planet), IN (errr, “in”), last letter [far edge] of {univers}E.
A word that I knew existed, but couldn’t confidently have defined. |
|
| 16 | What’s sticky Cajun soup giving out bad small (3) |
| GUM – GUM{bo} (Cajun soup), minus [giving out] BO (“body odour” = bad smell).
Edit: I didn’t even notice the typo here during the “solve & blog” process. But I’m confident that’s all it is: for “small” in the clue above read “smell”. |
|
| 18 | Sad following holiday problem with car? (9) |
| BREAKDOWN – DOWN (sad) after [following] BREAK (holiday). | |
| 20 | Your setter is assessed as very angry (5) |
| IRATE – I (your setter, from their point of view), RATE (is assessed as).
“I rate this as excellent” is a close relative of “This is assessed as excellent”. There’s probably a better example (the subjects and objects of the verbs don’t correspond in that example), but it’s close enough for me. |
|
| 21 | Increase of former unease? (9) |
| EXTENSION – EX (former), TENSION (unease). | |
| 22 | Sudden blow besetting European visitor (5) |
| GUEST – GUST (sudden blow), around [besetting] E [European, as in EU]. | |
| Down | |
| 1 | Go through fabric stiffener when time is key (6) |
| SEARCH – STARCH (fabric stiffener) with T for time replaced by E (a musical key). | |
| 2 | Glove in cold season without top temperature is on and off (12) |
| INTERMITTENT – MITTEN (glove) in {w}INTER (cold season without top), T (temperature).
You have to avoid the temptation to define ‘mitten’ as ‘glove in cold season’. |
|
| 3 | Runs in to adore stirring bullfighter (8) |
| TOREADOR – R (runs, cricket) in (TO ADORE)* [stirring]. | |
| 4 | More irritated tackling constant goal getter (6) |
| SCORER – SORER (more irritated) including C for constant.
‘Tackling’ is obviously being used as the containment indicator here, but I’m struggling to come up with a usage where “to tackle” could mean “to contain” or “to include”. Anyone? |
|
| 5 | Low average signal (4) |
| MEAN – an example of the lesser-spotted triple definition.
1) “That was a mean thing to do.” 2) “The mean value is…” 3) “But what does this gesture mean?” |
|
| 6 | Planet hot and ultimately very wet underfoot (6) |
| MARSHY – MARS (planet), H (hot), {ver}Y [ultimately]. | |
| 8 | What traveller takes proper food? (12) |
| THOROUGHFARE – THOROUGH (proper), FARE (food). | |
| 13 | Caught with penchant for housework (8) |
| CLEANING – C for caught (cricket), LEANING (penchant). | |
| 14 | Public transport turning up prepared for part of a group (6) |
| SUBSET – BUS (public transport), reversed [turning up] + SET (prepared). | |
| 15 | One mathematical figure regarded as symbolic (6) |
| ICONIC – I (one) + CONIC (mathematical figure, as in conic section).
Conic sections are the curved shapes you get when a plane cuts through a cone: ellipses, parabolas and hyperbolas (I looked it up). I last encountered these in O-level maths in 1984, and about the only thing I remembered is that a circle is just a special case of an ellipse. |
|
| 17 | Consequence of workers cutting vehicle test (6) |
| MOMENT – MEN (workers) inside [cutting] MOT (vehicle test).
The MOT test is the British annual test for roadworthiness of vehicles over a certain age: it was named after the Ministry Of Transport, which no longer exists, but the name stuck. |
|
| 19 | Tease about new style (4) |
| KIND – KID (tease) around [about] N (new).
kind = type = style. |
|
Congrats to those doing fast times and especially PBs today. We were well off the pace at 17:04 but IRATE was the only clue I assessed as puzzling. Thanks to Joker and Doofers.
DNF
Pretty straightforward, all done in 17 with LOI DIRECTORY. Unfortunately I failed to answer the clue as set and put starch for 1dn giving me a dreaded pink square.
Dnf…
16 mins – but also put in “Starch” for 1dn, which was annoying. An enjoyable puzzle though.
FOI – 1ac “Saint”
LOI – 4dn “Scorer”
COD – 16ac “Gum”
Thanks as usual!
Took 9:41, didn’t find it easy for a QC, LOI SEARCH