The one obscurity is gettable from wordplay; the potato discussion may rumble on; and any UK-centrism is fairly balanced, as noted below. Can I ask that if you put your time up, you say whether it is better than usual or the opposite? And do please comment if you can.
Across
1. Book tough defender on the pitch (8)
HARDBACK – Definition is book, a BACK is a defender in soccer and other games, HARD = TOUGH
5. Search for food? (4)
GRUB – A double definition, GRUB means to dig or search in the dirt, and is also a colloquial word for food.
8. Keep most important article in metal container (8)
MAINTAIN – MAIN = most important, A is the (indefinite) article in TIN = metal container. The word ‘article’ in a clue should trigger thoughts of either THE (definite article) or A (indefinite article). TIN, meanwhile, can be money, metal, element, backward idiot etc. etc.
9. Kitchen equipment from Coventry (4)
OVEN – C{OVEN}TRY – ‘from’ may be the trigger word for such a clue.
11. Girl associated with cider? One’s into wine (5)
ROSIE – From the famous book by Laurie Lee, concerning memories of his childhood, although some may have been embellished. One (I) into wine (ROSE). Clever surface to this clue, but how many other girls would you associate with cider?
12. Train former newspaper employees (7)
EXPRESS – An EXPRESS is a train (in some places and countries anyway; let’s leave aside the differences and avoid discussing infrastructure). EX- = former, PRESS = newspaper employees.
13. Minor rebuff (6)
SLIGHT – SLIGHT as an adjective means minor, SLIGHT as a noun is a rebuff, modern synonyms may be ‘blank’, ‘disrespect’ etc. A double definition.
15. First person to take artillerymen around fleet (6)
ARMADA – definition is ‘fleet’, as in the famous and ill-fated Spanish invasion force of 1688. First person is ADAM, artillery (useful crossword term) is RA for Royal Artillery, part of the British Army. ‘Around’ indicates a reverse, thus ADAM + RA reversed = ARMADA. Adam is the name given to the first person in Genesis, the first book of the Hebrew and Christian Bibles. Adam is formed by the Lord God from the dust of the earth (Genesis 2:7) – the ancient Hebrew word for humanity/man being adam, the word for dust being adamah.
18.Inside country house you’ll see an orchid (7)
VANILLA – V{AN}ILLA, VILLA being a country house (discussions on a postcard please – up here it’s a soccer team), with AN inside. It was news to me that VANILLA is an orchid; the name derives from the Greek for ‘testicle’, from the appearance of the ‘root-tubers’. This gives me a nice segue into 21ac.
19. Bet it’s a long time between start and end of war (5)
WAGER – a WAGER is a bet, a long time is an AGE, start and end of war = W—R
21.Underground root, not right for cylindrical container (4)
TUBE – The clue could be parsed as TUBER (underground root), minus the R (not right) = TUBE (cylindrical container). Or it could be parsed as TUBE (the London Underground (subway/metro) system); TUBE (root = TUBER, without the R); TUBE = cylindrical container – a triplet of indicators. Both parsings are nice, and valid, but only if you accept a TUBER as a root, which it isn’t – this has been the subject of much discussion on these pages.
22. Underwater explorer Edward turned away (8)
DIVERTED – An underwater explorer can be a DIVER (pace Tom Daley); Edward is sometimes shortened to TED. DIVER + TED = DIVERTED = turned away.
23. Head removed from shiny vegetable (4)
LEEK – {S}LEEK = shiny, head removed. Leeks, vegetables possibly similar in taste to onions, associated with Wales (in Henry V, Ancient Pistol is made to eat a raw leek).
24.Certainly not rare words of congratulation (4,4)
WELL DONE – words of congratulation = WELL DONE; in the cooking of meat, this is at the other extreme from ‘rare’. Nice distracters here as could spend a while thinking ‘Certainly not’ is the definition. See 4 down. If you should go to France, and you eat steak, it’s worth knowing the French terms: tartare (raw); bleu (just about sealed); à point (medium or thereabouts, but the French will be impressed as it means ‘just right’); and the Franglais ‘bien cuit’, which can mean ‘thoroughly’ or ‘well cooked’.
Down
1 Sound of funny bone (7)
HUMERUS – Haha, a homophone for humorous, a bone in the upper arm. Incidentally, ‘humorous’ is spelt the same way in British and US English, despite the differences in humo(u)r.
2. Defeats Republican in US manoeuvres (5)
RUINS – R (for Republican) + an anagram (manoeuvres) of ‘in US’. It’s too serious to be flippant about this.
3. Dutch gambler having modest amount of ale? (6,4)
BETTER HALF – Definition is ‘Dutch’ = wife in cockney slang (probably from duchess) = BETTER HALF – jocular or serious term for spouse. BETTER = gambler; HALF = ‘modest amount of ale’, as in half pint. Undoubtedly my COD (clue of the day).
4. Shout about former president’s goodness (6)
CRIKEY – Definition is ‘goodness’ as in the exclamation, a mild oath or expression of surprise, derived from ‘Christ’. cf COR, MY. We have CR{IKE}Y – CRY = shout, about IKE, Dwight D. Eisenhower, 34th US President 1953-6.
6. Disorganised, I arrive in holiday area (7)
RIVIERA – anagram (Disorganised) of ‘I arrive’.
7. Initially brassed off with students getting extra money (5)
BONUS – ‘extra money’ = BONUS; ‘Initially brassed off’ = BO (first letters of words) + NUS (National Union of Students).
10. We helpers arranged to install a car part (5,5)
SPARE WHEEL – Anagram (arranged) of ‘We helpers’ including (to install) A = SPARE WHEEL.
14. Mean US soldier lifted old coin (7)
IGNOBLE – Definition is ‘mean’. This is a down clue, so ‘US soldier lifted’ is G.I. reversed = IG, + NOBLE, an obsolete gold coin.
16. Reduce size of brigade after reorganisation (7)
ABRIDGE = ‘reduce size of’, anagram (after reorganization) of ‘brigade’. Nice surface to this clue, but ‘reorganisation’ sets off alarm bells.
17. Some brought a gin, especially for N. African stew (6)
TAGINE – Sometimes in crossword land you have to take the wordplay and make a word you’ve never heard of, as in this case for me. Thus we have ‘Some’ (indicating an extract) of BROUGH{T A GIN E}SPECIALLY = TAGINE, a North African/Berber stew named for the pot in which it is cooked, also known as tajine, marqa or maraq. You can buy a posh cast iron tagine (pot) for £140, but it won’t be authentic as they should be made of earthenware.
18. Five Italians, not half lively (5)
VITAL = ‘lively’. V = five in Roman numerals, appropriately + ITAL (Italians not half). If this were clue number 17 I could digress about why Italians believe 17 (XVII) is unlucky.
20. Annoy husband leaving densely populated area (3,2)
GET TO = ‘annoy’; ‘husband leaving’ indicates losing the h for husband from G{H}ETTO, ‘densely populated area’, although the word has much uglier associations.
Whether this blog gets to you or pleases you, please comment – all feedback is most welcome and can help others.
I must have missed or forgotten the discussion about roots and tubers as I was not aware of the controversy. Needless to say the dictionaries have the looser definition covered so any complaints need to go to the lexicographers rather than the setter.
Edited at 2016-10-07 12:49 am (UTC)
So let’s call it average.
Thanks Flamande and Rob.
Edited at 2016-10-07 08:17 am (UTC)
This took me 5 minutes which is my usual time. The 15×15 took 30 minutes today. It doesn’t seem 6 times harder but I can never get my time down substantially.
Did half the grid (right side) in about 15 mins. The anagrams helped and I got most of them quickly.
Then struggled with left side and especially nw corner.
Enjoyable though.
Tubers aside, nothing too controversial or too tricky.
And yes Rob, please digress away about why XVII is unlucky for Italians.
I thought this one was a pleasant stroll in the park, 11 minutes so well below my 20-25 average, and easy easier than yesterday’s DNF.
I couldn’t parse “crikey”, and still not quite convinced by it meaning goodness, but it fit the words too well to be anything else.
PlayupPompey
Ethel The Frog