The curse of the last clue struck again, and I gave up and clicked on the answer after a bit of an impatient stare at 17d. There’s little excuse for this when the clock is only at 8:30, but there we are: I apologise to the crossword gods and will endeavour to improve. (In my defence I will say I recently seem to have spent quite enough time staring at the last one or two clues, and there’s only so much self-improvement one can profitably attempt in an average week.) Good fun apart from that – many thanks to Pedro!
Across | |
1 | Youngster I start to lecture? (5) |
PUPIL – PUP (youngster), I, L (“start” to Lecture). An &lit clue where the whole clue is a literal definition, as well as the cryptic. | |
7 | I’m leading a lot of constables to capture it? Unwise (9) |
IMPOLITIC – IM ahead of POLICe (“a lot of” constables) capturing IT | |
9 | A visitor from Edinburgh, say, in Berkshire town (5) |
ASCOT – A SCOT (a visitor from Edinburgh, say) | |
10 | Elected tyrant, not the first time? That’s a sign (9) |
INDICATOR -IN (elected) DICtATOR (tyrant), without the first T(ime) | |
11 | Money fool returned (3) |
TIN – NIT (fool) returned | |
12 | Disorganised carpool is a sight to see in Athens (9) |
ACROPOLIS –anagram (disorganised) of CARPOOL IS | |
14 | Looking peculiar in soccer gear? Every chance! (5,4) |
SHORT ODDS – ODD (looking peculiar) in SHORTS (soccer gear) | |
16 | Pet fur has nothing removed (3) |
CAT – CoAT (fur), with O (nothing) removed | |
18 | Irrational character had gone wrong in the topic (3,6) |
MAD HATTER – anagram (gone wrong) of HAD in the MATTER (topic) | |
20 | Enough to taste? Not initially (5) |
AMPLE – sAMPLE (taste) “not initially” | |
21 | Matt rages after changing plan (9) |
STRATAGEM – anagram (after changing) of MATT RAGES | |
22 | One trap set around river still (5) |
INERT – I (one) NET (trap) around R(iver) |
Down | |
1 | Flying vehicle on flight, finally, for Mars? (6) |
PLANET – PLANE (flying vehicle) on T (flighT “finally”) | |
2 | Measure of importance under the mistletoe? (7,5) |
PECKING ORDER – cryptic hint: pecking = kissing | |
3 | Literary giant ruined pursuing legal action (8) |
LITIGANT – LIT(erary) and an anagram (ruined) of GIANT. Litigant as an adjective is litigating/engaged in a lawsuit. | |
4 | Arachnid runs underneath piano in bank (6) |
SPIDER – R(uns) under P(iano) in SIDE (bank) | |
5 | Forestall reduced group of countries (4) |
BLOC – BLOCk (forestall) “reduced” | |
6 | Road vehicle adopted by one American guy involved in fatal flight (6) |
ICARUS – CAR (road vehicle) adopted by I (one) US (American) | |
8 | Variety of top celestial or astronomical event (5,7) |
TOTAL ECLIPSE – anagram (variety of) TOP CELESTIAL | |
13 | Finished source of mutton before one serving of ham (8) |
PASTRAMI – PAST (finished) RAM (source of mutton) before I (one) | |
14 | Pacific islands are home to small spicy dish (6) |
SAMOSA – SAMOA (Pacific islands) are home to S(mall) | |
15 | Spot mature time of feeble-mindedness (6) |
DOTAGE – DOT (spot) AGE (mature) | |
17 | Sign of gratitude, having supplied skill (6) |
TALENT – TA (sign of gratitude) having LENT (supplied). Perfectly fair clue, of course, just me being dense. | |
19 | One opposing article returned it (4) |
ANTI – AN (article) TI (it “returned”) |
FOI 19dn ANTI
LOI 17dn TALENT
COD 2dn PECKING ORDER
WOD 6dn ICARUS
M H V Meldrew
Edited at 2021-10-07 04:29 am (UTC)
Also struggled with SAMOSA. And really hesitated over lent=supplied in TALENT. Was sure that ‘sign’ was the definition, and ‘supplied’ just doing duty in construct8ng the clue.
COD PECKING ORDER, very clever. Please don’t tell me it’s a chestnut.
BTW, fifteeners, today’s 15×15 is on the easier side, I think.
I made exactly the same mistake with stratagem. Thanks for the recommendation on the 15×15. I’ll print it now to mull over at work.
Contrary to popular belief the ‘Mad Hatter’ is never mentioned in Lewis Carroll, he’s just called ‘The Hatter’, but there have been ‘Mad Hatter’ characters in various comic strips.
“There was a table set out under a tree in front of the house, and the March Hare and the Hatter were having tea at it.”
The Hatter is referred to as “mad”, along with his little tea party, but he is never explicitly called ‘Mad Hatter’ in Carroll’s works of 1865.
The first documented instance of the phrase can be found in the 1829 short story, Noctes Ambrocianæ, published in Blackwood’s Edinburgh Magazine.
“Mad as a March hare” is a common British English phrase, and is first noted in John Heywood’s collection of proverbs, published back in 1546.
I would humbly suggest Lewis Carroll was perhaps avoiding legal action by this omission! The Hatters of Northampton were somewhat litigious! There have been scores of Judicial references citing both ‘Alice in Wonderland’ and ‘Alice Underground’ – the name of the original manuscript of 1862.
She had not gone much farther before she came in sight of the house of the March Hare …
Bob
Thank you to rolytoly and Pedro.
Enjoyed PECKING ORDER and ICARUS but my COD goes to PUPIL. Squeaked in just under target in 9.59 with LOI ICARUS.
Thanks to rolytoly and Pedro
Edited at 2021-10-07 08:05 am (UTC)
4d. I didn’t fill spider in for a long time as it seemed too obvious to me. Really, did it need the rest of the clue after arachnid? In the end some cross-letters told me it must be spider.
13d. Pastrami – as somebody indicated above, I did not think pastrami was ham. I always thought it to be a beef dish. When I saw the answer here I Googled “pastrami” and could see no mention of ham. Everything pointed to beef. If this is true, on how earth did this clue pass the pre-publish checks?
I found this QC to be very difficult. In fact when I first ran through the clues, so many just seemed utter gibberish to me. As I worked on them many of them became clearer.
Not an unenjoyable puzzle, but exactly enjoyable either.
At some point, you’re just going to let your mind click into cryptic solving mode, and see them all very quickly when you get to that point. Maybe you’ll get stuck on something you don’t know (like me in today’s 15 x 15), but you’ll be whipping through a whole bunch of them as you approach the end.
Edited at 2021-10-07 08:53 am (UTC)
Edited at 2021-10-07 09:04 am (UTC)
As Bob Todd used to exclaim in the old Knorr adverts “IT’S BEEF !” (Horryd will remember those)
MER at “shorts = soccer gear”, which was so vague as to hold me up almost until the end.
FOI PUPIL
LOI SAMOSA
COD PECKING ORDER
TIME 4:21
What I do remember is ‘Wendy’s’ great Joe Sedelmaier’s ad for agency Dancer Fitzgerald NY :- “Where’s the Beef?” Writer Cliff Freeman.
I can only vaguely remember Bob Todd larking around with Mr. Hill. The ‘Woke’ crowd would have a fit!
Bob, to barman: “Do you think you could get double whiskey into my pint?”
Barman: “I think so, sir”
Bob: “Why don’t you fill it with beer, then!”
Edited at 2021-10-07 12:16 pm (UTC)
SHORT ODDS held me up most.
COD to PUPIL.
A good challenge and nothing too demanding.
David
… and thought I was in for another struggle to follow yesterday’s, but picked up Pedro’s wavelength and ended in just under 13 minutes. Minor hold-up at soccer gear = shorts; one wears more than shorts to play soccer and can play many other sports in shorts, so a bit of a MER at this clue, but otherwise a steady solve.
Many thanks to Roly for the blog
Cedric
Liked the pair of classical clues ICARUS and ACROPOLIS
Thanks Pedro and Rolytoly
I really enjoyed the lower half of the grid with lots of smiles. LOI IMPOLITIC as I could not see the wood for the trees. I do like Pastrami (and US corned beef rather than UK in a tin variety) but it is always beef not ham.
Thanks Rolytoly and Pedro.
FOI – 9ac ASCOT
LOI – 17dn TALENT
COD – I would go for both 2dn PECKING ORDER and 18ac MAD HATTER as the stand-out clues.
Thanks to Pedro and Rolytoly
Liked PECKING ORDER, ICARUS, SAMOSA, amused by ‘Carpool Is’ being an anagram for ACROPOLIS.
Could not parse SHORT ODDS (mer?), INERT (must remember trap=net), MAD HATTER, SPIDER but answers were clear.
PASTRAMI amusing, so not bothered by meaty error.
Maybe I do better leaving the QC until lunchtime.
Thanks all, esp Roly.
FOI — 1dn “Planet”
LOI — 6dn “Icarus”
COD — 2dn “Pecking Order” — first Xmas clue of the season?
Thanks as usual!
However my impetuosity was my “downfall”, when I immediately saw how 6 d worked but entered “Adonis” instead of “Icarus”, something I’m not “waxing” lyrical about……
COD 2d “pecking order”
Thanks to Roly for the blog and to Pedro.
FOI: ASCOT
LOI: SHORT ODDS
COD: PECKING ORDER
Thanks Rolytoly and Pedro.
As for clues like pastrami, if you are solving from the cryptics, you won’t even notice the literals, saving yourself a lot of trouble!
We both found the lower half of the grid more tricky than the top, and we both finished in the SW corner.
Many thanks to Pedro and rolytoly.
Edited at 2021-10-07 03:56 pm (UTC)
Strangely, I always think of mutton as being from ewes, not rams, which makes no sense from a farmer’s or butcher’s point of view! I guess it must be linked in with the phrase ‘mutton dressed as lamb’ 😅
FOI Ascot
LOI Anti
COD Total eclipse
Thanks Pedro and Roly
BTW I didn’t find today’s 15×15 that easy – the bottom half went in quite quickly, but the top half had rather too many blanks 🤔
Edited at 2021-10-07 04:46 pm (UTC)