A second outing for Monty today, his first being a fortnight ago to the day. Looking back over the previous comments, it was a puzzle that divided opinion, with some fairly tough clues, a dash of obscurity and an original style. I really liked it, and did so again today with what was a similar solving experience (reflected by my time, again coming in around three minutes over target). Again I learnt a few things, but none of the obscurity proved essential to the solve, and some of it even merited a closer look – just the way it should be! An array of fine clues, several pitched at the trickier end for a QC, all well worth it – many thanks to Monty!
Across | |
1 | Turkey leg Bob demolished? Right! (7) |
GOBBLER – Anagram (demolished) of LEG BOB, and then R(ight). Originally a US term for a male turkey, with ‘gobble’ being imitative of the gurgling noise they make. | |
5 | Row after catching grand, wild cat (5) |
TIGER – TIER (row) catching G(rand) | |
8 | Ermine Street coming across to Alconbury at first (5) |
STOAT – ST. (Street) coming across TO A (TO, Alconbury “at first”). Ermine can be both the animal and the fur; Ermine Street was a very ancient road from London to York, predating the Romans, and was later named by the Saxons after a tribe of people living near a part of the route. And yes, apparently it does pass through Alconbury. All news to me – lovely stuff! See here. | |
9 | Artist’s pants (7) |
DRAWERS – DRAWER’S = Artist’s. LOI – was stuck on the idea of rubbish/pants instead of underwear/pants. | |
10 | Gather idiot has badge with end missing (8) |
ASSEMBLE – ASS (idiot) has EMBLE |
|
12 | Overheard couple too much (3) |
TOO – sounds like (“overheard”) as TWO (couple). I was sufficiently unsure of this not to enter it on a first read through of the acrosses, as I don’t ever recall seeing the answer so blatantly in the definition. I think what’s happening here is that “too much” is an old way of simply saying “too”, as in Richard II, “Your majestie is too much sad.” (Thank you OED!) Quite a confusing clue without this knowledge, but thankfully not necessary for solving it. Well, at least Monty wasn’t in an even cheekier mood with “Couple overheard too much”, eh? 😉 | |
14 | Bald Ulsterman moved item of hall furniture? (8,5) |
UMBRELLA STAND – anagram (moved) of BALD ULSTERMAN. Nicely disguised umbrella, I thought, that initially got me wondering who or what a MURLAND was, and what function their TABLE performed in a hallway. | |
16 | Struggle avoided, ignoring the odds (3) |
VIE – a V o I d E d “ignoring the odds” | |
17 | Celeb briefly backed into corrupt poll (8) |
ELECTION – CELE |
|
20 | Those people must accept rebuke for this treatment (7) |
THERAPY – THEY (those people) must accept RAP (rebuke) | |
23 | Boy trapped back in concrete pillar (5) |
PETER – trapped back in the letters of concRETE Pillar | |
24 | Forger sends money in two holdalls first of all (5) |
SMITH – Sends Money In Two Holdalls, “first of all” | |
25 | Chap’s local refurbished in 2000 (7) |
MALCOLM – anagram (refurbished) of LOCAL in MM (2000). I share the common dislike for random name clues but this was neatly done. |
Down | |
1 | Point, when American soldier’s on the way (4) |
GIST – GI (American soldier) is on the ST. (Street/way) | |
2 | Top, black, suitable for surfers? (9) |
BROWSABLE – BROW (top) SABLE (black); as in a browser for surfers of the net. Tricksy stuff: the B/BL for Black had me looking for a top via a wave. | |
3 | Volume was illuminating, with accompanying note (5) |
LITRE – LIT (was illuminating), with accompanying RE (note – as in do, re, me) | |
4 | Communist: the German revolutionary (3) |
RED – DER (the, German), revolutionary = reverse. (The only revolutionary in today’s puzzle, 1688.) | |
5 | Violinist’s last seen on composer’s journeys (7) |
TRAVELS – T (violinisT‘s “last”) seen on RAVEL’S (composer’s) | |
6 | My half of child’s horse (3) |
GEE – a GEE-GEE being a child’s horse. | |
7 | Comes back on steamship going round small lake (8) |
RESPONDS – RE (on) SS (steamship) going round POND (small lake) | |
11 | Bottom of ship’s bunk (5) |
BILGE – double definition, and nicely done. Another unknown for me: the bilge is the bottom of a boat; it later came also to mean “the foulness that collects in the bilge”, and was thence but a short hop to rubbish more generally. | |
12 | Tango with novel footwear in song from musical (3,3,3) |
TEA FOR TWO – T (Tango in the NATO phonetic alphabet) with an anagram (novel) of FOOTWEAR | |
13 | Oust violently with veto to achieve defeats democratically (8) |
OUTVOTES – anagram (violently) of OUST with VETO | |
15 | Rubbish solution for irritated viewers (7) |
EYEWASH – double definition, the first somewhat dated; boat bilge not recommended for the second. | |
18 | Part of flower — and of date palm (5) |
TEPAL – “part of” daTE PALm. Another unknown: the outer part of a flower, which wiki says is used when you can’t work out if something is a sepal or a petal. It’s a bit more technical than that, but potentially very useful if you want to confirm your ignorance of such matters in a fancy way. | |
19 | Daughter’s head: strange place to do tattoo (4) |
DRUM – D (Daughter’s “head”) RUM (strange). A tattoo being a tapping on a drum. | |
21 | Old priest: the Spanish one (3) |
ELI – EL (the, Spanish) I (one) | |
22 | Yours truly’s up for eating a potato (3) |
YAM – MY (yours truly’s) up = reversed, eating A |
Edited at 2020-08-27 06:55 am (UTC)
Apart from TOO which puzzled me too I enjoyed this.
Tea for Two an ear worm now though, and BILGE took longer than it should have done.
For once I actually got Malcolm – usually a bugbear of mine.
Thank you Monty and Rolytoly
Diana
It’s from an American musical called ‘No, No, Nanette’ that played on both Broadway and in the West End in the mid 1920’s but has never been revived in a major production in the UK since then. There were two films of it, the most recent having been made in 1940 which is rarely if ever shown on TV and is certainly not rated as being of particular merit.
The song is famous enough in its own right of course (as is ‘I Want to be Happy’ the other hit from the same score) but the fact that it was in a long-forgotten musical is not really relevant nor of much help to the average solver.
Edited at 2020-08-27 09:01 am (UTC)
Edited at 2020-08-27 07:57 am (UTC)
GOBBLER first in and last LITRE although I should have got it much sooner.
The surface of 24a was very smooth so that gets my COD.
Random??
I think not 🙂
Some good clues: responds, election.
Today’s 15×15 is doable, and verlaine did it in a quicker time than today’s “Quickie”.
But too is up there with the worst clue I have seen in the last 4 years, tied with the eyot one. Agree with Jack it has to be a typo. Overheard couple also is simpler and works.
Edited at 2020-08-27 08:44 am (UTC)
I don’t have a problem with random names as answers, but I dislike it when they are part of the wordplay.
As a bald Ulsterman who recently moved an item of hall furniture I had no problem with 14A!
Thanks for the blog
Brian
Edited at 2020-08-27 09:33 am (UTC)
Other than 12ac “Too” which I couldn’t quite believe and stared at for far too long, I really enjoyed this puzzle. Some nice deception and clever clues including 12dn “Tea for Two”, 19dn “Drum”, 2d “Browsable” and 25ac “Malcolm” (not that I really like actual names for answers). Erroneously biffed “Petal” for 18dn which distracted me a little, but the rest went in with a smile.
FOI – 1dn “Gist”
LOI – 15dn “Eyelash” (wrong!)
COD – 7dn “Responds” – nice surface
Thanks as usual.
Held up for a bit by putting TWO FOR TEA at first, and thus ruling out 14a as an anagram. Fortunately MALCOLM put me right.
On the plus side I thought BROWSABLE was very clever and therefore had me stumped for a while and I also enjoyed UMBRELLA STAND and MALCOLM. Finished in 14.12 with TOO.
Thanks to Roly
Edited at 2020-08-27 09:41 am (UTC)
I doubt if more than 3 people ever used it and if thy did it was certainly long before I was born
Yes. Often heard from my father in earlier years. More common than other crossword items.
Edited at 2020-08-27 06:42 pm (UTC)
Philip
Or is it just trying to be too clever by half and failing miserably?
H
TEPAL has caught me out before, especially as PETAL is often a near miss.
COD THERAPY
And I agree, the Bald Ulsterman is a nice anagram, Umbrella is not easy to hide.
I’m getting fed up with ELI who seems to be making a lot of appearances. Lets have some other OT priests like Aaron, Zadok or (more challenging) Melchizedek,
FOI Gobbler
COD Umbrella stand
DNF after 20 minutes + with TOO and BROWSABLE to go
Thanks anyway Monty! And thanks Roly for the very helpful blog
Edited at 2020-08-27 10:33 am (UTC)
FOI TIGER
LOI BILGE
COD DRUM
TIME 7:22 (or TOO TOO !)
Yam=Potato? I guess if a Rattlesnake can be poisonous instead of venomous then I can live with the Yam thing too 🙂
NHO bilge other than the nautical sense.
I saw a live ermine on our window sill in a ski resort once. I was less keen on our resident stoat here.
‘A stoat can be easily told from the weasel
by the simple fact
Its tail is blacked
and its figure
is slightly the bigger’
Liked Drawers and Bald Ulsterman.
Thanks all round.
Thanks roly.
Templar
FOI: tiger
LOI: drawers
COD: drawers
Thanks to Rolytoly for the blog
But (as many have said) also some real shockers. Not just 12A Too, which is worth all the brickbats already thrown at it; 18D Tepal highly obscure, 13D Outvotes puzzled me as the anagram indicator (“violently”) seems only to point at oust, not also at veto, and in 3D “illuminating” and “lit” are simply different parts of speech – it would have been so easy, and much better, to clue it “Volume was illuminated with note” instead. And a personal grumble at “on” = “re” in 7D – not really synonyms surely.
So, not a puzzle i will look back with much fondness on. Roly’s blog, on the other hand, is a masterpiece of empathy and generosity sprinkled with GK and wit. Thank you!
Cedric
I also thought the STOAT cluing was a little weak and there were too/two? many names for my liking.
COD goes to UMBRELLA STAND – very clever anagram.
Thanks to Monty for providing 20 minutes of mental gymnastics and to Rolytoly for the cheery blog.
FOI: tiger
LOI: drawers
COD: drawers
Thanks to Rolytoly for the blog
These things happen alas. All too obvious after the event.
I suggest putting 8ac 1ac, 14ac, 5ac 9ac, 25ac 23ac 24ac into Google 🙂
MP
You even managed to get ELECTION and OUTVOTES in there.
Excellent nina ….. too. Thanks.
Nice work on the Monty P anyway! I’ll be on the alert next time 🙂
H
H
Now it is letting me “reply”. I’ve no idea what’s going on.
H
Tim (not that Tim).
My MP at the time was Lieutenant-Colonel Sir Walter Bromley-Davenport (Conservative, Knutsford). I swear Sir Bufton Tufton was based on him.
But enjoyed a good puzzle and wasn’t timing myself. So enjoyed the experience apart from Browsable. I was fixated on Boobtubes for a long while until Vie went in and spoilt my reverie..
I had wondered about a modern internet connection but missed it.
PS. I didn’t like drawers either….(strange considering my desire for boobtubes)
PPS. Nice to see another GR airing!
Thanks all
John George
Thanks Monty and roly.