Whilst my time was close to a personal best, that didn’t stop me from enjoying the smooth surfaces. However, I do feel that I have done a short shift with only 12 across clues (about normal) and 10 down clues (a few fewer than usual). It made me start to wonder how many of the 169 available squares in a 13 x 13 grid are usually black. Based on a very limited survey, today’s grid does look overborne with black ones (57). I wonder if anyone has done an analysis to determine the averages (number of clues and number of black spaces v those that require filling).
Across
1 Greeting the Spanish commended at first – in women, mostly (7)
WELCOME – EL (the in Spanish) and C{ommended} (at first) inside WOME{n} (mostly, drop the last letter)
5 Persian ruler’s quiet expression of satisfaction (4)
SHAH – SH (quiet) and AH (expression of satisfaction). Of course, Persia is now roughly equivalent to Iran, and there hasn’t been a Shah in power since the 1979 Iranian Revolution.
8 Resilient young male worker inspiring union leader (7)
BUOYANT – BOY (young male) into which is slipped (inspiring) U{nion} (leader – first letter) and ANT (worker)
9 Some strapping lad entering forest clearing (5)
GLADE – Hidden inside (some) {strappin}G LAD E{ntering}.
11 Military tribunal heard top officer when speaking (5,7)
COURT MARTIAL – Part homophone (when speaking) sounds like caught (heard) and Martial (Marshall) (thanks to Des – see comments below) Marshal is variously defined as a law-court officer or the highest military rank (in France). A COURT MARTIAL is a tribunal or court held by officers of the Army, Navy or Air Force.
12 Slight breeze extremely rare in Somerset city (6)
BREATH – R{ar}E (extremely – first and last ketters) inside (in) BATH (Somerset city), as in the expression ‘a BREATH of wind’.
14 Scavenge at great length, never finishing (6)
FORAGE – At great length would be FOR AGE{s} (never finishing – drop the last letter).
15 Big tree a jazzman originally identified in Washington (12)
WELLINGTONIA – {Duke} ELLINGTON (jazzman) and I{dentified} (originally) inside (in) WA{shington} – the state not the city in the District of Colombia (DC).
17 Control male ox (5)
STEER – Double definition.
18 Trembling, seeing second colony of bees by railway (7)
SHIVERY – S{econd} and HIVE (colony of bees) by RY (R{ailwa}Y).
20 Time to abandon hackneyed ceremony (4)
RITE – Take the first T (time to abandon) out of {t}RITE (hackneyed}
21 Fawn upon grown-up relative finally touring area (7)
ADULATE – ADULT (grown-up) (touring) A{rea} and finally (last letter) of {relative}E.
Down
2 Flightless bird in Prague museum (3)
EMU – Hidden in {pragu}E MU{seum}. They don’t come much easier than this!
3 Rodent initially caught on yellow plant, unfortunately (5)
COYPU – First letters of (initially) C{aught} O{n} Y{ellow} P{lant}, U{nfortunately}.
4 Tiny worker marking time on watch, perhaps? (6,4)
MINUTE HAND – Double cryptic definition, the first pronounced MY NEWT where HAND is a worker, and the second MINNIT where HAND is a hand (or pointer).
6 Composer upset about pistol case (7)
HOLSTER – The composer is Gustav HOLST (famous for the Planets Suite), and HOLST is followed by RE (about) but reversed (upset).
7 Shrub in untidy garden surrounded by fresh hay (9)
HYDRANGEA – My heart usually sinks when I see flowers or plants defined, but this was relatively easy. An anagram (untidy) of [GARDEN] inside another anagram (fresh) of [HAY]
10 Brought from a distance? That’s unbelievable! (3-7)
FAR-FETCHED – Almost a double definition. Something brought from a distance would have been FAR-FETCHED, as would something improbable, unlikely or unbelievable.
11 Woodworker’s writing instrument pinched by carrier(9)
CARPENTER – PEN (writing instrument) inside (pinched by) CARTER (carrier)
13 Sick inmate nursing ultimately fatal illness (7)
AILMENT – Anagram (sick) of [INMATE] containing (nursing) last letter (ultimately) of {fata}L.
16 Original, having first half of month on lake (5)
NOVEL – NOVE{mber} (first half of month) on L{ake}.
19 Dreary routine involving stags in autumn (3)
RUT – DD. Something that sexually stimulated stags do in the autumn, and a tedious routine from which it is difficult to escape.
Beginners should note the Wellington/Ellington chestnut; any time you see boots and jazz in the same clue, this is a likely suspect.
As you would expect, the two meanings of ‘rut’ come from two different roots, like so many such pairs. Another one is ‘boss’, where the stud on the shield always baffles beginning solvers. One word, one spelling, one pronunciation, but two entirely different meanings. Sometimes this is due to assimilation, sometimes just to chance.
Loi coypu which should have been easy.
Cod holster
Thanks
Heading one possible query off at the pass I’d mention that Bath was restored to the historic county of Somerset after a period of 22 years (1974-1996) in the newly made-up county of Avon which has since been abolished.
Edited at 2019-02-21 10:19 am (UTC)
Thanks
As so often for me, the LOI was the dreaded plant -only 7:30 to that point.
However the unknown WELLINGTONIA emerged from the clue and the checkers so I was over the line in 7:58. Very fast for me.
Lots of plants today,feels like Spring. David
Rotter, I now think heard = caught which sounds like COURT in 11a.
An astonishing 5:42 for my second ever sub-Kevin. They just all went in at first pass, except ADULATE, FORAGE and WELLINGTONIA (LOI and COD; thank goodness my father planted a couple years ago so I’d heard of it). Amazing. Back to normal tomorrow, I’m sure.
Thanks to Orpheus and Rotter.
Templar
Thanks for the blog
Tim
I would have joined you Tim but I didn’t know adulate or Wellingtonia and I biffed buoyant but after yesterday when I only filled in one clue on the first pass this was a welcome easier test with the ne corner quickly completed. Many congrats I’m sure I’ll get there in the end
Edited at 2019-02-21 10:44 am (UTC)
FOI EMU
LOI WELLINGTONIA
COD HYDRANGEA only because I am useless at flower clues but this one jumped out.
PlayUpPompey
FOI SHAH
LOI BUOYANT
COD WELLINGTONIA
TIME 3:11
Adrian
Learn more about LiveJournal Ratings in FAQ.
LOI was buoyant mainly because I had the Y from coypu and assumed that was the ‘young’ part of the clue with ‘male worker’ giving ant. Didn’t fully grasp the parsing until reading this so thanks!
However – a quibble, no more – I was also thrown by the definition. Is resilient really a fair clue for buoyant?
I do see the connection. They call it bouncebackability in sport after all, quite literally what a buoy does.
Yet I can think of plenty of examples of resilience that hardly qualify as buoyant. Theresa May is undoubtedly resilient, but is she buoyant? Hydra are biologically as resilient as you can get but don’t float. Fish (or people for that matter) only become buoyant upon the expiry of their resilience.
As I say, a quibble but it did cost me a few seconds!
Quibble accepted, but I think Orpheus gets away with it in this case.
I was glad to have an easier QC today but surprised that most people seemed to find it so very easy. It was a relief to find you and I, once again, on the same wavelength. I however preferred 11a and so that gets my COD.
Thanks, Rotter , for the blog and for your perfect reply to Invariant!!MM
All went in pretty well with a bit of biffing where I just couldn’t quite parse the answer – 9a, for example, where I was looking for letters that ‘lad’ could enter and completely missed the hidden – anyway, we’d had one already so maybe I can be excused. Also 14a, which I just couldn’t see.
Knew the big tree – we used to have one in our front garden when we lived on the side of the Malvern Hills.
Thanks to Orpheus for a much needed boost to my motivation for keeping going. And to Rotter for the explanations. I would have given up years ago without this blog.
Brian
Edited at 2019-02-21 02:12 pm (UTC)
I DNF yesterday and meant to have another crack but never got round to it. Reading the comments on yesterday’s blog gave me heart that I was not alone.
Edited at 2019-02-21 03:35 pm (UTC)
Tim
FOI: Welcome
LOI: Wellingtonia
COD: Persian ruler’s quiet expression of satisfaction (4)
Time: 12.52 (2.2 Kevins – by far my best)