I needed all of my 10-minute target to complete this but I hope the puzzle will be received as an easier example that many of our newer contributors have been waiting for following a run of quite hard ones. As an experienced solver myself it’s often hard to predict the reaction but I think most people will be familiar with the answers here, and the construction of the clues is generally straightforward with perhaps the odd exception.
As usual definitions are underlined in bold italics, {deletions and substitutions are in curly brackets} and [anagrinds, containment, reversal and other indicators in square ones]
Across | |
1 | Flower finally dies now, getting very little rain (8) |
SNOWDROP – {die}S [finally], NOW, DROP (very little rain) | |
6 | Droop, faced with a story of epic proportions (4) |
SAGA – SAG (droop), A | |
8 | Exam some scholar once rejected (4) |
ORAL – Hidden [some] and reversed [rejected] in {scho}LAR O{nce} | |
9 | Marines clashing with squadron leader — almost a catastrophe (4,4) |
NEAR MISS – Anagram [clashing] of MARINES, S{quadron} [leader] | |
10 | NB: what a money thief might do (4,4) |
TAKE NOTE – A straight definition (Latin: nota bene – note well) followed by a cryptic hint | |
11 | Time to copy recording (4) |
TAPE – T (time), APE (copy – mimic) | |
13 | Cheap tinsel is out of place in this sacred building (7,6) |
SISTINE CHAPEL – Anagram [out of place] of CHEAP TINSEL IS. Perhaps one of the harder clues, but if you spotted that it’s an anagram and had a checker or two in place, that should have helped. | |
16 | Viewed from the back, a precious stone is great (4) |
MEGA – A + GEM (precious stone) reversed [viewed from the back] | |
17 | Like religious person stoic man converted (8) |
MONASTIC – Anagram [converted] of STOIC MAN. My comment at 13ac applies here too. | |
19 | Like some tall buildings much liked by fat cats? (4-4) |
HIGH-RISE – A straight definition followed by a cryptic hint. ‘Fat cats’ in the sense of wealthy and powerful people. On edit, please see my comment in the discussion below for further details if required. | |
21 | Tract having articles about religious education (4) |
AREA – A+A (articles) containing [about] RE (religious education). ‘Article’ often translates to A, AN or THE. | |
22 | Surveyed? Not half! (4) |
EYED – {surv}EYED [not half]. Semi&lit | |
23 | Guess I’m conveyed in spacious car (8) |
ESTIMATE – I’M contained by [conveyed in] ESTATE (spacious car – known elsewhere as ‘station wagon’). ‘Stretch limo’ was never going to fit! |
Down | |
2 | Account local person presented about beheaded wife of Henry VIII (9) |
NARRATIVE – NATIVE (local person) containing [presented about] {p}ARR (wife of Henry VIII) [beheaded]. A nice piece of misdirection here as Catherine Parr was not among Henry’s beheaded wives – they were Anne Boleyn and Catherine Howard. I imagine many will have solved this from a combination of definition and checkers, and then worked out the wordplay by reverse-engineering. | |
3 | Unrestrained European writer (5) |
WILDE – WILD (unrestrained), E (European). Dear Oscar. | |
4 | Ski slope, perhaps, makes you weak and tired (3-4) |
RUN-DOWN – This time the cryptic hint comes first | |
5 | Source of timber to make aircraft (5) |
PLANE – Two straight definitions | |
6 | Terrible traumas in Indonesian island (7) |
SUMATRA – Anagram [terrible] of TRAUMAS.This island seems to be very popular in puzzles at the moment. | |
7 | Gossips principally like to talk a lot (3) |
GAS – G{ossips} [principally], AS (like) | |
12 | I will have diamonds gift-wrapped for head of state (9) |
PRESIDENT – I + D (diamonds) contained [wrapped] by PRESENT (gift) | |
14 | Criticised intricately-woven threads (7) |
TRASHED – Anagram [intricately-woven] of THREADS | |
15 | Competition cheat put on trial (7) |
CONTEST – CON (cheat), TEST (trial) | |
17 | Crop of the month, do you say? (5) |
MAIZE – Sounds like [you say) “May’s” (of the month). Of which sweetcorn is one variety. | |
18 | Lots of people in Cornwall region acquiring weapon (5) |
SWARM – SW (Cornwall region – Southwest England), ARM (weapon) | |
20 | Climber, one going over sides of valley (3) |
IVY – I, V{alle}Y [sides] |
Edited at 2018-10-01 02:38 am (UTC)
Edited at 2018-10-01 05:49 am (UTC)
Challenge for setters – use only words in clues and answers that have been in Times editorial in last 12 months or are in the GCSE syllabus, then you really will be dragged kicking and screaming into 21st century and will attract some younger solvers.
tip for beginners (I still consider myself one), keep trying and don’t give up.
I didn’t see a problem with 19a as “fat cat” usually means someone on a very large salary, who invariably gets a much higher (percentage as well as absolute) rise than their staff. Wikipedia suggests the term may have a different meaning in the US.
COD 22a – a semi&lit semi?
Thanks for the blog.
Having decided Plane or Plain, Snowdrop for 1a came to mind and so unusually got 1a quickly.
Thanks to all
John George
Completed in 17.38 with LOI 3d and CoD to 2d.
Thanks as always to setter and blogger.
Templar
Gentle and enjoyable challenge.
PlayUpPompey
Maybe there’s something paradoxical about a flat being anything but? Just a thought!
Thanks Flamande and Jack
Apart from 2d I solved the top half pretty quickly. I then slowed down a bit and had two left after 15 minutes -16a and 2d.
MEGA has caught me out before and did so again but not for too long. Then I had to really work at 2d. I could not see where the wife of Henry fitted in with or without her head. Anyway I thought of Narrative and was finished in about 18 minutes.
Incidentally there is another of the six wives in today’s Daily Quiz which I look at when I’m stuck (you need the newspaper to see what I mean).
And well done to Europe’s Ryder Cup team.
David
Graham
So many to enjoy today but I especially liked 13a for its perfect surface reading. How do these amazing compilers do it? So, thanks to Flamande for keeping my spirits up and to Jackkt, for the blog. You always set it out so clearly and explain everything so well. MM