Time not recorded accurately, as I left the puzzle unattended with timer running when I went to deal with other pressing weekend matters, so all I can guarantee is that it wasn’t more than 10h 16m 13s. General impression, however, was that this was harder than average, with several hard-to-spot definitions (the lift-and-separate was used regularly) and more than one thing I didn’t know in the first place, or couldn’t remember. Not a smooth solve, for me anyway, and as will be seen below, some very densely packed clues.
With Jumbos I generally confine myself to discussion of answers which I think might be a) less straightforward for inexperienced or non-UK based solvers, or b) especially elegant / questionable. However, as always, if a particular clue is not discussed, please feel free to raise it in comments for explanation or discussion.
| Across | |
|---|---|
| 1 | ISHERWOOD – 1 + SHERWOOD, the forest in Nottinghamshire where Robin Hood hung out, not to be confused with Nottingham Forest FC. |
| 10 |
PILAF – L |
| 13 | LEIPZIG – LE (“in France, the”, our first lift and separate) + 1 + [Z in PIG]; on British road signs, a lopsided ‘Z’ indicates a potentially dangerous corner. |
| 14 | MUZAK – froM impromptU jazZ orchestrA booK; “maybe lift notes” is the subtle definition. |
| 15 |
EGON RONAY – EGO + N |
| 22 | BOOKKEEPER – BOOK(=reserve) + KEEPER (i.e. wicket keeper in a cricket team). Noteworthy, of course, for having three consecutive double letters, so it loooks very odd when written down. |
| 23 | HELIUM SPEECH – 1 in (MUCHSLEEPHE)*; have to admit I worked this out from wordplay, and twigged what was being described without realising it was a recognised expression. |
| 27 |
DR WHO – [DR |
| 29 |
VOYAGER – O |
| 30 | ENTRY FEE – cryptic def., and I’m assuming the extra ‘d’ is a misprint (the online version, at least, has “Damaged” as the definition rather than “Damage”, as was presumably intended). |
| 34 | INSPECT – ECT (Electro Convulsive Therapy) follows (“dogs”) (PSNI)rev. |
| 41 | UP IN THE AIR – cryptic def., but I’d have said skiers go up the hill, prior to coming back down, rather than up in the air (unless they’re ski-jumpers, of course)… |
| 44 |
OCTOBER – i.e. O.C. TO BE + R |
| 46 | YESHIVAS – YES + [IV in HAS]; all new to me, but worked out reasonably confidently from wordplay. |
| 53 |
AGGRAVATE – A + [GRAV |
| 54 |
SCREW – (C.S.)rev. + RE: + W |
| 55 | IMITATE – A in [1 MITT] + E (which is what follows C,D…). |
| 56 |
DUNNO – (NO, NUD |
| 58 | YOU NAME IT – (AMOUNTIEY)*; “variable” in the mathematical sense leaves a choice of x, y, or z, but it’s usually not too hard to work out which is required. |
| Down | |
| 1 | IGLOO – (G.I.) rev. + LOO; the &lit. is irresistible when you think of the smallest room, but has been used as recently as April, when it was “Soldier turned back, little room for a packed house”, so went straight in on this occasion. |
| 2 | HAIL FELLOW WELL MET – OW! in [HAIL FELL(=bad weather report) + WELL(=spring) +MET. |
| 3 | RAZORBACK =”RAISER BACK”. |
| 4 | PARTIES – tOuRaGuIdEiS. “Parties” seems a tame way to describe it, but your mileage may vary. |
| 6 |
MUZZIEST – MUZZ |
| 8 |
OPENING TIME – (P |
| 9 | TROUT FARM – cryptic def. based on “rainbow” being a species of trout. |
| 12 | FLY BY NIGHT – FLY(“race”) + BY(“times”) NIGHT(sounds like “knight”, unarguably). |
| 20 |
THEREBY HANGS A TALE – (BY |
| 21 | DERVLA – ER in DVLA. |
| 28 | OLDEN – “or” in the heraldic sense of “golden”, “below the peak” meaning “everything after the first letter”. |
| 33 |
SEE EYE TO EYE – S |
| 35 | EXPLAIN AWAY – EX (“lover who’s gone”) + PLAIN + AWAY. |
| 38 |
IDIOT BOARD – IDIOT + BOAR + D |
| 42 |
HIROSHIMA – HI! + (OR)rev. + [M |
| 43 | JIGGERED – JIGGER + hEaD. The “for” is just for surface, I guess, but seemed to get in the way. |
| 45 |
BUFFALO – BUFF (“in the buff”=”in the altogether”) + A L |
| 51 | LOG ON – LOG (part of a Kon-Tiki style raft) + ON (as in cricket’s leg-side). |
| 52 | EXERT – X in (TREE)rev. |
Thanks to the setter and to Tim for clarifying the wordplay of a couple of clues.
Several I didn’t understand, so thanks to Tim for the explanations. I couldn’t quite believe MUZZIEST was a word.
I still don’t have the answer for 18a (?G?S?I?G). tony_sever confirms it’s not an anagram of SWEATING and Chambers online has no word that fits the letters. What have I done wrong?
I think 11d must be LINDA, but I don’t know why. I can only see (NIL)rev.
I’m annoyed that 30a was unsolvable because of a misprint. But I still don’t fully understand it. I know damage=fee as in “what’s the damage”. Is the rest just a weak cryptic definition? Or is it something to do with TRY=shot?
And talking of weak cryptic defs, I though 9d (TROUT FARM) was rather poor.
At 41a you have to read it as “where SKYERS go” (cricket term). Apparently, both spellings, SKIERS and SKYERS, are acceptable.
It’s worth noting that omitted clues 19a and 10d are both hidden words, one in reverse.
11dn ‘AD NIL – the dropped H being characteristic of all Cockney speech in crossword land.
30ac – I read simply as a CD based on the assumption that, as for instance in the Times Crossword Competition, one entry (shot) to a competition incurs one entry fee.
41ac – you appear to be right about the variant spelling; obviously I’d only ever previously seen the one with a Y previously used in a cricketing sense.