41:49 on the Club timer, which rightly suggests something a bit trickier than usual. This was a tremendously good puzzle, I thought, with very smooth surfaces, some tricky definitions, a wide range of required general knowledge, and a few traps for the unwary. Nice work, setter.
With Jumbos, which attract a far smaller audience than daily puzzles, I generally confine myself to discussion of answers which I think are a) less straightforward for inexperienced or non-UK based solvers, or b) especially elegant / questionable. In other words, unless it’s an exceptionally interesting puzzle, the coverage is unlikely to be 100%; however, as always, if a particular clue is not discussed, please feel free to raise it in comments for explanation or discussion.
Across | |
---|---|
6 |
CHAFF – H |
9 |
DE FACTO – ACT in DEFO |
13 |
SOLON – SOLON |
14 |
PROMISE – PROM IS E |
15 | INCURSIVE – IN + CURS I’VE; lift and separate required on “attack dogs”. |
18 | FORBAD – FOR(in the service of) BAD(evil); “forbade” is what I would have expected, but either is acceptable. |
19 |
TOREADOR – TORE, ADO, R |
21 | TASMAN – i.e. take MANTAS, cut it in half, and rearrange the two halves. Tasman will obviously be very straightforward for our Antipodean solvers. |
26 | BREAD AND BUTTER – READ in [B AND B], UTTER. |
28 |
ISLAY – L |
29 | PLIANT – I in PLANT; “supply” as adverb in the definition, of course. |
33 | LOCKSMITHS – cryptic def. |
36 | STATE – I spent ages thinking this must be something to do with the words themselves, but in fact the answer is so obvious it seems hardly cryptic (when you get it, that is) i.e. the first two are states as well as cities, which the other two aren’t. |
40 | NOSE RING – some people won’t like this, as it requires very specialist knowledge of The Owl and the Pussycat, to wit their purchase (for a shilling i.e a bob) of the ring through a pig’s nose to use at their wedding ceremony. |
42 | KNIGHT – cryptic def.: in chess, the only piece on the back rank which can make an opening move is the knight. |
47 | SIDE STREETS – [ID EST] in STEERS(rev.). |
53 |
IN ERROR – IN(=governing) E |
54 | DARBY =”DERBY”, the most prominent of the English racing classics. One half of the proverbially contented married couple. |
57 | PORTRAYAL – RAY in PORTAL(“way in”). |
Down | |
1 |
BOSUN – BONUS with partners N |
2 |
MILITARY POLICEMEN – R |
5 | CROSSBOW – different, and differently pronounced, BOWS – one which you might shoot with, the other being the part of a ship across which the shot might be fired. |
7 |
AMERINDIAN – N |
10 |
FIRING SQUAD – (IF)rev., RINGS QUAD |
11 | CAIRO – inflated company, as produced by putting AIR in your CO. |
12 | ODENSE – 0 DENSE; very tempting to put in ODESSA, which isn’t northern, and doesn’t fit the wordplay. |
18 | FRITILLARY – TILL in FRIARY; I thought a fritillary was only a butterfly, but obviously I was wrong. |
20 | REASONED – theatRE AS ONE Does. They say that if a hidden word clue is one of the last in, it’s a good one of its type, and this one certainly met that criterion for me. |
22 |
ALTERNATIVE ENERGY – GREEN |
23 | DELPHI – (LED)rev. + PHI; brilliant &lit. clue, as the oracle at Delphi gave famously opaque advice, which was open to misinterpretation, hence the adjective “Delphic”. |
24 |
TROY WEIGHT – TROY(=city of Paris) W |
31 | ACTION – I(=current in scientific notation) in ACTON(part of West London). |
34 |
SMORGASBORD – (GRABSROOM)* in S |
37 | FLY FISHING – (IFSHY)* in FLING. |
45 | ASKANT – AS KANT. As with FORBAD, I always thought ASKANCE was the only correct version, but this is, again, a perfectly valid alternate form. |
46 | FAIRER – i.e. this is the comparative adjective of “FAIR”, which can mean any one of “fine”, “blonde”, “just” or “beautiful”. |
48 |
DATUM – T |
49 | EASED – EASEL(=”support for artist”) with the final L(=50 in Roman numerals) changed to D(=500). |
nuein CAT(=pet).Steve Rourke
36dn SPELL(read letters in) BINDER(file) = SPELLBINDER (gifted orator)
44ac LIEN (from OED “a right to keep possession of property belonging to another person until a debt owed by that person is discharged” i.e. right, to lawyer) in CT. (=Court) gives CLIENT (employer of professional)