FOI 22ac, as I’ve done enough crosswords by now for that DID O type device to leap straight out at me; LOI 15ac where I was looking for an archaic word for “roughneck” for way too long. There are loads of clues here that are candidates for high praise but a couple that stuck out for me were 18ac (I’m easily tickled by political surfaces), 20dn (perhaps a trifle libertarian but it directs the brainwaves towards the wrong kind of theatre very nicely). As a classicist I only ever had one real option for Clue of the Day, the Latinate and very smoothly clued 6dn. Bravo to the setter!
ACROSS
1 Prop, you said, caught by Belfast’s flankers and lock (8)
BUTTRESS – U [you “said”] “caught by” B{elfas}T + TRESS [lock]
5 In retreat, heroic national leader’s instructions (6)
RECIPE – reverse all of EPIC ER [heroic | national leader (the UK’s Queen)]
8 Strategy adopted by men due to work, or not? (10)
UNEMPLOYED – PLOY [strategy] “adopted by” (MEN DUE*) [“…to work”].
This is a semi-&lit but I’m not quite sure where the wordplay ends and the definition begins; it seems to me there must be partial but not complete overlap.
9 Bearing king on throne (4)
LOOK – K [king] on LOO [throne]
10 Bird and dog laze in Manhattan area, perhaps? (8,6)
COCKTAIL LOUNGE – COCK and TAIL LOUNGE [bird; dog; laze]. Not an area of the New York borough of Manhattan, but an area in which one could be served a nice Manhattan.
11 Viewpoint associated with Times sub (7)
STANDBY – STAND associated with BY [viewpoint; times]
13 Worry about woman in flood (7)
FRESHET – FRET about SHE [worry; woman]. “The flood of a river from heavy rain or melted snow.” I know it was something watery but probably would have guessed at a babbling brook or suchlike.
15 Roughneck turning criminal in early period (7)
BOYHOOD – reverse YOB [roughneck “turning”] + HOOD [criminal]
18 Some current politicians hiding before backing America’s leader (7)
AMPERES – MPS [politicians] “hiding” ERE [before], backing A{merica}
21 Charming helper‘s good faith and merry fooling around (5,9)
FAIRY GODMOTHER – (GOOD FAITH + MERRY*) [“fooling around”]. Charming not as in pleasant, but as in casting magic spells.
22 Addict to make no gains at all (4)
WINO – WIN O = win nothing = “make no gains at all”
23 Put up with drinks, initially punch (10)
ROUNDHOUSE – HOUSE [put up], with ROUND [drinks] initially
24 Get wrong place to eat on a plane? (4,2)
MESS UP – MESS [place to eat] + UP, as in up in the air, as in maybe on a plane.
25 The English lady trembling with passion (8)
HEATEDLY – (THE E{nglish} LADY*) [“trembling”]
DOWN
1 Throws out black cats (7)
BOUNCES – B OUNCES [black | cats]. Bounce as in “what a bouncer does”, I think.
2 Article on overthrown officer rude in Iran? (9)
THEOCRACY – THE [article] on reversed CO [“overthrown” officer] + RACY [rude]. Iran with its Ayatollahs being perhaps the most noted modern theocracy.
3 Place covered by grass is viewed well (7)
REPUTED – PUT “covered by” REED [place; grass]
4 Question one with foxy clothing in flamboyant fashion (7)
SHOWILY – HOW I [question | one], with SLY “clothing”
5 Turn up during criminal ram-raid to give message (9)
RADIOGRAM – GO reversed [turn “up”] during (RAM-RAID*) [“criminal”]
6 About fifty tips for first date in Rome (7)
CALENDS – CA L ENDS [about | fifty | tips]. In ancient times, the calends was the first of the month.
7 Page with note about Polish sound (7)
PHONEME – P with ME, about HONE [page; note; polish]
12 It could be explosive blunder litigant’s turned up (5,4)
BOOBY TRAP – BOOB [blunder] + PARTY reversed [litigant “is turned up”]
14 Horse and badger eating mineral in medicinal plant (9)
HOREHOUND – H and HOUND eating ORE [horse; badger; mineral], Horehound lozenges are good for digestion, sore throats and inflammation, I discover.
16 Foul American kills fish (7)
OFFSIDE – OFFS [an American word for “kills”] + IDE [fish]
17 Appalling hotel that is recalled by us abroad (7)
HEINOUS – H [hotel] + I.E. reversed [that is, “recalled”] by NOUS [us “abroad”, specifically in France]
18 Dip in alcohol fit for diner (2,5)
AL DENTE – DENT in ALE [dip; alcohol]
19 Adept on piano, the playing is diviner! (7)
PROPHET – PRO [= professional = adept] on P [piano] + (THE*) [“playing”]
20 On-line rush for event in theatre (7)
SURGERY – on-RY SURGE [(railway) line; rush]. An operating theatre, not a playhouse.
I slowed myself up by being sure, as only the ignorant can be, that 6d was CALIENS, a notion of which I was not disabused until I finally twigged the COCKTAIL LOUNGE.
I knew FRESHET but didn’t know what it meant, so I just learned something.
All Verlaine’s suggestions for COD are worthy contenders, but I’m giving it to one of my last in, the foul American in OFFSIDE
Edited at 2018-06-15 07:27 am (UTC)
Actually most the LH side went in smoothly enough (I’ll come to the exceptions in a moment) but the RH was something of a nightmare with a number of unknowns, some of them intersecting, which presented me with no end of problems. Needless to say I didn’t know CALENDS until the wordplay led me to it and I made the association with ‘calendar’ which more or less meant it had to be correct. Other unknowns were FRESHET, ROUNDHOUSE (other than the venue in Camden Town) and HOREHOUND which sounds more like a term of abuse in a Jacobean drama than a medicinal plant.
My problem on the LH side was bunging in S(ASK,I)LY at 4dn which then gave me an incorrect checker and prevented me solving 8ac until I had corrected the error. The word doesn’t exist of course but I had confused it in my haste with ‘sassily’ which arguably fits the definition but not the wordplay.
Trickiest bit was the Freshet/Horehound crossers. Both DNKs but the wordplay was helpful.
Mostly I liked: Amperes, Calends and COD to the bird and dog lazing and chatting in a chirp/woof pidgin while surveying the rooftops of Manhattan.
Thanks setter and V.
If you stopped me in the street and asked me what the first day of the month was, I would have said Kalends, confirmed by Collins Latin Dictionary and Grammer (Kalendae = Kalends, first day of each month). I suppose though that as it also says ‘Calendae – see Kalendae’ it is sort of OK but this one niggled a bit.
Anyway, thanks setter and V.
Edited at 2018-06-15 07:42 am (UTC)
Edited at 2018-06-15 07:53 am (UTC)
Edited at 2018-06-15 08:57 am (UTC)
I felt sure we’d seen FRESHET before but I was surprised it was as long as 3 years ago: https://times-xwd-times.livejournal.com/1299854.html. Though we didn’t have the clues in the blog back then the explanation says it was also formed by SHE and FRET in that instance.
COD: CALENDS. Nicely disguised.
LOI: PHONEME. An awkward surface and not a phrase I imagine is used that often. Perhaps when I next attend a European Phonetics Book Review group, I will catch myself saying, “Have you seen that page with note about Polish sound?”
On further reflection, I suppose it could be a page, as in an attendant, carrying a note about Polish sound. Maybe Queen Victoria received a recommendation to listen to Chopin delivered by a “page with note about Polish sound”.
Edited at 2018-06-15 09:15 am (UTC)
Surely a FRESHET is one of those lemon soaked paper napkins without which (allegedly, H2G2) aircraft can’t take off. You’d need a slew of them even to create a trickle.
OK with CALENDS, now looking forward to four of them in the dyslexic version of the Two Ronnies’ best sketch.
HEINOUS of course from Bill and Ted, not knowingly used elsewhere.
HOREHOUND took me into The Scottish Play, but on checking it’s not The Scottish Person calling out the assassins, but (sic) in one of Lady Scottish Person’s early soliloquies in its medicinal guise.
MESS UP my CoD, not least because it invoked memories of airline meals you never can eat tidily (not in cattle class anyway). Now where did I put my freshets…
Took a while to start (FOI FAIRY GODMOTHER), and also a while to finish (LOI PHONEME), but in between I burbled along quite steadily to an 18 minute finish.
I was also enticed into momble country with “saskily”, but avoided the temptation until “how” became evident. Unusually for me, no biffing today.
Lovely puzzle with lots of COD candidates, but I particularly liked the rugby usages of BUTTRESS.
Have much in mind, so oft he plucks therefrom
Obscurities we elsewhere never find.
What, will the line stretch out to th’ crack of doom?
I’m not sure what the consensus is on “you said” for U, but personally I’m not a fan – a homophone (even if only for one letter) where it’s not pronounced that way in the answer doesn’t sit terrible well with me.
Speaking of not being a fan, I tried the Evening Standard cryptic for the first time yesterday, and possibly the last.
And yes, I wrote this for insertion here before I saw the blog and read the comments. Hi, Kevin!
Edited at 2018-06-15 04:53 pm (UTC)
I can’t for the life of me find any reason why I found this one difficult – even the slightly obscure CALENDS and HOREHOUND were familiar. Regarding the latter’s clue, it is notable that a badger can badger a hound, and a hound can hound a badger. Well, perhaps not so notable after all.
Thanks to setter and blogger alike, and a good weekend to all and one.