I rather enjoyed this one, though it took around 25 minutes, with 3d incompletely parsed but confidently entered. There was a decent helping of wit, and plenty of the kind of misdirection which didn’t make you feel you were being cheated. There’s quite a lot of food and drink (and some heavy duty drugs) dotted around the grid, though it would make a strange kind of breakfast so doesn’t really suggest a menu.
The surfaces throughout are pretty smooth and convincing, which again is a good mark in my book.
My reasoning and unravelling appear below, with clues, definitions and SOLUTIONS
ACROSS
1 Cooked, this contains potatoes, certainly no turkey! (5,3)
SMASH HIT An anagram (cooked) of THIS containing MASH, one way to serve potatoes. I’ll start the ball rolling by suggesting Emoji the Movie and Love Actually as two possible ends of the turkey/smash hit spectrum
5 Sort of film entertainer going into space (6)
ROMCOM Love Actually again? Your entertainer is an MC, and is inserted into ROOM for space
9 Men pierced by a bladed implement (3)
OAR You should know by now that men are Other Ranks, in this case with an A intruding
10 It reduces friction in social event with standing (4,7)
BALL BEARING Social event: BALL, standing: BEARING (think demeanour)
12 Marine received alarming signal at sea (5,5)
JOLLY ROGER A Marine is a JOLLY, originally a nickname for the Trained Bands in London around 1660. ROGER, in radio chatter slang, means “message received”
13 Website where wife and kids get 50% off (4)
WIKI Just take the front halves of Wife and KIds
15 Such a clue gets a mark of affection? (6)
ACROSS or a cross, an X or kiss
16 Attack on fortified building as exercise (4,3)
KEEP FIT Fortified building is a KEEP, and FIT comes from attack as in some sort of seizure
18 Said no official had a drug problem (7)
REFUSED Breaking the clue at the right point is critical. REFeree is our official, and apparently he/she USED, or took drugs. Whether or not that constitutes a problem is a moot point.
20 Rocky ravine is greener (6)
NAIVER Looks like, is, an anagram (rocky) of RAVINE
23 Girl a man of God rebuffed (4)
VERA Our random girl is A REV backwards. Events (especially the appointment of Sarah Mullally as Bishop of London) make “man of God” perhaps a little presumptive.
24 Landlord approving of new porter, drinking one (10)
PROPRIETOR Approving gives you PRO, and “new” PORTER with a I (one) introduced provides the rest.
26 “Sweet” summarised daughter brought in indisposed (7,4)
SPOTTED DICK A staple of school dinners and schoolboy jokes. Summerised gives POTTED, add D for Daughter, enclose in SICK for indisposed
27 Choose to be heard still (3)
PIC Still as in photograph, sounding very much like PICK as in choose
28 In nomad’s dwelling, leave rolls for other food (6)
YOGURT One of four (at least) spellings of what, in my youth, tasted properly sour. The nomad’s dwelling is a YURT, and leave gives GO which is “rolled” and inserted
29 Farm animal to get on part of vessel (8)
STEERAGE STEER obviously your farm animal, AGE to get on (in years)
DOWN
1 Small hill by first person in French capital (6)
SKOPJE I remember Skopje for the disastrous earthquake of 1963, but it’s now the capital of FYR Macedonia. S(mall) KOP (Afrikaans for a hill) plus JE as French for the first person singular.
2 Original lyric, a concert’s opening material (7)
ACRYLIC An anagram (original) of LYRIC, A and C(oncert’s) opening
3 Toy goblin: beastly, empty junk (10)
HOBBY HORSE A goblin is a HOB, B(eastl)Y is emptied. HORSE puzzled me , but both junk and horse are slang terms for heroin.
4 Person needing prison doctor, maybe left with inflamed rash (3-10)
ILL-CONSIDERED An ILL CON would need a prison doctor, left is one possible SIDE, inflamed is RED. And that sort of rash.
6 Just dropping marks in exam (4)
ORAL Just would be MORAL then, lose the M
7 Chicken, I note, provided in cheap eatery (7)
CAITIFF Well, a cheap eatery is a CAFF, and I TI is given by I note. My Chambers doesn’t give the cowardly definition, but other sources do. Anyway, that sort of chicken.
8 Artist shows courage in China (8)
MAGRITTE “10 famous Belgians”, this one gave us “Ceci n’est pas une pipe”. When you see CHINA, you know it’s either PAL or MATE, and courage gives the inserted GRIT, as in John Wayne’s true version.
11 Server’s problem about gin spilt in tense moment (8,5)
BREAKING POINT This is a tennis rather than technology reference. A server who has a break point against him/her must win the next or lose the game, set or match. Which would be a problem. GIN “spilt” provides the remaining letters.
14 Sort of blue colour around elevated cable, live on the outside (10)
PERIWINKLE When it’s a colour, it’s a light blue, though the flower can be almost any colour. No doubt the mollusc provides a few more. In the wordplay, the colour is PINK, around a reversal of WIRE (cable) and L(iv)E, the outside thereof, completes.
17 Seek to protect birds heading for tricky takeoff (8)
TRAVESTY Takeoff as in imitation, commonly in theatre an actor playing a different gender. Seek is TRY, birds are AVES, and the heading for Tricky is T. Assemble thoughtfully.
19 Perhaps squirrel atop pine in the distance (7)
FURLONG Like mink, the animal name can be applied just to the animal’s means of keeping warm. Pine gives rise to long, and distance here is a distance.
21 Medical abnormality nurse finally spies round head (7)
ECTOPIA “Out of place”. Nurse finally is E, spies are the CIA, and head is TOP.
22 Diviner gold left for one to gather (6)
ORACLE Gold is an heraldic OR, one is ACE, which “gathers” L(eft)
25 What agitator does, in time caught by teacher (4)
STIR T(ime) is caught by SIR, the teacher who isn’t Miss
The biffed ones included ‘hobbyhorse’, ‘ill-considered’, and ‘breaking point’. My only real problem was remembering how to spell ‘Skopje’.
Cleverly constructed, hugely enjoyable and a really good workout. Great fun. Let’s hope it helps me to sleep.
Love Actually is down there with Tuesdays (or is it Thursdays?) with Morrie for worst film ever. The wife loves it, though…
Edited at 2017-12-21 06:57 am (UTC)
The other clues managed to reveal themselves with some effort – quite a few aha moments. Thanks to the setter and to Z for the blog.
On edit: As I now see has already been pointed out by Myrtilus.
Edited at 2017-12-21 02:13 pm (UTC)
I agree this was a good one. Good surfaces and nice misleading.
Mostly I liked: Yogurt (obvs) and Server’s problem.
Thanks clever setter and Z. Well done on resisting the schoolboy jokes.
Edited at 2017-12-21 08:06 am (UTC)
35mins with a lucky punt at CAITIFF, which sounded only marginally more likely than ‘caimiff’.
HORSE for ‘junk’ (for ‘heroin’) unknown (or forgotten). Opted for SKOPJE over ‘storje’ as I’d heard of the capital but not not the hill, rather than the hill but not the capital.
For those dropping Turkey hints — yes, I’m working on it!
Edited at 2017-12-21 08:34 am (UTC)
It took me around 75 mins. A very Fridayish feeling
I began well with FOI 6dn ORAL followed by 7dn CAITIFF easy as at school in the lower sixth I played Ralph (Rafe) in
Beaumont & Fletcher’s comedy, ‘The Knight of the Burning Pestle.’ What fun and it had ‘caitiff wretches’ abounding!
LOI was8ac ROMCOM (nasty word) I prefer the ‘One Foot in the Grave’ Meldrewvian style (COMCOM) complaint comedy.
But it was the SW that held me up horrydly.
COD 28ac YOGHURT quam gigliano and WOD ECTOPIA chillin’
Thank-you Sir Pip Kirby for the ‘Santa Owl’ avatar and you are admissable for the competition even if ‘her indoors’ is an ex-Gooner!
Ask her to renounce Arsen Wenger (Old Vinegar Face) thrice.
A word of warning however Kirby, the jury isn’t really big on cats or anything Trumpy.
I also notice that Lady Sarah Sotira has upped the ante – with her Christmas fowl! Gobble-gobble!
Any new avatars forthcoming? Don’t forget your avatar could win a splendid prize in the TftT ‘Avatar of the Year’ competition!
Top Ten – results in early January.
Edited at 2017-12-21 09:12 am (UTC)
And no cats either.
Sir Pip
This was a lovely crossword, with a good mix of easy (STIR, OAR, ROMCOM) with some more tortuous (SMASH HIT, CAITIFF). 39 mins. Thank you, blogger for your neat elucidation and commentary.
Edited at 2017-12-21 11:24 am (UTC)
And especially for Horryd, here is another avatar – myself in salad days. I’m rather more like Whistler’s mother (vide infra) nowadays.
I say ‘probably’ just because I have also seen Truly Madly Deeply.
Picking things up later, I immediately popped in TRAVESTY and YOGURT, then ummed and ahhed for another five minutes between CAIMIFF, CAITIFF or possibly something else.
Imagine my annoyance when I finally plumped correctly for the unknown CAITIFF, then came here to find that SKOPJE was the NHO capital, and not STORJE, which sounded just as plausible to me. I did know “kop” for hill—from the Goon Show episode The Battle of Spion Kop, if nothing else—but hadn’t considered it when TOR sprang so readily to mind.
As for 1d it started life as STORJE, then I remembered that there was a city that sounded like SCOPJE, and then I remembered that it was SKOPJE and that a kop, but not a cop, was a hill.
I think I just about remembered CAITIFF from ?Othello.
As for Horryd’s avatars, Whistler’s mother is rather descriptive of how I feel this morning. 18.40
Edited at 2017-12-21 03:49 pm (UTC)
*Smash hit – couldn’t get spud out of my head, though guessed at the wordplay
Romcom – was thinking silent (en in anagram of slit)
Ball-bearing – couldn’t get _ice-breaker out of my head.
Keep fit – initially was thinking kick box
Vera – had the wordplay but name didn’t arrive
Spotted dick – was nowhere near
Steerage – couldn’t think of an animal _t…
Caitiff – worked out the wordplay but guessed caimiff
Still learning!
Mighty