I found this quite tricky and needed 10 minutes over the hour to complete it. No doubt that 10 minutes will have been enough for some to solve the whole puzzle, but as I never struggled to the extent that I was out of ideas and just sitting and staring blankly at the page, I can take the positive view that I had an hour’s more enjoyment than the speedsters. Of course in retrospect I can’t understand what delayed me, apart from the unknown expression at 8dn
As usual definitions are underlined in bold italics, {deletions are in curly brackets} and [anagrinds, containment, reversal and other indicators in square ones]
Across | |
1 | Short of a proposal, still (10) |
MOTIONLESS – MOTION (proposal), LESS (short of) | |
6 | Go crazy, spinning around (4) |
STAB – BATS (crazy) reversed [spinning around]. As in ‘have a go or stab at something’. | |
10 | Bit pale, ultimately? (5) |
WHITE – WHIT (bit), {pal}E [ultimately]. The definition is &lit but you may care not a whit or a jot. | |
11 | Epic figure lookin’ to steal painting, criminal finally retiring (9) |
GAZILLION – GAZIN’ (lookin’) containing [to steal] OIL (painting) + {crimina}L [finally] reversed [retiring]. SOED has ‘kazillion’ as an alternative, which may be worth remembering. | |
12 | Dish of stuff finally brimming over, clutched by old cook (4,10) |
BEEF WELLINGTON – {stuf}F [finally] + WELLING [brimming over] contained [clutched] by BEETON (old cook). Watching a docudrama about Mrs B on TV a few years ago I learnt that she wasn’t a professional cook, but a jounalist, editor and compiler. She reproduced other people’s recipes in her cookery column for ‘The Englishwoman’s Domestic Magazine’ and collected and later published many more in her famous ‘Book of Household Management’ which contained advice on all manner of domestic duties and home-making, not just cookery. | |
14 | Letters to burn — dipped in water, on reflection (7) |
AITCHES – ITCH (burn) contained by [dipped in] SEA (water) reversed [on reflection] | |
15 | Look again, as rector not half given hell! (7) |
RECHECK – REC{tor} [not half], HECK (hell) | |
17 | Cappuccino maker is putting chocolate on it — cheers! (7) |
BARISTA – BAR (chocolate), IS, TA (cheers!). Two lots of DBE going on here as a barista is not restricted to serving cappucino, and chocolate is just one example of a product that may be made in the shape of a bar, but it can also come in many other forms. | |
19 | Unpredictable boy munching grass (7) |
ERRATIC – ERIC (boy) containing [munching] RAT (grass – inform on) | |
20 | Abandoning capital in London, northerner could rent close to home (5,3,6) |
ROUND THE CORNER – Anagram [rent – in the sense of ‘torn’] of NORTHERNER COU{l}D [abandoning capital in London] | |
23 | Bee’s sting? (9) |
HONEYTRAP – A straight but figurative definition with a cryptic hint (bee) that helps to point us in the right direction. Here’s some info gleaned from Collins: “A honeytrap is a situation in which someone is tricked into immoral or illegal sexual behaviour so that their behaviour can be publicly exposed”. “A sting is a clever secret plan carried out by the police in order to catch criminals”. The meanings don’t quite match in these definitions but they have become a little wider in general usage so I think the clue is fine. | |
24 | Exercise / a bit with this? (5) |
DRILL – Two meanings | |
25 | Alcoholic drink / vessel’s left (4) |
PORT – Two meanings | |
26 | Leader in Times, see, pretty embarrassing for worker on newspaper (10) |
TYPESETTER – T{imes} [leader], anagram [embarrassing] of SEE PRETTY. I wasn’t entirely sure about ’embarrass/ing’ as an anagrind so having checked it’s on the Chambers list (it is) I looked it up in a thesaurus and found at least 12 possible synonyms that fit the bill perfectly. |
Down | |
1 | Audible complaint cut short (4) |
MOWN – Sounds like [audible] “moan” (complaint) | |
2 | Someone trying to bag skirt for school term (9) |
TRIMESTER – TESTER (someone trying) contains [to bag] RIM (skirt). Used more in the USA than the UK, I believe, but familiar enough here. | |
3 | Stockings loosely on, do safety pins when all goes pear-shaped? (3,2,5,4) |
ONE OF THOSE DAYS – Anagram [loosely] of ON DO SAFETY contains [pins] HOSE (stockings). Two expressions meaning a time when everything goes wrong. Brewer’s advises that ‘pear-shaped’ has its origins in RAF slang for when an aircraft has crashed nose-first, but it later came to refer to a person who is noticeably “broad in the beam”. | |
4 | Drunk missing the stage? (7) |
LEGLESS – Following the same formula as 1ac we have LEG (stage), LESS (missing) | |
5 | Wonderful thing / frying sausage, say? (7) |
SIZZLER – Two meanings | |
7 | ‘T isn’t corrupt (5) |
TAINT – {i}T, AINT (isn’t) | |
8 | Outlaw getting a thrill stealing article, one not going straight? (6,4) |
BANANA KICK – BAN (outlaw) + A + KICK (thrill) containing [stealing] AN (article). “In soccer or rugby, a kick to the side of the ball causing it to follow a curved line in the air, typically in order to avoid interception by an opponent”. Never ‘eard of it. | |
9 | Lean on hump in humpback structure? That won’t kill you! (5,9) |
BLANK CARTRIDGE – LANK (lean) + CART (hump) contained by [in] BRIDGE (humpback structure?) | |
13 | For example, Sweeney Todd’s musical style? (10) |
BARBERSHOP – Cryptic definition with reference to Sweeney Todd, the demon barber of Fleet Street. Close harmony singing, typically for four male voices. | |
16 | Fanatic getting cross in street: I’m worried (9) |
EXTREMIST – Anagram [worried] of STREET I’M containing [getting…in] X (cross) | |
18 | Smoker’s item lost touring hospital (7) |
ASHTRAY – ASTRAY (lost) containing [touring] H (hospital) | |
19 | One getting out of cloak in the gents, free at last (7) |
ESCAPEE – CAPE (cloak) contained by [in] {th}E + {gent}S + {fre}E [at last] | |
21 | Piece of insightful narrative on member’s part? (5) |
ULNAR – Hidden in [piece of] {insightf}UL NAR{rative}. The ulna is a bone in the arm, hence ‘member’s part’. ‘On’ is part of the definition here to fit with the adjectival form of the answer. | |
22 | Vague shape in Monet’s colour, reportedly? (4) |
BLUR – Sounds like [reportedly] “bleu” (Monet’s colour – French for ‘blue’) |
I actually enjoyed the originality of “Bleu” as a homophone!
I think in the last clue you meant to type “bleu”. Or probably you did, but the spell corrector “fixed” it for you.
Edited at 2018-02-06 07:25 am (UTC)
blɜː
and “bleu” in “bas bleu in British” comme ça:
French (bɑ blø).
But I just looked at Oxford too, where “blur” is:
blur/bləː/
and
sacré bleu (which no one says anymore, by the way):
sacré bleu/sakʀe blø//ˌsakreɪ ˈbləː/
Edited at 2018-02-06 11:10 am (UTC)
(JerryW not signed in)
Wikipedia: “The expression today is not used in the major French-speaking countries France, Belgium, or Switzerland,[citation needed] but in the English-speaking world it is well known from Agatha Christie’s books about the fictional Belgian detective Hercule Poirot.”
I know Poirot only from the telly.
Pace Stanley Holloway.
Peter from Yorkshire
I remember ‘banana kick’ being used briefly in soccer circles circa 1970 – for free kicks from the likes of Zico. I think it is well out of fashion now.
MER at ’embarrassing’. Whatever the possible ways to get there, it is dodgy in my book.
Mostly I liked: Beef Wellington, Barista and the Northerner abandoning London. You come home lad.
Thanks (Inspector Clouseau) setter and Jack.
Which is usually a sign of a good puzzle. LOI the unknown BANANA KICK, COD and WOD 11a GAZILLION, though perhaps if I’d managed to parse a few of the others I’d have found them cleverer!
I have a vague recollection of my mum using Mrs. Beeton’s cookbook for her rhubarb crumble, among other things…
I thought this was on the easy side getting in in 25 mins. Perhaps getting 11 ac GAZILLION early on helped.
FOI 1dn MOWN
LOI 24ac DRILL
COD 22dn BLUR – it is homophonic en mon livre!
The clue I did not like was 14ac AITCHES from the IKEAN back catalogue.
WOD 12ac BEEF WELLINGTON. Yum!
23ac HONEYTRAP is fine with me – if your brave enough.
Another typeface problem, reading 14A as “to bum” but guessing “letters” starting “a” would be AITCHES. You sometimes hear a curving golf shot referred to as a “fyffes” being a reference to a bendy banana
BLUR raises nothing but a smile round here.
So Mrs Beeton became Britain’s most famous cook without necessarily knowing how to boil an egg. I like her style!
Edited at 2018-02-06 09:33 am (UTC)
25 mins for this.
And of course there’s the old EFL-teachers’ joke about the foreign student in class who asks the teacher “Plees, I need a piss. A piss of paper?” – “Ah, Stefan! I think you should probably say ‘a sheet of paper’.” – “OK, OK, so now I really want a shit!”
Thanks for blog, and parsing of TRIMESTER.
Edited at 2018-02-06 10:58 am (UTC)
I was a scrum-half, and scrupulously fair, putting in before the ref caught up with play.
Harry Kane does a pretty good BANANA KICK every now and then, but I’m not sure that’s the language currently in use.
Add me to the many who decided MEST must be an obscure kind of skirt out of my ken.
Good challenge, and a tough game of spot the definition. And then work out what on earth’s going on in the wordplay. Many thanks, Jack, for sorting it all out.
As for 22 down – I like Franglais as much at the next man but there is no Sacre Blur around here. However it was possible to solve the clue now that I understand that some people talk funny and are not very good at French either.
Here at the Ministry of Slow Solvers (MoSS) about an hour of relaxed fun. Thanks to setter & jackkt.
~ Nila Palin
Incidentally, jackkt, I used to try to convince myself after a marathon that I’d had ‘an hour’s more fun than the speedsters’ but it didn’t feel right.
It’s the first time I can remember seeing it used the ‘non-Times’ way in a clue, anyway.
I suppose Richard Rogan would be able to confirm it either way (no pun intended), but I doubt that he trawls the blog for late replies.
~ Nila Palin
On the point about BARISTA and ‘on’ in a clue, I’ve never heard of the convention in the 10+ years that I’ve been blogging for TftT and I’m sure there have been many occasions that it would have come up for discussion if it had existed. It may be a policy that Don follows when he’s setting for the Times.
Don Manley’s comment did imply that he wasn’t sure why the convention existed, but I’ve since checked Brian Greer’s book, which confirms it (on Page 51): ‘on’ in an across clue means following rather than preceding when used to indicate the juxtaposition of parts of the answer.
I guess only Richard Rogan will be able to confirm whether it still applies today.
~ Nila Palin
I’ll wait until your blog has moved down the page before I do it, in case they spot the query here first.
~ Nila Palin
Edited at 2018-02-06 10:09 pm (UTC)
I’ll bring it up on the Crossword Club forum shortly, at the risk of being replied to with “No one cares, you crashing bore”!
~ Nila Palin
IMHO it’s not good enough to assert the rule applies and then let a breach of it pass without comment
Edited at 2018-02-07 02:09 pm (UTC)
I wasn’t sure if he’d missed my point about that particular clue, or just didn’t want to discuss it – I didn’t want to push my luck with another post. Thank you for the follow-up!
It’s a convention that was worth clarifying I hope.
~ Nila Palin
20:25, anyway, so trickyish for sure.
I remember a letter to a newspaper years ago asking how, without getting too technical, to kick a football so that it bends, as in a banana kick. Among the answers that cam in from readers were “Ask a Brazilian to kick it for you” and “Ask Vinnie Jones to kick it straight”.
I got off to a very slow start with only a couple going in on a first pass. Then I realised I’d forgotten to boot up the other neuron, and things got a bit faster after I’d poured some coffee into it. All very enjoyable, although I thought SIZZLER was a bit of a weak clue.
Regarding “pear-shaped” – I find it hard to believe that it refers to an aircraft that’s gone in nose first, as the result is seldom any recognisable shape. A friend of mine was astonished to learn that the phrase was not – as he had been saying for many years – “it’s all gone bear-shaped”.
Edited at 2018-02-06 01:46 pm (UTC)
The way I say the words ‘blur’ and BLEU don’t sound the same but it’s close enough as far as I’m concerned.
PS I’m in the groan, but close enough camp on BLUR/BLEU.
Edited at 2018-02-06 02:50 pm (UTC)
The French pronunciation, according to Wiktionnaire, is
bleu blø
whereas the pronunciation of BLUR is
ˈblɝ (États-Unis)
ˈblɜː (Royaume-Uni)
I’d imagine people from Corsica would pronounce bleu differently than people from Alsace, who’d pronounce it differently than Parisians, who’d pronounce it differently than Bretons, who’d pronounce it differently than Pauvians, etc.
I’m with others above in defining the absolute reference of French pronunciation as Peter Sellers in Inspector Clouseau. Your perambulations around the web finding 5 different pronunciations in 5 different websites would confirm to me that they can all be taken with a pinch of salt.
Edited at 2018-02-07 04:11 am (UTC)
“You just sort of, like, wrap your foot around the ball…”
I imagine it helps if you have a fairly prehensile foot to start with.
Thought I would find a whole load of comments decrying how easy it was, so pleased to see that wasn’t the case.
Dropped by to say thank you, on the grounds this blog has been responsible for pretty much all of my progress from barely understanding the clues even when I had the answers, to finally completing it today.
All best,
Jonathan
Next thing, get yourself an identity, introduce yourself and get involved!
Welcome to the club.
Don
I’m another who rarely contributes so don’t have a proper identity but I’m impressed that you managed to complete this one. I thought this was really tough and only managed to complete 31% of it.
That’s how I track my progress (or lack of it), by working out what percentage of the crossword I complete rather than how long it took to do (like most contributors).
But I did have a rare 100% on Monday!
Phil R
I was also fooled by MEST as a skirt. With a more careful setter, I would have been suspicious, but here we had RECtor & IS both entering the crossword without conversion, so why not TRIER as someone who tries. Just grateful that TRIMESTER was biffable, otherwise it would have been sad to fall at the last.
What’s DBE, please, that someone mentioned in the context of BARISTA?