For those tackling this one early on the Club site, the lack of a clue for 9ac, and the lack of any means of typing in the letters not covered by the down clues meant that we were doomed to at least a 1 error outcome, and while it looks as though the omission was corrected by around 2 AM my time it can’t be corrected for those of us who stoicly submitted with a hole in the grid, in my case after 24 minutes. It means that my dominant reaction to this puzzle is one of frustration, which is a bit of a shame, as it’s quite a decent, accessible grid, albeit with a Spanish dance you may not have heard of and a bean masquerading as a musical instrument. Possibly the other way round.
Here’s how I construed what was available, plus the miss
ing clue as supplied by the online newspaper version.
Clues, definitions, SOLUTIONS
Across
1 Females generally in West, gracious about Eastern state (9)
WOMANKIND W(est) gives you a start, the Eastern state is OMAN, and gracious KIND
6 Latvian, possibly, at first introducing Pakistani cuisine (5)
BALTI There are many theories about the origin of Balti curry, Pakistan being one of them, Stoney Lane, Sparkbrook, Birmingham being another, the name coming from the steel, wok–like bowl in which it is cooked and served. A Latvian is, among others, a BALT, and I is the first letter of introducing. Mix over a strong heat and serve.
9 Girl accepts wine, revealing easing of relations.
DETENTE Very much needed by those of us attempting the early version of the puzzle and prodding fruitlessly at the light. I suppose the girl is DEE, because the wine is TENT, but the Dee who sang and (possibly) played the thing that goes tschhh in “Zabadak” is a bloke.
10 He accumulated great wealth, using various sources (7)
CROESUS As in “As rich as”. His method was to scrumple up each £5 note so as to find it increases. A variety of SOURCES
11 Ensure prosperity: don’t buy off-the-peg garment (4,2,4)
HAVE IT MADE for instance in Savile Row, not as found in Asda.
12 Quickly write a Spanish dance (4)
JOTA New word for today, which I have always assumed was a variant on Iota, and a useful score in Scrabble™. JOT for write quickly (which refused to come readily to my mind, still annoyed over 9ac) plus A, masquerading as a.
14 Persistently attack judge’s conclusion in worst case (5)
BESET The conclusion of judge is E, so you have to do that bit of mental gymnastics which makes worst BEST (it does work, look it up) without having to do a Michael Jackson impression. It then becomes the “case” for the E
15 Basis of amusing books about stock panto character (9)
FUNDAMENT Amusing: FUN, books: the evergreen New Testament, and DAME from panto land, placed centre stage.
16 Trendy girl, some say, and free from injury (9)
INVIOLATE Assuming one alternate pronunciation which allows Violet to be pronounced as if spelt as our answer. Trendy supplies the IN.
18 Old-fogeyish farmer’s first posh enclosure (5)
FUSTY Farmer’s first F, posh U (ref Mitford, can’t remember which one) and STY from enclosure.
20 Supporter Republican dismissed from mass meeting (4)
ALLY So many to choose for the literal but C.J. Cary will do, chucked out from a Trump rally despite being a full on Republican. Take the R(epublican) out of the rALLY.
21 Like elder, perhaps, stop brief falling out in sleeping area (10)
DENDRIFORM Elder as in tree. Stop: END, brief falling out RIFt, sleeping area DORM, and assemble.
25 Vessel wrapped by laid back daily? (7)
DIURNAL You don’t have to translate LAID into anything except its reverse, and then insert an URN which won’t hurt a bit.
26 Confections given to the French by spectators at match (7)
GATEAUX “To the” in French is AUX, which is given to the GATE, your matchday crowd
27 Give up flipping home improvements, saving energy and pounds (5)
YIELD Home improvements has to be DIY, which after “flipping” “saves” E(nergy) and £
28 Shows impatience about men with joint academic position (9)
TUTORSHIP TUT for “show impatience” surrounding O(ther) R(anks) and waiting for a new HIP to replace the old joint.
Down
1 Swim this distance, accompanying daughter to centre? (5)
WIDTH Accompanying WITH, and move D(aughter) where it says.
2 Test American composer’s reasons (7)
MOTIVES MOT (Ministry of Transport) tests ensure your car is roadworthy. IVES is Charles, whose work was virtually unheard during his lifetime but has a greater following now.
3 Lie under new screen finally digesting old biography, say? (3-7)
NON-FICTION Works like this: Lie translates to FICTION, preceded by N(ew) screeN (finally) and O(ld) in the middle.
4 Part of alimentary canal, or pelvic bone, we hear (5)
ILEUM Not helped by the absence of 9ac to provide you with the checking letter, but this version is a bit of intestine, the I version is the bone, or come to that the city with the topless towers which was Troy.
5 Corruption found in northern church after some years (9)
DECADENCE For some years read 10. Add N(orthern) C(hurch of) E(ngland)
6 Barracks demanding alcohol, by the sound of it (4)
BOOS Which sounds like “booze!”
7 Supple girl is so merry at heart (7)
LISSOME Today’s hidden: girL IS SO MErry
8 Popular time to visit Falklands port, missing English at once (9)
INSTANTLY IN is popular, this time. STANLEY is the port, from which you remove the E(nglish), and allow T(ime) to visit appropriately
13 Shamefully she flirts with a family member! (4-6)
HALF SISTER And an anagram (shamefully) of SHE FLIRTS and A.
14 Plundering of sailing-ship, as well as trains (9)
BRIGANDRY ailing ship BRIG, as well as AND, trains R(ailwa)Y
15 Standard obstruction limiting rise of old eastern instrument (9)
FLAGEOLET Standard: FLAG, hindrance LET (think tennis) sandwiching O(ld) E(astern) reversed. In my tins it’s a bean, but back in the day it was the forerunner of the tin whistle.
17 Rapacious type opposed to the arts? Not initially (7)
VULTURE Arts is represented by CULTURE, from which you remove the top and replace it with V for “against”, versus.
19 Corporation taking to graduate in school (7)
STOMACH Graduate is MA, and you also need the innocuous TO. Stuff both into SCH(ool)
22 Contemptible person overwhelmed by girl’s figure (5)
DIGIT Your contemptible person is a GIT, and DI is the venerable girl. Overwhelmed only means under here
23 Confusion arising in the afternoon about university team (3-2)
MIX-UP Afternoon PM, U(university) and XI forteam are inserted and the whole reversed.
24 Aim to accommodate one’s girl (4)
ENID I think the setter may have been getting tired by now (I know I am) I’s surrounded by END for aim.
Although I finished in good time, I thought the puzzle was a bit on the advanced side. ‘Dendriform’, ‘gateaux’, ‘flageolet’ and ‘diurnal’ may prove challenging for some, and there’s always the question of how ‘Croesus’ is spelt and what might possibly fit in 12 across if it’s not ‘jota’.
FOI 1dn WIDTH LOI 9ac DETENTE guessed.
COD 21ac DENDRIFORM WOD 9ac DETENTE
Enjoyable puzzle even with the cock-up!
Edited at 2017-03-16 12:54 pm (UTC)
Edited at 2017-03-16 03:46 am (UTC)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PPZ7lq6CPwk
and was so taken by the music I tried to find what it was – took only a minute, by googling on the vaguely heard gateau. “Le Goudron,” by Brigitte Fontaine.
Quite enjoyable, even with 4 random girls DEE DI ENID VIOLET. I seemed to be on the wavelength.
Under my 30 mins target, but with dendtiform as Isla. Chose to trust the wp, shrugged, and moved on… Note to self: remember tiff/riff.
JOTA u/k, but here the wp was pretty unambiguous.
I was pleased to dredge up DENDRIFORM from somewhere and to work out the unknown JOTA (okay, I met it once before in an ST puzzle in 2009, but I think I can be forgiven for not remembering it).
40 minutes interrupted by a trip to the computer to see if the missing clue was available on the new platform.
At the time of posting I cannot see that the error has been amended as stated by Z8 in his intro.
Edited at 2017-03-16 05:51 am (UTC)
Might be wrong – not what I know, only what I’ve read. I use Linux/Opera, but still have a backup windows system to read crappy webpages.
Partly, that’s because of the rapid rise of mobile phone browsing and Microsoft’s failure to get much of a foothold there. The leading web browser is now Chrome, a country mile ahead of IE and Edge in market share on both desktop and mobile. Safari has also had quite a surge because of the iPhone. This has tended to lead the market in the direction of web standards, though there are always areas where browsers differ, whether deliberately or accidentally!
Edited at 2017-03-16 07:30 am (UTC)
Thanks to setter and blogger.
Shame about the snafu as there are some nice things in this. Very satisfying to be able to assemble DENDRIFORM from wordplay and then recognise it as something seen before. INVIOLATE got a chuckle here.
Came here to parse the let in Flageolet and still not convinced by it.
Many thanks indeed
At least I had a good day on the Concise puzzle – 58 seconds and certainly a personal best!
PB on the Concise for me, too, though a bit less stellar at 1:36. I think that might be terminal velocity for me.
Pity, it was a good puzzle otherwise, with a lot of half-known words neatly clued.
Thanks setter and Z.
Haven’t heard of the dance jota or pena which I considered.
I have seen that worse = best before but its still confusing.
COD 27a.
At 3dn: there’s “say” (for example) and a question mark. Can we reasonably assume that not all biography is non-fiction? Several examples spring to mind, including a very interesting one by Ray Davies. Not sure I quite agree with the FICTION = lie equation either.
Easy enough puzzle for old hands
Exceptionally glad that a friend needed FLAGEOLET beans for a recipe recently, and I looked them up on Wikipedia at the time. (Especially as I’d forgotten all about “let” for hindrance. I see now it’s also where a let in tennis comes from.)
FOI 1a, COD 13d, LOI 17d. Thanks to setter and blogger.
Thanks for the blog and thanks to Jack for earlier posting the clue to 9a.
BALTI and DIURNAL GATEAUX – now that’s my kind of diet.
No problem with DETENTE as I do the newspaper version.
Time: all correct in 40 mins.
Thank you to setter and blogger.
Probably one of the great myths of corssword setting.
Towards the end the cryptic brain should be in overdrive
There is a world of difference between “should” and “is”. Obviously I have no idea how and in what order any setter sets the clues. I was merely reflecting that, in my opinion, this was a bit of a lightweight clue. And, at 2 in the morning, believe me, I was flagging.
And furthermore, though I have never read “Great Myths of Crossword Setting”, I’m prepared to bet this isn’t one if them.