After yesterday’s blog by proxy, here’s one of my own.
This one presented a few problems in the solving and even more in the blogging where I found some of the parsing quite tricky to explain and I’m left with a few loose ends as noted below against the relevant clues. I don’t have a time because I forgot to note it down but I doubt it was many minutes under an hour. On edit: as pointed out in the comments, there’s a hidden name in the grid which I failed to spot.
As usual definitions are underlined in bold italics, {deletions are in curly brackets} and [anagrinds, containment, reversal and other indicators in square ones]
Across | |
1 | In Paris I read about this writer’s rejected complaint (8) |
JEREMIAD – JE (in Paris, I), READ containing [about] I’M (this writer’s) reversed [rejected]. My last one in and I needed to check the answer because I wasn’t sure of it. I knew about Jeremiah and his lamentations and that his name has come to mean someone who complains a lot, but JEREMIAD as a complaint or list of complaints was unknown to me. The wordplay was helpful though. | |
5 | Reckless senior officer’s assistant enthralled by chart (6) |
MADCAP – ADC (senior office’s assistant – aide-de-camp) contained [enthralled] by MAP (chart) | |
9 | Friend o’ the compiler’s briefly seen with old horse (8) |
PALOMINO – PAL (friend), O, MIN{e} (the compiler’s) [briefly], O (old). A horse with light golden-brown coat and white or pale mane and tail. | |
10 | Lizard droppings mostly found in Iowa (6) |
IGUANA – GUAN{o} (droppings) [mostly] found in IA (Iowa) | |
12 | Studious type watching the cricket, perhaps? (12) |
ENTOMOLOGIST – Cryptic definition with reference to the study of insects | |
15 | Piece of litter on doorstep (5) |
RONDO – Hidden in {litte}R ON DO{orstep}. Piece of music, that is. “Piece” also helps to indicate the enclosure here. | |
16 | Aware of fellow worker swigging spirit from East (9) |
COGNIZANT – CO-ANT (fellow worker) containing [swigging] ZING (spirit) reversed [from the East]. I had problems with this one because the only spelling I knew has S for Z so I was unable to parse it for a while. | |
18 | A commotion connected with mother’s inlaid work (9) |
DAMASCENE – DAM (mother), A, SCENE (commotion). I knew the word but not this meaning. SOED has “Damascening” as the art of inlaying different metals into one another. | |
19 | I see nothing grand in this dome-shaped dwelling (5) |
IGLOO – I, G (grand), LO (see), 0 (nothing) | |
20 | Start of rally with state soldier, perhaps (12) |
SERVICEWOMAN – SERVICE (start of rally – tennis), W (with), OMAN (state) | |
24 | Was jealous of girl embraced by English chap (6) |
ENVIED – E (English), then VI (girl) contained [embraced] by NED (chap) | |
25 | A ghastly start for one city plant! (8) |
AGRIMONY – A, GRIM (ghastly), O{ne} [start], NY (city). I’m not too bad on plants usually but this one has passed me by until now – apart from April 2010 and June 2015 when I also didn’t know it. Again the wordplay was helpful. | |
26 | Divine in church vestment, not the first to walk unsteadily (6) |
TODDLE – DD (divine – Doctor of Divinity) in {s}TOLE (church vestment) [not the first]. “Stole” is more familiar as a woman’s long scarf or shawl, but it can also be a vestment worn by priests. A “divine” can be a priest who is learned, especially in the study of theology. | |
27 | Rosalind’s ally caught eating last of the summer veg (8) |
CELERIAC – CELIA (Rosalind’s ally – “As You Like It”) containing [eating] {th}E + {summe}R [last of…], C (caught) |
Down | |
1 | Primate crushed by judge’s joke (4) |
JAPE – J (judge), APE (primate). “Crushed by” indicates A beneath B in the Down clue. | |
2 | Responsibility quietly removed from uncultured pleb (4) |
ROLE – {p}ROLE (uncultured pleb) [quietly – p – removed] | |
3 | Fateful sign all of the French associated with mass (9) |
MOMENTOUS – M (mass), OMEN (sign), TOUS (all, of the French) | |
4 | Queen’s article on new enemy upset most of intelligent Society (4,2,6) |
ANNE OF CLEVES – AN (article), N (new), FOE (enemy) reversed [upset], CLEVE{r} (intelligent) [most of…], S (society) | |
6 | Trouble-making Greek disrupting a match? (5) |
AGGRO – A, GR (Greek) is contained by [disrupting) GO (match – as colours may match or go) | |
7 | Generous woman taken in by communication about hours (10) |
CHARITABLE – RITA (woman) taken in by CABLE (communication) containing [about] H (hours). A Russian doll type of clue with two containment indicators, “taken in” and “about”. | |
8 | Plot French film director takes on in cultivated area (10) |
PLANTATION – PLAN (plot), TATI (French film director), ON | |
11 | There’s rhyme as well as reason in this jazz style (6-6) |
BOOGIE-WOOGIE – The cryptic element of this clue remains a bit of a mystery to me. It’s obvious where the “rhyme” come into it, but as to the “reason”, I’m stumped. My only thought is that it’s a reference to i.e. as an abbreviation meaning “that is” or “namely” which customarily introduces an explanation or reason. On edit: please see my comment below timed at 01:59 pm. | |
13 | Hibernian ancestry second husband denied, getting shot! (10) |
IRIDESCENT – IRI{s,h} (Hibernian) [second, husband denied], DESCENT (ancestry). I didn’t have any idea how the definition works here and after consulting the usual sources I was none the wiser, so in desperation I googled “shot” and “iridescent” together and came up with this on Wikipedia: Shot silk (also called changeant changeable silk and changeable taffeta) is a fabric which is made up of silk woven from warp and weft yarns of two or more colours producing an iridescent appearance. A “shot” is a single throw of the bobbin that carries the weft thread through the warp, and shot silk colours can be described as “[warp colour] shot with [weft colour].” I still don’t really know whether this covers what the setter intended, or if it does, whether it actually works as a clue. | |
14 | Lacking firm evidence, I’m internally no better (10) |
UNIMPROVED – UNPROVED (lacking firm evidence) containing I’M [internally] | |
17 | Mimicking cry of kid at play a president’s wife’s mounted (9) |
IMITATIVE – I’ M IT (cry of kid at play – e.g. playing tag), EVITA (president’s wife) reversed [mounted]. The terms used in “tag” or “he” seem to vary according to local custom but as played at my school in the 1950s the person doing the chasing was said to be “it”, and that fits nicely with our clue today. | |
21 | Visionary declaration of banker at table? (5) |
IDEAL – I DEAL. It’s clued as if it’s a homophone but as it’s not I suppose it’s straight definition with a not very cryptic alternative route to the answer. As for the straight definition, once again I’m struggling to see it and the best I can find is this in Collins: visionary – (of people) characterized by idealistic or radical ideas, esp impractical ones. | |
22 | Asian desert, one with marshland up to the north (4) |
GOBI – I (one) + BOG (marshland) reversed [up to north] | |
23 | Alignment required to make washing-up place sound? (4) |
SYNC – Sounds like “sink” (washing-up place) |
Many of the same questions as Jack, esp. “shot”. Only thing I could think of was certain birds (e.g., my friendly local bronzewings) which are irridescent, so shot through with certain colours (in this case blue-green).
No idea about the “reason” for BOOGIE-WOOGIE. Fun bass line to play though. Anyone can do it in C# at the bottom end of the piano.
And also tempted by COGNISANT (with an S) but couldn’t justify SING as “spirit”.
Hesitated at 24ac because (while often confused) envy is not jealousy.
Is DAVID the new NINA?
Well done for spotting DAVID, mctext. I’m still waiting to see FREDERIK as a Nina. I’ll die a happy man when I do.
Thanks to setter and blogger.
Now I remember a friend from Liverpool University who was both: David by day (a tall swotty type) and Nina by night (an “escort” for “gentlemen”). Wonder where s/he is now.
Once I finally finished, I discovered I put SING not ZING in 16a since SING and spirit didn’t set off alarm bells.
So technically DNF.
Edited at 2016-10-18 03:37 am (UTC)
42 mins but two very carelessly incorrect. 1ac JEREMIAH instead of JEREMIAD and 16ac COGNISANT for COGNIZANT which is not fully displayed in my Chambers just -z-. My cheongsam shirt is of shot silk.
But did notice DAVID and, if you look closely, his twin brother DUG is at sixes and sevens.
Being a country boy 13ac IRIDESCENT has always been ‘shot’ – due to lapwing’s and pheasants plumage – always pointed out by my grandfather.
FOI 15ac RONDO
Didn’t parse 4dn ANNE OF CLEVES
COD 27ac CELERIAC WOD DAMASCENE
A Meldrew day all round
This puzzle had quite a few words I thought I knew how to spell but didn’t. The wordplay saved me with a few of them but not with palAmino, which I was so sure of I didn’t bother to parse it beyond ‘friend’ -> ‘pal’.
Around 17 minutes but with the mistake. LOI JEREMIAD
Thanks jackkt, and the setter. I enjoyed the puzzle, regardless.
http://www.maydaybooks.com/shop_image/product/03956.JPG
There may have been a reprint that got it wrong …
COD 20a SERVICEWOMAN
At 15A “piece” seems to be doing duty both as definition and containment indicator. At 16A didn’t know it could be Z rather than S. Don’t understand 16D and 11D is a total mystery
Well done Jack!
Particularly enjoyed IMITATIVE, IRIDESCENT and SERVICEWOMAN, but there were plenty of the kind of clue I like—where when the penny finally drops it drops hard, and possibly with a groan.
*A friend bought me Miles Davis’s Kind of Blue for my 40th and I’m gradually coming around.
Edited at 2016-10-18 09:05 am (UTC)
So I’m holed below the waterline, possibly because in my mind I’d pronounce the two spellings differently, stress on first syllable with the S and on the second syllable (and with a long I) with the Z. I note Chambers pronunciation guide does the same, though unlike Chambers, I have always pronounced the G, as I would in recognise.
No problem with shot as in silk, for me that was a gimme.
Bit of an old-school feel to this one, especially the very churchy 26ac, which I couldn’t parse. It inclines me think this must be a Don Manley puzzle, which of course means that it certainly isn’t.
‘Shot’/IRIDESCENT seems fine to me in the silk sense: ‘woven to give a changing colour effect’, as Collins has it. I can’t explain the ‘reason’ part of BOOGIE WOOGIE though.
Don’t blame it on the sunshine
Don’t blame it on the moonlight
Don’t blame it on good times
Blame it on the boogie
If correct then the game has changed and it’s time for old farts like me to retire from the scene.
Edited at 2016-10-18 02:39 pm (UTC)
so BOOGIE-WOOGIE is in no way responsible for anything.
Edited at 2016-10-18 02:47 pm (UTC)
Disappointing, after I was so pleased with myself for going with the wordplay for the unknown JEREMIAD. Everything else took over half an hour, with the usual hold-ups on IRIDESCENT and BOOGIE-WOOGIE. Glad someone finally came up with the “reason”, but it’s not quite the PDM I was hoping for.
Interesting puzzle, COD to ENTOMOLOGIST. Thanks setter and Jack.
I don’t think it really helps explain the clue though.
JEREMIAD was an NHO but went in from the wordplay. I had no knowledge, either, of Rosalind’s sister, who I assumed must have been called “CELEIA”, assuming that the “last of the summer” was just the “r”. Now had I heard of AGRIMONY, which I would have guessed was some kind of legal term or, possibly, something not unlike agronomy.
Like others here, I am at a loss to explain BOOGIE-WOOGIE. Surely we on this forum have the collective power to summon the setter hence to account for him/herself? We don’t? Ah well.
I suspect 11dn is simply an old-fashioned Times crossword clue where “as well as reason” is there to make the surface reading better. Such padding was commonplace when I started solving (over 50 years ago), and even now caused only the briefest flicker of my eyebrow.
DAVID also passed me by and I am pretty sure it is a coincidence
RR
Edited at 2016-10-19 10:24 am (UTC)
RR