A reasonably tough puzzle, I thought, with some ‘well that’s probably what he means’ type definitions, and more than the usual number of debatable homophones. 1a passes muster, but 22d less so, and 8d definitely dodgy IMO. Nevertheless, some witty clueing and complicated parsing for the non-biffer to enjoy. It took me about forty minutes to solve and be satisfied I’d seen what was going on.
It’s a toss up between the witty definiion at 21a and the corny 17d for my CoD.
It’s a toss up between the witty definiion at 21a and the corny 17d for my CoD.
Across | |
1 | Organiser of defence to hold out for a hearing (4) |
OFFA – Chap who organised his Dyke. sounds like OFFER = hold out. Offa was King of Mercia from 757 to 796, so he had plenty of time to get it done. | |
3 | Notice drag performer: one looked up to for a time? (5,5) |
CLOCK TOWER – Clock = notice, see; a TOWER tows something. | |
10 | Time mostly occupied with cast struggling to learn lines? (9) |
FORGETFUL – T, FUL(L), after FORGE = cast. Surely you forge a piece of metal into shape, or you cast it with liquid metal, they’re not the same thing? If I had a Chambers here I’d check. | |
11 | Research key WWII triumph (5) |
DELVE – DEL the delete key, VE Victory in Europe. I was tempted to have the key of D and recall the famous WWII Battle of Elve, but the battle was fake news. | |
12 | Fellow stressed but in good form? (7) |
HIMSELF – I see this as a sort of double definition, where himself is used as a stressed form of HIM, and in the reverse of the idea ‘he’s not himself today’ meaning he’s not in good form. In my 15 years in Ireland I did meet real people who addressed me with the opening “is it yerself?” when it fairly obviously was me they were meeting. Frank Carson used to make a joke of this Irishism in his stand up act. Or was it Hal Roach? They were both hilarious. | |
13 | French person’s back at the races, perhaps, taking in run (6) |
BRETON – If you had a BET ON you could be backing a horse at the races; insert R for run. | |
15 | In which one’s had secret set of cards (10,5) |
CONFIDENCE TRICK – Confidence = secret, trick = set of cards. | |
18 | Girl’s offer counters Trust mostly battering Establishment (4-3-4,4) |
FISH-AND-CHIP SHOP – FI’S = girl’s; HAND = offer, CHIPS are counters, HOP(E) = trust mostly. Biff time, unless you’re the blogger. | |
21 | Dish served piping? Charming woman serving Americans (6) |
HAGGIS – HAG meaning witch, a charmer, GIs serving Americans. Nice def. | |
23 | Fury after not counting number of shots (7) |
BARRAGE – RAGE after BAR = not counting, as in ‘all bar two’ for example. | |
26 | Standpoint that is often right (5) |
ANGLE – Double def, it could be a right angle. | |
27 | Pasta turning cool if sliced with short knife (9) |
FETTUCINI – IN (cool) IF with CUTTE(R) inserted, all reversed. IN I CUTTE F. | |
28 | Stop using sticks for cycle accessories (10) |
KICKSTANDS – KICK the habit, STANDS = sticks, e.g. in vingt-et-un. | |
29 | Travel writing on reflection that’s bad, if inspired (4) |
SMOG – GO = travel, MS = writing, all reversed. |
Down | |
1 | Not prepared to mess with quartet of females? Touché! (3,3,4) |
OFF THE CUFF – Anagram of F F F F TOUCHE. | |
2 | RAF officer: eccentric old square (5) |
FORUM – FO = Flying Officer, RUM = eccentric. | |
4 | What player shown red card has is unusual (9) |
LEFTFIELD – if you’re shown the red you’re sent off so you have left the field. Is OK as one word as an adjective. | |
5 | Star maybe lecherous, lifting trousers (5) |
CELEB – Hidden reversed in MAY(BE LEC)HEROUS. | |
6 | One passes on dry clothes, smarter than anything (7) |
TIDIEST – I DIES inside (clothed by) TT = dry. | |
7 | Graceful, is going to want to secure Oscar (9) |
WILLOWISH – WILL WISH = is going to want; Insert O for Oscar. | |
8 | Is sorry about deception auditor’s picked up (4) |
RUES – A nearly homophone IMO; RUES sounds like RUSE (deception) except for me they sound like ROOZE and ROOSE. | |
9 | Arab dated second person — the first person back at home (6) |
YEMENI – YE = dated (old) second person, ME = first person, IN reversed. | |
14 | Leading team jump with hoop around gym (10) |
SKIPPERING – SKIP = jump, PE = gym, RING = hoop. | |
16 | Locating back from places exotic, being this? (9) |
NOSTALGIC – (LOCATING S)*, the S being the back from places. | |
17 | Didn’t officially join in cry from angler breaking record? (9) |
COHABITED – CD is the record; insert what an angler may cry, OH A BITE! | |
19 | Capital for redevelopment is large (7) |
ALGIERS – (IS LARGE)*. | |
20 | Rise briskly and tip over (4,2) |
PERK UP – I’m thinking, a PERK is a tip, an extra benefit, and UP can mean over, as in ‘your time is up’. Maybe there’s a better thought out there, though. | |
22 | It follows funk broadcast in European city (5) |
SOFIA – SO = it follows; FIA perhaps sounds like FEAR = funk. I visited Sofia in 1968 in a Morris Minor convertible, and was unimpressed, it’s probably quite nice now. | |
24 | Man with a cross to bear: that’s self-evident (5) |
AXIOM – IOM for the Isle of Man, has A X = cross in front. | |
25 | Rating that’s worth more than a ten? (4) |
JACK – A double def, JACK tar being a naval rating, and a jack being higher than a ten in cards. I had RANK at first for no particular reason then couldn’t justify it when blogging. |
PERKS, short for perquisites, are benefits or additional payments received in the course of one’s work which may well include tips. ‘Perks of the job’ is a very common expression.
No problem with RUES/ruse here!
Edited at 2019-02-13 05:43 am (UTC)
FOI 21ac HAGGIS (I just love it but not so keen on neeps!)
LOI 20dn PERK UP which I failed to parse – looks good to me Mark!
COD 1dn OFF THE CUFF
WOD 4dn LEFTFIELD
Time an eon
Butcher’s (hook) is the Lunnon CRS version.
Squint is a further form.
Enjoyed 21a HAGGIS, though after making a mistake of scale when ordering one from Ocado last Burns Night and having to eat it for most meals for a week, it may be next Burns Night before I can face it again. You can have too much of a good thing…
HAGGIS is lovely (the clue, not the food, the taste of which I’m happy to let remain a mystery), but COD to HIMSELF for making me think without totally bamboozling me. Which I could say of the whole crossword. Nice.
For god’s sake, this is an outrage.
Edited at 2019-02-13 09:55 am (UTC)
Edited at 2019-02-13 09:58 am (UTC)
and not seeing JACK. Duh! The whole thing had been such a struggle that I simply threw in the towel at that point. I too was convinced about the 1942 Allied victory at Elve. HAGGIS was an instant biff. With the time ebbing away, I didn’t bother trying to parse the biffed FISH-AND-CHIP SHOP. And, of course, I thought the homophones were all entirely reasonable.
I quite enjoyed this, despite the sweat and tears it cost me.
Your blog is much appreciated, Pip. Many thanks.
I thought this was hard but fair – with some very clever disguises and misdirections.
COD: A tie. The outrageous COHABITED and the neat TIDIEST.
FOI HAGGIS (piping without hot made it a “gimme”)
LOI SOFIA – simply awful clue
COD COHABITED
TIME 22:40
Edited at 2019-02-13 11:28 am (UTC)
Thanks pip and setter.
I never did figure out DELVE: like GM I am still often fooled by the ‘key’ device, however often it comes up.
Nothing wrong with any of the homophones, though.
Thanks setter!
I thought the homophones at 1ac and 8dn were OK, but 22dn is weird.
I’m very impressed you got a Morris Minor of any description to Sofia!
Thank you, particularly for HIMSELF.
Like you, I was casting around for a famous WWII victory and ELVE was one that suggested itself!
I’m very pleased after my slog that the SNITCH rates it as 159 Very Hard.
This certainly was a hard one taking just under the two hours to fill the grid and parse them all, except the SO part of SOFIA (so subtle). I thought that YEMENI one of the better clues – simple construction in hindsight but took me a while to see through it. Liked the misdirection used in many of the definitions and was pleased when the penny dropped with JACK which I thought was in the top 3 or 4 of the clues too – especially the second part of it.
Finished in the NE quadrant with BRETON (a clever play with ‘back’ = BET ON), CELEB (well hidden from me) and DELVE (misleading surface that took an age to separate the DEL key and the VE triumph – must admit to initially looking for the ELVE battle too).