After last week’s toughie with the SNITCH at a high of 178, I was expecting even more pain with this. Maybe I was just lucky to be on a wavelength, because only 7 of 24 had it correct on the day, perhaps time was a factor and it was able to receive less attention coming third in the booklet at the end. I found it easier than 27237. Had it been in exam conditions, there was only one clue (11a) I’d have been unsure I’d entered correctly, and it took me around half an hour. There are three straightforward anagrams, a couple of messed-around ones, and the two long down clues are eminently biffable. You have to know a literary family. The rest is standard fare, as I see it.
Across | |
1 | Close to nothing in charity that’s opening (6) |
ALMOST – ALMS has O inserted, then T = that’s opening. Took a while to reverse my thinking from looking for a word meaning opening. | |
4 | Jazzy music involving musical sense is promising (8) |
SWEARING – SWING is that music, insert EAR = musical sense. | |
10 | Trivial problem to fall between aristocrat and monarch (2-7) |
NO-BRAINER – RAIN = fall, goes between NOB and ER. My FOI. | |
11 | Crack from unknown imbecile (5) |
GOOFY – Not sure I quite get this. GOOF to me means to make a mistake, or a person who makes one. Y for the unknown. I presume there is a sense in which CRACK can be a synonym for goof, as in crack under pressure, or goof can mean a joke perhaps. I was tempted by GOON-Y, goon being an imbecile, but couldn’t make that crack either. EDIT see ulaca’s proposal below. | |
12 | Desirable quality in grand name of literary siblings (7) |
SITWELL – IT is the desirable quality; enter IT into SWELL for grand. The Sitwells, I recalled, were a family of three siblings from up’t Yorkshire who were all rather arty; Edith, Osbert and the one beginning with S who’s hard to spell. Edith being the one who wrote Facade for Mr Walton to score. | |
13 | Oppressive old tyrant leading America (7) |
ONEROUS – O for old, NERO your tyrant, US. | |
14 | Marshal calm when changing side repeatedly (5) |
ARRAY – To calm would be to ALLAY; swap the LL for RR. | |
15 | A diet not designed as a remedy (8) |
ANTIDOTE – (A DIET NOT)*. | |
18 | Line that stops tongue moving, twisted in knots? (8) |
SHOELACE – Cryptic definition, easy once you’re tuned in. | |
20 | Cold dish using incomplete vessels (below and above water) (5) |
SUSHI – SU(B) and SHI(P) being the incomplete vessels referred to. | |
23 | Something ideal for jamming broadcast, in short (7) |
CURRANT – Well, I know of blackcurrant jam, and possibly redcurrant jelly, but I can’t imagine currant jam being very edible. Currants are chewy dried small grapes. Currant here presumably is used as a sort of generic for jam made from any type of that fruit or a mix. CURT = short, has RAN = broadcast inserted. | |
25 | Men concerned with later life backing part of Mediterranean diet? (7) |
OREGANO – OR = men, ON AGE = concerned with later life, reverse that. Oregano, which i pronounce oree-GAR-no, per Italian, is one of my favourite herbs, but I squirm when a transatlantic person says o-REGG-ano. Perhaps I shouldn’t, as in the original Greek word the accent is on the I, ρίγανη. | |
26 | Trader’s tip diluted small change (5) |
TWEAK – T = trader’s tip, WEAK = diluted. A nice change for small change not being currency. | |
27 | Watched and heard the writer with no hair (9) |
EYEBALLED – EYE sounds like I, BALLED sounds like BALD. | |
28 | Theatrical set, scary in play (8) |
ACTRESSY – (SET SCARY)*. Not a pretty word, but it’ll do. | |
29 | Short cannon’s middle-of-the-road rating (6) |
MORTAR – MOR = middle of the road, TAR = rating, sailor. |
Down | |
1 | Unaware of past uprising as some of America is, en masse (8) |
AMNESIAC – nicely hidden reversed in AMERI(CA IS EN MA)SSE. | |
2 | Principal substituting old boy for a family man (7) |
MOBSTER – MASTER = principal; swap the A for OB. Family man as in Mafioso. | |
3 | Rolling fat? (5,4) |
SPARE TYRE – Crptic definition. Mine needs deflating after the festivities. | |
5 | Gentle champion’s stopping stock conflicts (4,2,3,5) |
WARS OF THE ROSES – I biffed this then sorted it out. WARES is or are the stock, insert SOFT HERO’S for gentle champion’s. | |
6 | Reason males are excluded from rummage around (5) |
ARGUE – Remove males from rummage gives RU AGE, then (RUAGE)*. | |
7 | Man in promise to pay on time shows resolve (4,3) |
IRON OUT – IOU = promise to pay, insert RON the man and add T for time. | |
8 | Most like The Merry Widow being terribly stagey (6) |
GAYEST – (STAGEY)*. | |
9 | Peace group requests soldiers possibly to protect brief retreat in quarrel (14) |
UNPLEASANTNESS – UN = peace group, PLEAS = requests, ANTS = soldiers possibly, insert NES(T) = brief retreat. Or biff it. | |
16 | Outlaw’s unfeeling ring captures northbound travellers (9) |
DESPERADO – DEAD = unfeeling, O = ring, insert REPS reversed = northbound travellers. | |
17 | Complaint caused by command from detective? (8) |
DISORDER – Well, a DI’s ORDER would be a command from the detective. | |
19 | Crop top with short dart in front (7) |
HARVEST – VEST = top (not crop top this time) preceded by HAR(E) = short dart. | |
21 | Vegetable: wrap up portion (7) |
SHALLOT – SH ! = wrap up, be quiet; ALLOT = portion as a verb. | |
22 | I caught summer in Paris on a refresher (3,3) |
ICE TEA – I, C = caught, ÉTÉ = French for summer, A. | |
24 | Heel’s neighbour caused anger after undressing (5) |
ANKLE – RANKLED = caused anger, loses its ‘dressing’ i.e. front and back. |
Edited at 2019-01-09 05:43 am (UTC)
Having said that, it took an age for SHOELACE to manifest itself even with all checkers, and it may well have ended up blank had I been talented enough to have made it to the GF.
But here’s the main news – having had a couple of slips already, I invoked my New Years resolution to proof read before submitting and Actually found and corrected a typo. So not all bad.
GOOFY took a bit of understanding and got CURRANT from the cryptic – weak definition in my view. I suspect time pressure on the day was a big factor in stopping so many from solving it
At the 45 minute stage, I had an ALMOST empty NW corner, and not much else on the left of the puzzle. I spent the last 15 minutes practically becalmed. There was already one unsolved clue in Puzzle 1, and five in Puzzle 2. The effect of having then hit Puzzle 3 was akin to be being mugged.
Apart from that half of the puzzle, I didn’t solve MORTAR, and had an incorrect “goony”. That one was still unparsed until I arrived here (it’s a horrible clue, but it’s fair once you see it), and also I hadn’t parsed CURRANT fully (not struck with the “jamming” element there I’m afraid). Obviously it wasn’t spotted on the day, and left poor old me in a jam – or more accurately in the soup.
As the not very proud owner of a SPARE TYRE, I really should have got that one, but it was my failure to solve ALMOST that probably contributed more than anything to my chronic case of “left-bank stasis”.
The other unsolved answers were SITWELL, SHOELACE, TWEAK, ACTRESSY, AMNESIAC, MOBSTER, UNPLEASANTNESS, and HARVEST.
FOI NO-BRAINER (very ironic !)
LOI N/A
COD SHOELACE (with hindsight)
TIME felt like an eternity – even given an hour or more, I would still be left feeling GOOFY.
So….was it just me, or was this as horrendous as I thought at the time ?
Pah – lots of time was taken on justifying Goony, which still seems better than Goofy to me. Collins has Goony as a foolish person. And ‘go on’ could be ‘crack from’.
And time spent justifying Currant which is not something ever used in Jam.
Not great clues for a final IMHO.
Thanks setter and Pip.
Ah well, it was fun until I stalled. Thanks for the explanations!
Edited at 2019-01-09 08:51 am (UTC)
I only struggled on my last three, CURRANT, HARVEST and my LOI SHOELACE. I’m not good at spotting a cryptic definition and this was no exception.
Maybe it was a wavelength problem. I’ve reviewed all three puzzles again this morning, and I must concur with Olivia that Puzzle 2 was actually trickier than this one.
Ah well, at least I don’t have to pay for next year’s ritual humiliation.
Thanks for explaining it all, Pip.
Edited at 2019-01-09 11:49 am (UTC)
Thansk pip and setter.
At the risk of being wildly unoriginal, I put in GOOFY without understanding it, but do now; and CURRANT, which I’m still not totally convinced about. If my wife put “currants” on the shopping list, I think she’d be surprised if I came back with an assortment of summer fruits…but obviously the rules are different in Crosswordland. Otherwise, like the other Finals offerings, hard but fair.
Edited at 2019-01-09 12:14 pm (UTC)
I guess that CURRANT was referring to Blackcurrants etc.
I liked MOBSTER and the SPARE TYRE and SHOELACE cryptic defs, although I was definitely tuned out today and the latter was my last in. I agree with our blogger about ACTRESSY – not a word I hope to meet again.
Thank you to setter and blogger.
Today it took me under 11 minutes despite not finding much of it familar second time around. Knowing that SHOELACE was in there certainly helped my time. I agree with BW that the use of the questionable line and knots in a CD were a bit much.
ARRAY at 14a is probably the first and last time I’ll get an answer right that Mark Goodliffe didn’t (albeit he took about a third of my time and got many more right that I got wrong).
Usually I’m not too bothered by homophones in the crossword, but I certainly don’t pronounce BALLED and BALD the same.
Edited at 2019-01-09 03:36 pm (UTC)
Roll on next Wednesday and a new start.
It’s been a long time…
CURRANT is ridiculous, even if the setter means black- or red-. Currants are not good for jamming anything except possibly the plughole. And SHOELACE is a brilliant/horrible CD: delete according to preference.
On the other hand, AMNESIAC was as good a reverse hidden as you’d find. An odd sort of puzzle with some bright bits, easy bits and downright annoying bits. Well played, Pip, and welcome back to normality in advance of next week!
Interesting puzzle that I generally found difficulty in different spots to others. Not with 18a though, needing help to get SHOELACE (and then kicking myself for not seeing it first – a clever cd).
Although had written in the answers for MORTAR and SHALLOT – couldn’t fully parse them – not thinking of ‘rating’ as a sailor and having not heard of the phrase ‘wrap up’ to mean “Be quiet!” They were my second and third last in. GOOFY was last and was pleased when the penny dropped with the parsing.