I see 84 contestants attempted this and 33 got it correct. So, not a piece of cake. I got it right eventually, but not under exam room presssure.
I found this a game of two halves. The RHS went in reasonably smoothly, after a couple of minutes reading through and finding little by way of easy clues to get me going. 4a was my FOI. It didn’t then help that I had at first put in RUMINATE for 8d, before seeing the fishy mathematician at 16a.The LHS took longer, but in retrospect I can’t see why, there is nothing too nasty about it, I just wasn’t on song. Nowhere near a 20 minute romp which I’d have needed on the day.
Maybe because of the lack of on-song mood, verging on headache, I didn’t particularly enjoy this, but it is noteworthy for having a Yiddish word I actually knew, which is probably a first.
I found this a game of two halves. The RHS went in reasonably smoothly, after a couple of minutes reading through and finding little by way of easy clues to get me going. 4a was my FOI. It didn’t then help that I had at first put in RUMINATE for 8d, before seeing the fishy mathematician at 16a.The LHS took longer, but in retrospect I can’t see why, there is nothing too nasty about it, I just wasn’t on song. Nowhere near a 20 minute romp which I’d have needed on the day.
Maybe because of the lack of on-song mood, verging on headache, I didn’t particularly enjoy this, but it is noteworthy for having a Yiddish word I actually knew, which is probably a first.
Across | |
1 | Deliberate snatching is bad treatment (6) |
MISUSE – MUSE = deliberate, snatches IS inside. | |
4 | Brilliant odds before racehorse runs (8) |
SPARKLER – SP = odds, ARKLE was a racehorse of note, R = runs. | |
10 | One who has it may quickly lose it (5,4) |
SHORT FUSE – cryptic def. | |
11 | Perhaps a sett … the setter’s material (5) |
DENIM – DEN = perhaps a sett, which is a badger’s den; I’M = the setter’s. | |
12 | General grounds for curtailment (3) |
LEE – I think this is LEES = grounds, as in coffee for example, curtailed. | |
13 | Lumières can’t broadcast without a place to show all their work? (11) |
MULTISCREEN – Anagram of (LUMIERES C NT)*, the A you are told to omit. | |
14 | The endless growth in snooker (6) |
THWART – TH(E), WART = growth. I think snooker has a more specific definition than ‘thwart’. | |
16 | Man responsible for distribution of toxin around centre of Salisbury (7) |
POISSON – If you didn’t do any statistics or A Level maths, you could still get to the answer from word play I think. POISON = toxin, has S the middle of Salisbury, inserted. Poisson was a French chap who understood about statistical distributions, which I can just about remember learning about, and he also had a Series (or series of series?) named after him, which I never got to grips with. | |
19 | A beastly mother keeping literary retrospective for gifted child (7) |
MATILDA – A DAM = a beastly mother, holds on to LIT, then all reversed. Matilda is the title of a book by Roald Dahl about a gifted child. | |
20 | Detective Gadget succeeded inside the CID, for example (6) |
SENSOR – S inside SENOR. I am thinking, here SENOR = CID in so far as El Cid was a Spanish señor or Lord. Have I missed the plot? | |
22 | One who introduces expert on Browning? (11) |
TOASTMASTER – Cryptic DD, where a toast master would be good at making brown toast. | |
25 | Attempt retiring (3) |
SHY – DD. | |
26 | One might see spider on this: howls out loud? (5) |
BAIZE – BAIZE sounds like BAYS = howls; a reference to an elongated rest device used on a snooker table, which is of course baize covered. | |
27 | Categorise works evading understanding, ultimately as such (9) |
ESOTERICA – Anagram of (CATE ORISE)* where the G is omitted as instructed by “evading understandinG ultimately”. “As such” referring to the surface meaning. | |
28 | Occasion that is wrapping up day (8) |
EVENTIDE – Cryptic definition that took me ages to see, after lots of present-giving festivals had come and gone. EDIT there’s more to this, see parsing by our friend ejected from Bletchley, second comment below. | |
29 | A carriage heading for Scottish cathedral city (6) |
AMIENS – I had this quickly, as we pass by the city on the way to Calais often enough, but it could be tricky if you’re not hot on French geography. A, MIEN = carriage, S = heading for Scottish. |
Down | |
1 | Might Mark blitz clues? (6) |
MUSCLE – M, (CLUES)*. a simple clue I made difficult. | |
2 | Singer’s second discussion about sound quality? (9) |
STONECHAT – S = second, TONE CHAT = discussion about sound quality, if you like. Know your birds to succeed at crosswords. | |
3 | She’s short with pot belly — that’s Mum! (5) |
SHTUM – SH(E), TUM = pot belly. Keep shtum = be quiet, you shmuck. | |
5 | Bent coppers splitting up, say (14) |
PREDISPOSITION – Parsed after the event. DIS = coppers, splits PREPOSITION, of which UP is an example. | |
6 | Censorship of the October Revolution? (9) |
REDACTION – RED ACTION being a way to describe what went on in November 1917. | |
7 | Move impetuously to sacrifice pawn and foil attack? (5) |
LUNGE – PLUNGE = move impetuously, loses a P. LUNGE as in a fencing move with a foil. | |
8 | Harry Truman taking on board current thinking (8) |
RUMINANT – (TRUMAN)* takes an IN inside, IN being current. Thinking as a participle adjective, as in ‘the thinking man’. | |
9 | Comprehensive school’s first XI linked up with a top forward (4,5,5) |
FULL STEAM AHEAD – FULL = comprehensive, S = school’s first; TEAM = XI; A HEAD = a top. | |
15 | Frequently outspoken on males: time for a quota (9) |
ALLOTMENT – ALLOT sounds like A LOT = frequently; MEN for males; T for time. | |
17 | Evergreen explorer cut down in front of Resolution (5,4) |
SCOTS PINE – SCOTT the polar explorer chap loses his last S, then SPINE = resolution. | |
18 | I am one member of nest maybe suited to parrots (8) |
IMITABLE – I am = I’M I (= ONE) TABLE, as small tables can come in a nest where they all fit one on the other. Why do they call them Occasional Tables? We use ours all the time. | |
21 | Major operation as Times each year put on finals of puzzles championships (6) |
BYPASS – BY = Times, multiplied by; PA = each year, S S = end letters of puzzles championships. A timely reference in the surface. | |
23 | Cast me in a film (5) |
ANIME – (ME IN A)*. Anime is some sort of a Japanese cartoon genre I believe. | |
24 | Discharge suspect concealing high explosive (5) |
RHEUM – RUM = suspect, insert HE for the explosive stuff. The word RHEUM always makes me think of Peter Sellers as Clouseau asking for a rheum. That was great stuff. Toodle Pip! |
It was very satisfying to work out the unknown POISSON. I failed fully to parse IMITABLE and PREDISPOSITION but was confident of my answers. I still don’t see how ‘brilliant’ = SPARKLER as I would have expected SPARKLING.
Edited at 2018-12-05 06:28 am (UTC)
I parsed EVENTIDE as ‘Occasion’ = EVENT and ‘that is wrapping up day’= I(D)E, so it’s a bit &littish. I couldn’t parse SENSOR or LEE.
I enjoyed this and was disappointed not to finish correctly. STONECHAT goes in as a new avian acquaintance and I loved the surface for SHTUM.
My pick was ANIME, mainly because it reminded me of a film called “Porco Rosso” by Miyazaki. Magic stuff.
Thanks to setter and blogger.
I guess it must have been a chewy one, as even having solved it on the day, it still took 15 minutes this morning.
Edited at 2018-12-05 07:45 am (UTC)
Wasn’t Poisson distribution discovered by Jesus?
All correct within the hour would have been good enough for a top 25 finish and a free place next year.
I snuck into the final in 12th place with a combined time of 46:30 or thereabouts so any quicker than that for all 3 puzzles would have been good enough to make the final.
A sparkler of a puzzle: good mix of interesting words, good mix of clue types, good jokes (Browning) and topical references. Brilliant stuff.
The only blemish is the CID=Senor thing which was my LOI and took ages.
Mostly I liked: Bypass and Poisson (COD).
Thanks brilliant setter and Pip.
Edited at 2018-12-05 08:58 am (UTC)
There seems to be a growing tendency recently for setters to play fast and loose with punctuation, capitalisation etc. Nobody would write “the CID” for El Cid, not even Charlton Heston. I don’t like to put constraints on setters, they have enough to put up with with Ximenes so I will grin and bear it; but I’m not very keen on it.
A very good puzzle but CID for SENOR does seem a bit of a stretch and grounds and LEES are not the same thing at all.
Edited at 2018-12-05 09:10 am (UTC)
Things I didn’t know: STONECHAT (though my revision words include “wheatear”, which is a type of chat, so that helped); Arkle; lees; that MATILDA was a prodigy; anything about AMIENS, including that it has a cathedral.
Thank you for the parsings, Pip! I especially needed 5d PREDISPOSITION explaining, as I was fixated on the coppers being the “p” at the beginning.
Edited at 2018-12-05 09:30 am (UTC)
Seems like I’ve been down this way before.
Edited at 2018-12-05 09:58 am (UTC)
Edited at 2018-12-05 09:57 am (UTC)
CID for El Cid is not to my liking
Long standing readers will know from a previous blog that it was Poisson’s sister Avril who was the real female brains behind her brother
Well blogged Pip and thank you setter
I’m pretty sure it wasn’t puzzle 3, because I recall leaving it, and returning to get the last three answers.
FOI SPARKLER
BIFF POISSON which was a DNK
LOI SENSOR (the other hold up was the the crossing of BYPASS and ESOTERICA)
COD POISSON for its topicality, but also enjoyed SHORT FUSE
TIME not noted, but average of around 15 minutes per puzzle.
Pip : thanks for the (as ever) excellent blog, but the puzzle number in the heading should read 27,213 not 27,195.
Phil Jordan
I’d managed to forget the Dahl MATILDA (even though it was a successful Broadway show) in favour of Belloc’s little liar who shouted “fire fire”. Statues of Robert E. Lee (and removal of same) have become flashpoints around the Southern US. It looks as if I’ve been misusing SNOOKER in that context all these years. A very un-championship 23.31
P.S. For those who have access, David Parfitt has a comment on CID on today’s Club Forum.
Edited at 2018-12-05 11:19 am (UTC)
Come to think of it I biffed them again today. Ho hum.
Thanks Pip and setter for very nice work.
I breezed through the LHS and froze on the right. I did Statistics for A-level, so in theory POISSON should be a write in, but our teachers very rarely showed up and I still have nightmares about complete lack of preparation for the exams (I still got an A). I had a stab with POSTMAN: an &littish version of the clue with a distributor of toxin being a POTMAN (a bit harsh on alcohol, perhaps) and of course the centre of SaliSbury implanted. Neither Alexander Petrov nor Ruslan Boshirov seemed to fit (though they certainly did) in this cleverly themed clue. In the end I assumed a MAN is a species of french fish I haven’t heard of, which it might be. Somewhere.
I struggled with the obvious anagram of A SETT in 11, of which there are an annoying number, but none of them were material to the setter: no gelling agent, for example, not the Sun, not concrete and on an on.
No idea of what was happening in SENSOR, which seems common enough experience. If CID was misleadingly capitalised, shouldn’t it have been THE as well?
PREDISPOSITION I parsed as copper P, plus re-dis-position which might, in one of those Uxbridge definitions, mean separation. Well, it might.
I rather think this crossword in a daily effort would have been regarded as brilliant with time to solve and savour; as a competition piece it’s a demoralising B’stard. Thanks setter (I think) and brilliant work Pip.
Edited at 2018-12-05 11:49 am (UTC)
Furthermore, surely El Cid, being a prince of the realm and other things noble, would have been anything but a Señor. I like your parallel with Mr Beowulf.
Mind you, it’s also all about the environment, isn’t it…I can see how my feelings might have differed if I’d been presented with this on Finals Day, rather than at my kitchen table with a nice cup of tea.
P.S. Today’s unlikely ear-worm: the theme from Inspector Gadget.
Joint COD to 16a and 21d which I think are simply superlative examples of the setter’s art.
Thanks Pip for the blog.
At the time I remember appreciating the Browning clue.
PREDISPOSITION took me some time on the day, although it was SPARKLER that gave me the most grief because I’d never heard of the horse and couldn’t figure out the definition. In the end it was the only plausible entry I could think of, so I bunged it in and threw up my hand.
I thought this was a great puzzle, with POISSON my COD, although TOASTMASTER, ESOTERICA & EVENTIDE were also excellent. And I enjoyed the slyly self-referential 21d.
Fortunately I’d misspelt BAIZE recently in the daily, so was able to correct myself on the day of the finals.
Incidentally, Pip, “schmuck” definitely has a C in it (well, two in fact), in common with many other derogatory sch- words from Yiddish such as schlemiel, schmozzle, schlamazel and schmutz. Or, indeed, scholar.
Edited at 2018-12-05 05:24 pm (UTC)
I loved it.
Loved the blog, too. Thanks.
Crikey, this was tough. I did it in two bits, either side of walking the dog, and it took me at least an hour.
I studied Corneille’s Le Cid at A Level and university, so 20 across went in with a shrug.
I was just happy to finish without any errors.
Chapeau to everyone who completed this in the Championship.
Dave.
Ordinary bloke
I’m not sure there isn’t more to the clue. “Cid” means something rather close to both Sir and Señor, as I find in Wikipedia:
The word Cid originates from Arabic sidi or sayyid (سيد), an honorific title similar to English Sir (in the medieval, courtly sense).
The commonly used title El Cantar de mio Cid means literally The Song of my Lord or The Poem of my Lord. As the original title of the poem is lost to history, this one was suggested by historian Ramón Menéndez Pidal. It is Old Spanish (old Castilian), adjusted to modern orthography. In modern Spanish the title might be rendered El Poema de mi Señor or El Poema de mi Jefe. The expression cantar (literally “to sing”) was used to mean a chant or a song. The word Cid (Çid in old Spanish orthography), was a derivation of the dialectal Arabic word سيد sîdi or sayyid, which means lord or master.
IMITABLE was my guess, but as I didn’t know about nested tables, so I didn’t write it in, or I might’ve seen, eventually, BAIZE—if I hadn’t decided this morning to just put myself out of my misery and come here.
Edited at 2018-12-05 11:21 pm (UTC)