Apparently 36 out of 90 entrants got this one correct, of whom 22 found time to finish the other two puzzles correctly in the hour or less. I was not feeling the brightest, having already done two other puzzles hanging over from the weekend, but I managed to finish it in an unacceptable 39 minutes, in line with the feedback that this year’s selection were a grade harder than recent years.
I struggled with the SW corner, although in retrospect that bit isn’t any more difficult than the rest. The brand names at 18d and 20d threw me, I didn’t realise such things were permitted.
I struggled with the SW corner, although in retrospect that bit isn’t any more difficult than the rest. The brand names at 18d and 20d threw me, I didn’t realise such things were permitted.
Across | |
1 | After silence, hands round the writer’s contract (7) |
SHRIVEL – SH ! = silence!, R and L (hands) go round I’VE = the writer’s. | |
5 | Many dogs taking the lead off (6) |
OODLES – POODLES loses its P. An easy one for people like us who for many years were standard poodle owners. | |
8 | Twirling, maybe the ladies one saw approved (9) |
VALIDATED – LAV (maybe the ladies) reversed – VAL; I DATED = I saw. Not LOO for once. | |
9 | Great Britain’s flipping harsh (5) |
ACERB – ACE = great, BR reversed. | |
11 | Vehicle broken by butcher’s van in badly neglected state (5) |
LIMBO – LIMO vehicle, insert a B the ‘van’ of butcher’s. The definition seems a bit of a stretch, but I suppose anything more exact would give the game away. | |
12 | Venture into Microsoft’s domain is trouble for corporation (9) |
ENTERITIS – To venture into Microsoft’s domain could be to ENTER IT, then add IS. Corporation as in tummy. | |
13 | Particular sin, snatching diamonds from the east (8) |
ESPECIAL – LAPSE = sin, holds ICE = diamonds, all reversed. | |
15 | Wit’s heartless riposte wounded (6) |
ESPRIT – (RIP STE)*, the O being removed ‘heartless’. Another stretchy definition, IMO. | |
17 | Withdraw money that’s regularly paid to carry around (6) |
RECANT – I took too long to see this one, even with the initial R. RENT is money regularly paid, it ‘carries’ CA = around. | |
19 | Knight, travelling far, is in China (8) |
PARSIFAL – I don’t know why, because I’m not a big Wagner fan, but Parsifal sprang to mind immediately when I saw knight, not the usual N or KT. (FAR IS)* goes inside PAL = China. | |
22 | Primary colour nobody’s drawing in (6,3) |
NUMBER ONE – A simple clue I tried to make more complicated. UMBER a colour is drawn into NONE. | |
23 | Spray bound to release nitrogen (5) |
SPRIG – SPRING = bound, releases its N. | |
24 | Do away with Times editorial’s introduction (5) |
ERASE – Another simple clue I made hard work of. Too much time spent with X and BY for Times and trying to get to WASTE from ‘with’. ERAS are times, add E being initial letter of editorial. | |
25 | Vessel’s sharp, turning and heading for army bases (9) |
SUBSTRATA – This popped up as soon as I saw it ended in A. SUB = vessel, TART reversed, add A = heading for army. | |
26 | Cereal, tons on ground mostly (6) |
MILLET – MILLED = ground, delete the D and add the T for tons. | |
27 | Apt to see red snake, in fancy (7) |
WASPISH – Probably my favourite clue today. ASP = snake, inside WISH = fancy. Deceptive definition at first. |
Down | |
1 | Bad sign, boarding Sierra to travel around, one may end up in jam (7,6) |
SEVILLE ORANGE – EVIL (bad) LEO (sign) inside S, RANGE = travel around. I had to get some checkers before this one, which held up the LHS for a while. Of course Seville oranges are in marmalade not usually in jam, but that would have been too easy. | |
2 | Cold food after bread is shock (7) |
ROLLMOP – ROLL = bread, MOP = shock, as in a mop of hair. I have eaten warm rollmops, in Sweden, but perhaps they’re not then called rollmops. | |
3 | Record kept by Crusoe, divided up (5) |
VIDEO – Reversed hidden in CRUS(OE DIV)IDED. | |
4 | Christian left university and rushed to pen article (8) |
LUTHERAN – L, U, THE (article), RAN (rushed). | |
5 | Offbeat individual note lifted song, not a tango (6) |
ODDITY – DO = note, lifted = OD, DITTY = song, lose one T. | |
6 | What’s in Brontë novel read twice is inspiring English (9) |
DIAERESIS – (READ IS IS)*, then insert an E. Now I know how to spell it. The French call it a tréma, as in Citroën, which is easier to spell. | |
7 | Medical department that constantly admits horseman (7) |
EVENTER – The evergreen ENT goes inside EVER = constantly. | |
10 | Black grape intertwined with the lush grapevine (4,9) |
BUSH TELEGRAPH – (B GRAPE THE LUSH)*. | |
14 | Gull, say, overturned angler’s device to get fish (6,3) |
CONGER EEL – CON = gull, trick; GE = EG say overturned, REEL = angler’s device. | |
16 | What some musicians do before and after concert? (4,1,3) |
TAKE A BOW – Cryptic definition, easiest clue of the day. | |
18 | Intoxicating substance affected air supply (7) |
CAMPARI – As noted above, I was not looking for a brand name so took an age to get this my LOI. CAMP = affected, (AIR)*. Not sure about supply as an anagrind. | |
20 | Car to go wrong on a boring day (7) |
FERRARI – ERR = to go wrong, and A, go inside (bore) FRI = day. | |
21 | Back supporter in my place (6) |
CORSET – COR! = my!, SET = place. I was slow to see this in spite of having CORSET crop up as a sort of underwear in Monday’s puzzle. It wasn’t easy to see what the definition was going to be here. | |
23 | Places quotes from speakers (5) |
SITES – Sound like CITES = quotes. |
My only unknown was ESPRIT as ‘wit’ rather than ‘spirit’ although the former is quite clearly a valid definition and possibly even the principal meaning according to some of the usual sources. I also looked twice at WASPISH as ‘apt to see red’ as it’s not quite my interpretation of the word, but once again the dictionaries seem happy with it.
Like Pip, I also wondered about the brand names.
Edited at 2018-11-14 06:07 am (UTC)
All three correct in an hour would comfortably have secured a top 25 finish and a free pass for next year.
CS Lewis has a nice 25-page on essay on ‘Wit’ in his Studies in Words: ‘Anglo-Saxon wit or gewit is mind, reason, intelligence. Rational creatures are those to whom God has given wit.’
Edited at 2018-11-14 06:47 am (UTC)
30 mins to have 2 left (6dn/15ac) and feeling good. Then a pleasant 15 mins recalling everything I know about the Brontes: pseudonyms, titles, characters, themes, the brother, the parsonage. But only “Diatribes” would fit and it didn’t work with the wordplay. I tried a Read,is,is anagram but there are far too many vowels.
Oh well, at least I learnt something.
I have had Orange Jam in France and I really liked it. It is rare in the UK, like good Lime Marmalade, except the delicious version from Lewis and Cooper (Northallerton).
Thanks setter and Pip
Shame, as with the rest of the puzzle I’d rather surprised myself by my instincts consistently turning out to be right, often coming back to the first answer I’d thought of and then figuring out why the wordplay worked.
Had to check spelling of 6D but other than that all within my compass. I’ve also had orange jam and agree its very good. Brilliant work setter and well blogged Pip
Edit: wrong puzzle! As Philip points out below this was the second puzzle, not the first as I assumed. So it actually took me about 15 minutes. My other comments stand though: I completed the three puzzles in order this year, which is unusual.
Edited at 2018-11-14 10:34 am (UTC)
Also thrown a bit by the brand names – never allowed in the past, except Times. Then Murdoch’s other media started sneaking in, Sun and Sky. Then other media – I seem to remember Mirror, Express and Al-Jazeera in the answers. But random brands like Ferrari and Campari were definitely barred until very recently. Certainly verboten 10 years back, when Peter Biddlecombe explained the Times’ style.
https://times-xwd-times.livejournal.com/174088.html
I an not going to go hunting, but there have been brand names in the daily cryptics for quite a few years now, on occasion.
DIRE ‘E SAYS was the killer, umlaut barely visible on the screen and all that complicated anagramming.
Three brand names (Microsoft™ in the clue) in one crossword suggest sponsorship, though CAMPARI was slightly unfairly clued as intoxicating substance: I mean it is, but some people think it also tastes nice. Like defining FERRARI as air polluter.
Maybe next year.
This was puzzle 2 and I managed 22/30 clues correctly. Those I missed were Oodles, Enteritis, Parsifal, Substrata, Oddity, Diaeresis, Corset and Ferrari. I think all were solvable given more time – except Diaeresis. I don’t even recall the Oddity, Substrata and Corset clues.
COD: FERRARI.
Thank you, Pip, for a thorough blog.
This is actually Puzzle 2 from Preliminary 1, and I tackled the three of them with stopwatch and notes at home on the Monday. I completed all three in 39:36, and Puzzles 2 and 3 were done in a single pass. The total time was around three minutes faster than my time on the day for Preliminary 2.
Marques of car now seem to be fair game (see also AUDI recently), so FERRARI is OK by me, whilst CAMPARI has become a generic term in the same way as HOOVER or FRIGIDAIRE, so no complaints there either.
I had to be very careful with the typo trap that was DIAERESIS.
FOI OODLES
LOI CORSET
COD VALIDATED
TIME 14:16
Those of you who found this particularly difficult are really going to tear your hair out when the Final puzzles appear. I’m off now to source a wig.
Edited at 2018-11-14 10:01 am (UTC)
Were the puzzles in each heat numbered 1, 2 and 3, or just a pile of 3 puzzles? As it is the first one published, took it to be ‘number 1’ although it’s academic if you get three all at once to do in any order you wish. How will I know if next week’s is number 1 or number 3?
Pip
The puzzles are indeed numbered, and if you turn the booklet over when you start, you’ll probably start with number 3. I used to do that, but recently I’ve taken to opening the booklet and starting with number 1. You’d be most unlikely to start with number 2 because it’s either inside the booklet, or on the right hand page !
Edited at 2018-11-14 12:21 pm (UTC)
Anyway, to answer Penfold’s question, my time for all three was around 50 minutes. In previous years, I’ve clocked more like 40 to finish in roughly the same position, which adds weight to the general belief that the puzzles this year were slightly tougher than average.
Edited at 2018-11-14 10:54 am (UTC)
Your animadversion on ESPRIT surprised me, you being a francophone; after all, there’s eg. ‘l’esprit de l’escalier’. And–I don’t think anyone else has mentioned this, if they have, apologies–I took ‘supply’ to be ‘in a supple way’; it’s been done before.
I was in preliminary 2, and while I took away a copy of the P1 puzzles I haven’t looked at them.
Had I been faced with this on the day, I would have been staring at DIAERESIS all morning, so clearly wouldn’t have done any better!
This was a fairly advanced puzzle, but everything else was clear enough.
https://www.dailywritingtips.com/not-an-umlaut/
https://www.independent.co.uk/voices/letter-were-they-bronte-by-accident-of-accent-1431677.html
It seems to me, rightly or wrongly, they or he the dad added the diathingy to stop it being Bront. And maybe there was anti French (accent) attitude at the time. I am perhaps about to begin my long overdue Ph.D. diss on the subject. Well, not that long.
I was fine with the ESPRIT definition but I did wonder a bit about those for LIMBO and CORSET. The latter I think of as more of a way to shrink the corporation or squash it into shape. Oh and I also wasted time looking at “shrink” in 1a.
P.S. Speaking of corsets and the Guardian, I see in today’s Pasquale we have: 7D “My group getting back support.” I wonder if he was the setter – his alter ego is Don Manley.
Edited at 2018-11-14 12:08 pm (UTC)
CAMPARI and FERRARI: brand names? Does anyone have the official information on whether or not brand names are okay in Times puzzles? I can see how campari may indicate all manner of similar concoctions, but a Ferrari is a Ferrari is a Ferrari, is it not.
Thanks pip and setter.
RR
My main hold ups were OODLES, ESPECIAL and SUBSTRATA
Haha! No chance …..
I worked my way through this fairly steadily and, although I realised what was going on with 6 Down, I had to check the spelling before putting it in.
If you asked me again tomorrow how to spell it, I would have to look it up again.
Time: All correct in 54 minutes.
Thank you to setter and blogger.
Dave.
Of course there is no way I could actually sensibly compete in the Championship, so I am not tempted even to try.
Edited at 2018-11-14 10:00 pm (UTC)
Having solved it, I came here to find out how I’d done so, since there was much biffing. SEVILLE ORANGE, DIAERESIS, and few others went in sans parsing. PARSIFAL went in only because it fit the available letters – I still have no idea what it means. I did, however, manage to parse it afterwards. DIAERESIS was particularly nail-biting, since I didn’t spot the anagram and had “diacritical” in my mind, narrowly missing the bastard offspring “diacresis”.
Incidentally, why isn’t there a diaeresis in DIAËRESIS?