There will be no time and no music today, because I had to solve this on the train on the way home from New York City, and I had to give up after an hour with one unsolved. When I returned to the puzzle later, I decided to go for a likely answer and biffed it, without being able to make much of the cryptic. In the end, my solution turned out to be correct.
My solve was an interesting example of getting to a correct solution without really knowing everything that is needed to solve this puzzle. I had a hard time getting started, and several of the clues were definitely a stretch. Taking a hint from Jeremy, without completely altering my blogging style, I’m going to go into a little more detail than usual about how I managed to solve some of the more challenging ones. Anyone moving up from the Quickie to the main puzzle is eventually going to run into some more difficult puzzles, and developing a good technique will enable you to solve them….eventually.
Across | |
1 | Block entrance to office used by surgeon (4) |
VETO – VET + O[ffice]. Not obvious because of the word order, and skipped over until crossing letters became available. | |
3 | Having several parties subsequently in action (10) |
TRILATERAL – TRI(LATER)AL. It seems perfectly simple, but I was fixated on BI and THEN. Once I tried LATER, it became obvious….but that was much later. | |
9 | Keys a morbid type reportedly kept in lightweight anorak (7) |
CAGOULE – C(A GOUL)E. One of my last ones in, and very difficult. With all the checkers, I realized that C and E were the keys, and you want A G_U_ in the middle. But what? I considered ‘a glum’, but ‘glum’ is not a noun and doesn’t sound like ‘glum’, it is ‘glum’. Eventually, another word rang a vague bell in the back of my mind, although if you had asked me what a ‘cagoule’ is before I started solving I would have had no idea. The other possible meanings of ‘lightweight anorak’ offer additional chances for confusion, but here ‘anorak’ actually refers to an anorak. | |
11 | Small network I’m working to turn around (7) |
NOMINAL – LAN + I’M + ON backwards. I had biffed ‘minimal’, but couldn’t get it to work, so I just started writing in likely equivalents from right to left, read out what I had, and there it was! | |
12 | Intimidates thirty, having change of heart? (9) |
THREATENS – THRE(-e,+A) TENS. I saw at once there must be some fancy synonym for ‘thirty’, but I actually biffed the answer from the checkers and worked backwards. | |
13 | Broadcast protected by company’s capital (5) |
CAIRO – C(AIR)O, one of the useful starter clues that went straight in – there weren’t many of them. | |
14 | Welding substance damaging on eye? Exactly (12) |
OXYACETYLENE – Anagram of ON EYE? EXACTLY. I saw this was an anagram, but the two Y’s and an X gave me pause. It was only when I got the first letter from the crossing word that I realized what it must be. | |
18 | Camp fellow frames conditions covering posh wrapping material (6,6) |
BUTTER MUSLIN -BUT(TERM(U)S)LIN. The most difficult clue, IMO, the dreaded obscure answer with an obscure cryptic – obscure to me, anyway. An early attempt to put ‘ifs’ around U was not successful, but when I had more crossers I saw it must be ‘terms’ around U, and that the last word was probably ‘muslin’. I thought of ‘butter muslin’ almost at once, but I still trawled through the alphabet in search of a better answer. But in the end, I supposed that if there is cheesecloth, then butter muslin might exist as well, and I was right. Of course, if you live in the UK and know who Billy Butlin was, the whole thing is much easier. | |
21 | Hope and believe this is bound to be heard (5) |
TRUST – sounds like TRUSSED. I was hung up on ‘tied’ until I got the first and last letter. | |
22 | Deliver additional note about island clubs (9) |
EXTRICATE – EXTR(I,C)A + TE. A lot of possibilities in a short clue, but once you think of ‘extra’ it really can’t be anything else. | |
24 | First-class bishop, single chap, backing state (7) |
NAMIBIA – A1 B, I MAN all backwards. Another one where you will be rewarded by meekly following the instructions. | |
25 | Suffering fever, knight concealed torment (7) |
ANGUISH – A(N)GUISH. A write-in for me, because I just solved the same clue in another puzzle, I can’t remember where. | |
26 | S African native — worker in Francis Bret’s time? (10) |
HARTEBEEST – HARTE(BEE)’S T. I saw ‘worker’ and ‘South Africa’ and saw immediately what the answer must be. Bret Harte was a 19th-century American writer, for those who don’t recognize him. He had to change the spelling of his name from ‘Hart’ in order to get the clue to work. | |
27 | Fish trap creepy duke put out (4) |
WEIR – WEIR[d], a chestnut, and my FOI. I had to search the whole puzzle to find an easy one! |
Down | |
1 | Calling out initially for last of tea in break (8) |
VOCATION – V(-a,+O)CATION. I saw that this was a letter-substitution clue, but I needed a little help to figure out what the word to operate on was. The -tion’ ending was sufficient, and the initial V allowed me to get VETO as well.. | |
2 | Stone the writer picked up after row about golf (8) |
TIGEREYE – TI(G)ER + EYE, sounds like I. I spotted the TIGER part quickly enough, but wasn’t sure about the rest until I got the crossing Y. | |
4 | Magistrate constantly upset about illegal drug (5) |
REEVE – EVE(E)R upside-down, a compendium of crossword cliches leading to one of our favorite magistrates, along with the doge. | |
5 | Concerning two bodies jointly travelling in a Rolls round university (9) |
LUNISOLAR – Anagram of IN A ROLLS around U. Another toughie, and at first I played RR around U. Or maybe ‘rolls’ are the sort that are served with dinner, which could lead to all kinds of possibilities. Eventually, the checkers made it clear this must be an anagram, but even with all the checkers it was very difficult to place the remaining letters. I juggled a U, an I, and an O, and eventually I found it. | |
6 | Taking a while polishing off porridge? (4-9) |
TIME-CONSUMING – TIME + CONSUMING, in the prison-sentence sense of ‘porridge’. I thought this might be a cryptic definition for ‘life sentence’, which fortunately does not fit, but managed to get it eventaully. | |
7 | Managed to get record, holding second of rivals off (6) |
RANCID – RAN + C([r]I[vals])D. You would think by now that the setters would know that a CD is not a record, particularly with all the LP and EP clues that keep popping up. | |
8 | Proceed lumberingly and see ballot set up (6) |
LOLLOP – LO + POLL upside down. An easy one; clearly, LO and POLL must be involved in some combination, but it is not clear whether to invert one or both, so this took several tries. | |
10 | Female noble gripped by message defying explanation (13) |
UNACCOUNTABLE – UNA + C(COUNT)ABLE. Another one that should have been easy, but since the second C is the crosser, it is easy to suppose that the girl must be four letters, ruling out the obvious UNA. I got around to the idea that there must be two C’s only after trying a lot of four-letter females and four-letter nobles. | |
15 | Petite gal skipping small part of book (5,4) |
TITLE PAGE – Anagram of PETITE GAL, a relatively simple clue. | |
16 | Like lime perhaps from prickly plant in winding lane (8) |
ALKALINE – AL(IKALI)NE, where the outside is an anagram of LANE. I couldn’t think of an appropriate prickly plant, and in the end just biffed it. ‘Kali’ is probably more familiar as either a Hindu goddess or a Linux distro. | |
17 | Loose article pinched by ’awker, perhaps? (8) |
UNTETHER – UNTE(THE)R, i.e. the stage cockney’s version of ‘hunter’. | |
19 | Stink son on Web kicked up, about hackers primarily (6) |
STENCH – S + NET upside-down + C + H[ackers], a very convoluted clue, but the answer is obvious. | |
20 | Portion of flavourful marine bird (6) |
FULMAR – hidden in [faith]FUL MAR[ine], a bird I had only vaguely heard of. | |
23 | Athenian courtesan doing for certain Asians (5) |
THAIS – Double definition. Thaïs is a courtesan in an opera by Massenet, but she is Alexandrian, not Athenian. However, few solvers are likely to know or care. |
Edited at 2018-11-05 04:47 am (UTC)
Thanks, vinyl, for the blog (with additional detail :-). And to the setter for an interesting challenge.
The list needed to be refreshed, as new solvers have come on board and others have stopped solving online. Interestingly, although I’ve added over 30 new reference solvers, the NITCH values for each day remain remarkably consistent. I did some detailed checking for the 20 crosswords in October and the alignment (old vs new NITCH values) was very close.
There seems to be an error: Bret Harte’s original name was Francis Brett—two Ts—Hart.
Could it have been allowed in the Championships one wonders!
One thing that remains unexplaned is what ‘small’ is doing in 15dn.
Of course I didn’t know it, but I’ve since read that ‘Thais of Athens’ is an historical novel by Ian Efremov published in 1972. According to the blurb, Thais was an Athenian who later travelled to Egypt and became the mistress, possibly even the wife, of Ptolemy and bore him several children.
Edited at 2018-11-05 06:21 am (UTC)
I used to own a Cagoule (the shame). I worked out which ‘bodies’ and therefore where to put the vowels in Lunisolar. DNK Kali. Worked out Butter Muslin and even guessed 23dn might be Thais. BUT I was forced into submission by the DNKs: Beest, nor Bret.
Thanks setter and Vinyl.
“Nor am I in the least
Like that dreadful HARTEBEEST.
Gno,gno, gno I’m a gnu”
I wasn’t able to come here earlier although I did this puzzle yesterday with my morning cuppa as usual. I knew all the GK except for LUNISOLAR which became obvious from the definition as I struggled with the anagram. 34 minutes. Ann
Thanks vinyl and setter.
I’ve pasted the write up of the championships from today’s Times in the championships thread: https://times-xwd-times.livejournal.com/2035022.html
COD: Anguish.
I didn’t find this easy but got through it OK. Butter muslin (a familiar material to the Heyer groupies) last in and only parsed after biffing it.
Edited at 2018-11-05 09:57 am (UTC)
Clever letter sub clues like 1d and 12a usually get a thumbs up from me, even if 12a (three tens!) had a random letter substitution.
Francis Bret(t) Hart(e) would have been tricky in a TLS, but I got the “dreadful” HARTEBEEST from the South African reference. Curiously, the spelling may be S African in style, but varieties are found in much of the continent, where to the local predators it’s known as “lunch”.
BUTTER MUSLIN was my last in on definition only: I regret not taking the time to tease out the wordplay, as “camp fellow” was delicious.
Did others think “lime – acid, surely?”.
And thanks to the setter for the anagram for OXYACETYLENE: I’d have had no chance with the spelling otherwise.
And (again) much appreciation for the expansive blog which this crossword merited and beginners and old hands alike can benefit from.
Edited at 2018-11-05 09:59 am (UTC)
FOI CAIRO
LOI WEIR (I can’t concur with Vinyl1 on this being a chestnut, but I’m sure it will have appeared before).
Thanks to Vinyl1 for parsing my DNK’s, which were LUNISOLAR (obvs !), the prickly part of ALKALINE, and the ridiculously obscure reference in HARTEBEEST, and also for BUTTER MUSLIN where Sir Billy had passed me by.
I don’t believe I was stuck for ages with TRUST, and never realised until now that TIGEREYE was a single word.
COD THREATENS (answer pertinent to my Final performance ANGUISH !)
Good blog vinyl1 thanks. CoD 12a.
Must be my 15 minutes of fame – £20 prize cheque for the Mephisto arrived the other day.
And congratulations on your prize.
Not often we come across a new word in the blog itself. ‘Meeking’ is a particularly good example.
Thank you to setter and blogger
14 and three quarter minutes with those errors.
Kali, Thais and lunisolar were definitely unknowns, and I don’t think anyone has ever replied “aguish” when I’ve asked them how they are. “Alright considering” and “fair to crap” are far more common.
Edited at 2018-11-05 01:47 pm (UTC)
That left BUTTER MUSLIN, which was another unknown, so had to be solved in instalments, the last one being when I saw who the “camp man” was, which meant I finished on a pleasing penny-drop moment. As was said about one of the puzzles last week, a puzzle where you can get the answers (eventually) despite your ignorance is a good puzzle, and makes you feel it’s teaching you something new rather than just infuriating you.
As was your blog, vinyl1, so thanks for that.