FOI the fun anagram at 18ac, LOI, 16dn, which was somewhat embarrassingly (appropriately enough!) as I’d already put in ARRAS at 4dn but forgotten about 16 needing to mean the same thing, leading me to waste some time on trying to justify EXPOSURE. Hard to nominate a particular COD, I was going to go with 19ac because I like Moll Flanders, but then thought that that surface doesn’t really make much sense. So I’m going to go for 21ac, simple, fluent surface, nicely misleading definition, lovely clue all round really. 9ac is, while being slightly more complex in its wordplay, also very elegantly surfaced. In the debit column I don’t much like the 4dn device of having to solve a later clue before the current one can (confidently) be solved, but at least the Times rarely does puzzles containing many such, forcing the solver to race back and forth like a headless chicken… Thanks setter!
ACROSS
1 British fish and others around for shopping (8)
BETRAYAL – B [British] + RAY [fish] with ET AL [and others] “around”
5 Church to copy Lutyens’ façade in religious building (6)
CHAPEL – CH [church] + APE [to copy] + L{utyens}
10 Local branch hostile about new detailed references (7,3,5)
CHAPTER AND VERSE – CHAPTER [local branch] + ADVERSE [hostile] about N [new]
11 Senior instructor getting post in footer? The opposite! (10)
HEADMASTER – MAST [post] in HEADER [the opposite of footer]
13 Tactic initially used by City Group (4)
TRIO – T{actic} by RIO [city]
15 Dismiss objection showing old-fashioned brass (7)
SACKBUT – SACK BUT [dismiss | objection]
17 Top individual appearing in fashion title (7)
CAPTION – CAP [top] + I [individual] appearing in TON [fashion]
18 Gucci to start with simply formed tunic (7)
GYMSLIP – G{ucci} + (SIMPLY*) [“formed”]
19 Spineless creature welcomes us to Flanders clubs (7)
MOLLUSC – US “welcomed” to MOLL C [Flanders (in the Defoe novel) | clubs]
21 Long-distance runner having zero energy (4)
NILE – NIL E [zero | energy]
22 Shield lets axe in once and he’s crocked (10)
ESCUTCHEON – CUT [axed ] in (ONCE + HE’S*) [“crocked”]
25 Affect Tory supporters with reminder to behave appropriately (3,3,5,4)
HIT THE RIGHT NOTE – HIT THE RIGHT [affect Tory supporters] + NOTE [reminder]
27 Margins deserting Arab Bank? Not often! (6)
RARELY – {a}RA{b} + RELY [bank]
28 Greedy — backing stratagem, that is — not heartless (8)
ESURIENT – reversed RUSE [“backing” strategem] + IE [that is] + N{o}T
DOWN
1 Composer embracing cold American god (7)
BACCHUS – BACH [composer] “embracing” C [cold] + US [American]
2 Light meal Athena regularly provides (3)
TEA – {a}T{h}E{n}A
3 Transport gold fabric clothing gang (10)
AUTOMOBILE – AU [gold] + TOILE [fabric] “clothing” MOB [gang]
4 Somewhat embarrassing 16 (5)
ARRAS – hidden in {emb}ARRAS{ing}, a synonym for the answer to 16dn
6 No end to dismal accommodation in resort (4)
HOVE – HOVE{l} [“no end to” dismal accommodation]
7 Men feature in virgin’s paintings (11)
PORTRAITURE – OR TRAIT [men (as in Other Ranks) | feature] in PURE [virgin]
8 Rest of weight porky lecturer carries (3-4)
LIE-DOWN – W [weight] that LIE DON [porky | lecturer] “carries”
9 In meantime firm must replace current phone system (8)
INTERCOM – INTER{i->CO}M [replace I (current) with CO (firm) in INTERIM (meantime)]
12 Bet one will be put on charge (11)
ACCUMULATOR – double def. I knew the first def, but not the second, “a large rechargeable battery”.
14 Destruction of Capitol occurring in month? This could spread! (10)
APPLICATOR – (CAPITOL*) [“destruction of…”] “occurring in” APR [month]
16 Design such as Odo commissioned records shot (8)
TAPESTRY – TAPES TRY [records | shot]. If you realised that Odo (probably) commissioned the Bayeux Tapestry, you outdid me here.
18 Terribly urgent cases hard for this German (7)
GUNTHER – (URGENT*) [“terribly”] “cases” H [hard]
20 Fanciful idea concerning church in short quote (7)
CONCEIT – ON CE [concerning | church] in CIT{e} [“short” quote]
23 Motivates writer to dispense with peripheral characters (5)
URGES – {b}URGES{s}, Anthony, author of A Clockwork Orange etc
24 Greeting in place for little man (4)
PHIL – HI [greeting] in PL [place]
26 Lyric poem’s style devoid of metre? (3)
ODE – {m}ODE [style, losing its M for metre]
Nothing (else) here was very obscure, except for the quite archaic ESURIENT. I wouldn’t, as our classicist blogger did, put it in the same category (“slighty more ornate vocabulary”) as ESCUTCHEON and (especially not) PORTRAITURE. Also new to me was GYMSLIP.
I worked ACCUMULATOR and APPLICATOR one right after the other. Had to guess there was such a thing as an “accumulator bet.”
Edited at 2017-12-15 06:54 am (UTC)
Embarrassed not to have noticed “lie” for “porky” in 8d until I came here, but I didn’t let it trouble me too much at the time. I did at least clock the link between 4d and 16d, though I didn’t know who Odo was until I did, other than the shapeshifter in Deep Space Nine, which presumably was what I was watching when I should have been studying history.
Really must get around to Moll Flanders at some point. (Or at least watch the Alex Kingston telly version…)
Edited at 2017-12-15 07:42 am (UTC)
I’m sure there’s one of Pip’s short stories in this grid, what with the HEADMASTER, the SACKBUT and a GYMSLIP, but maybe that one’s best left unpublished.
No clue who Odo was so it’s nice to learn something else I can forget.
Bishop Odo we covered in the first form – terribly funny man apparently – had everyone in stitches.
FOI 2dn TEA
LOI 13ac TRIO
COD St Trinian’s 18ac GYMSLIP!
WOD 22ac ESCUTCHEON
Why did Lord Verlaine take so long!
Edited at 2017-12-15 08:18 am (UTC)
After some talk of extraneous ‘a’s, the setter today has decided not to have any ‘a’s at all. Is this a first?
LOI was 1ac where I was struggling until Mrs M glanced over and said, ‘And others – that might be et al’.
Mostly I liked: simply formed tunic, Flanders, Nile, Burgess and Intercom (COD).
Thanks erudite setter and V.
One of the jars has apparently got my name on it! I will use it as an occasional ‘avatar’ after I open it on Xmas morning so that you might share my good fortune.
Edited at 2017-12-15 02:54 pm (UTC)
I’ll try to get clues out to the lucky 32 some time today.
As gothick matt, FOI BACCHUS LOI ESURIENT, a lovely word.
Many thanks to both principal players.
Funnily enough TRIO was my last, rather painfully dragged in, being uncertain about LIE DOWN until I parsed it properly. Perhaps it was the capital G for Group that put me off from seeing it as the definition.
Breakfast? Zilch as usual. Damn this diet…
gothick_matt: do the more lively TV Alex Kington “Moll Flanders” — reading Defoe’s version is a rather dry scholarly exercise.
Held up by 21 but at least managed to complete this in a vaguely respectable 10,000 metre time anyway.
Thanks to setter and blogger.
Edited at 2017-12-15 12:25 pm (UTC)
Edited at 2017-12-15 12:40 pm (UTC)
I got stuck because I had biffed ‘set the right tone’, which worked on the right but gave trouble on the left. It took a bit to correct that, but it had to be ‘Gunther’, so there you go. I did remember who Odo was, and I’m surprised we’ve never seen him as an answer.
Edited at 2017-12-15 02:49 pm (UTC)
Over confident 21 minutes with this straightforward offering, but bunged in CONCEPT without thinking it through. Doh. But knew about Oh Doh.
Pleased with 23’ today but fell for ‘concept’ right at the end.
Phil R