I came to this straight after finishing another, easier puzzle and feeling ‘warmed up.’ However I soon cooled down as my first pass saw only a few clues in the NW corner filled in and many more which looked intractable, even a bit weird.
Gradually the little grey cells did their job and the Penny Drop Moments came along, revealing a hatful of ingenious wordplay and devious definitions. Forty minutes of fun. I wasn’t familiar with the exact expressions at 5d and 15d but they seemed likely phrases. For the sheer baffling brilliance of its surface – which had me struggling until the checkers were in – I vote for 16a as the CoD.
Gradually the little grey cells did their job and the Penny Drop Moments came along, revealing a hatful of ingenious wordplay and devious definitions. Forty minutes of fun. I wasn’t familiar with the exact expressions at 5d and 15d but they seemed likely phrases. For the sheer baffling brilliance of its surface – which had me struggling until the checkers were in – I vote for 16a as the CoD.
Across | |
1 Defender returned to usual position? (4-4) | |
LEFT BACK – Cryptic definition. | |
6 Pickle to grate for container (6) | |
JAMJAR – JAM = pickle, as in in a spot; JAR = grate. I think two words is more usual but the dictionaries allow jamjar as one. | |
9 Travel report for Japanese game (6) | |
GOBANG – GO = travel BANG = report. A board game involving trying to place 5 counters in a row, more usually called GOMUKO in Japanese. | |
10 Leader of Bolshevik women — or crazed reformer? (3,5) | |
NEW BROOM – (B WOMEN OR)*. Took me an age to see it was an anagram. | |
11 Office worker of note, one sitting in house (4) | |
TEMP – TE – musical note, MP sits in the House. | |
12 Shortage of decent cells with migrants slowly escaping? (5,5) | |
BRAIN DRAIN – I think &lit. cryptic definitions don’t come any smarter or more topical than this.. | |
14 Bogart film, something that opens slowly (3,5) | |
KEY LARGO – a key opens, and largo means slowly in musical terms . | |
16 The Central Line in E London has eleven stops (4) | |
AXIS – HAS in East London speak could be ‘AS. Insert (‘stops’) XI for eleven. Blimey guv, that’s neat. | |
18 Vessel that’s empty picked up by mistake? (4) | |
VEIN – Sounds like VAIN, meaning empty as in ‘empty threat’ perhaps.. | |
19 Some mocking hosts repelled European girl (8) | |
JENNIFER – Here’s our random girl’s name answer of the day. Insert FINN reversed (repelled European) into JEER = some mocking. | |
21 In place of repartee, was sitting wrapping present (5,3,2) | |
WHERE IT’S AT – A bit of an odd definition, I think. I untangled this as HERE inside WIT = repartee, and HERE SAT = was sitting. There’s probably a clearer way to express it. EDIT there is, as elucidated below; the definition is “in place” not “present” and WIT and SAT are around HERE. Doh. | |
22 Sound shocked when doctor comes round (4) | |
GASP – AS = when, surrounded by GP = doctor. | |
24 Nude pictures of an Archer are OTT: I’m rattled (8) | |
AMORETTI – This didn’t turn out to be as tasty as I’d imagined. An Amoretto is a representation of Cupid in art, not just an almond biscuit as I’d thought. Anagram time, (ARE OTT I’M)*. | |
26 Sort of home? Not there (2,1,3) | |
IN A WAY – Home = IN, AWAY = not there. | |
27 Working uniform, black (6) | |
USABLE – U = uniform, SABLE = black. | |
28 Relieved lover no longer exhausted, missing one (8) | |
EXEMPTED – EX = lover no longer, EMPTIED = exhausted, remove the I. I suppose there is a sense in which relieved can mean exempted, as in ‘relieved from duty’? |
Down | |
2 Recall some returning from trek overseas (5) | |
EVOKE – Hidden reversed in TR(EK OVE)RSEAS. | |
3 Bouncer’s long walk round ship (11) | |
TRAMPOLINER – TRAMP = long walk, O = round, LINER = ship. | |
4 Fare’s going up after month in German town (8) | |
AUGSBURG – AUG = month, GRUB’S = fare’s, reversed. | |
5 A joker, initially, took care, using awfully rough sentences (8,7) | |
KANGAROO JUSTICE – Anagram of (A J TOOK CARE USING)*. I got the kangaroo bit and had the letters for justice left over, I’d heard of a kangaroo court which obviously can dispense ‘kangaroo justice’ but I can’t actually find any reference on the net to the two words together being a phrase in use. | |
6 Maybe doing better than warring faction of German yesmen? (6) | |
JAWING – Well, they say “jaw, jaw, is better than war, war”, although Mr Trump might disagree where Rocket Man is concerned. And the JA WING could be a bunch of German yes-men. | |
7 Drinker finally overcome by mother’s ruin (3 | |
MAR – MA = mother, R = drinker finally. | |
8 Native area suffered without a single soldier (9) | |
ABORIGINE – A(rea), BORNE (suffered), insert I GI = a single soldier. | |
13 Trailer in Welsh county possessed by one travelling light (7,4) | |
READING LAMP – One travelling = REP. Insert AD (trailer), IN, GLAM (short for Glamorgan). Not the best of definitions. | |
15 Come home, through Slough for example (3,6) | |
EYE RHYMES – &lit. Those who amuse themselves with poetry will probably like this clue, but I didn’t. I had all the checkers and saw it must be EYE something before the penny dropped. Examples of words which look like they’ll rhyme, because of the similar spelling, but they don’t. How do people from abroad ever master English, when there are so many ways to pronounce -OUGH-? | |
17 Out — or still facing the bowler? (2,6) | |
ON STRIKE – Cryptic DD, one cricket related. More my kind of clue. | |
20 One going to market on foot? (3,3) | |
BIG TOE – Amusing cryptic definition; as in this little piggy went to market, this little piggy… . I hope I don’t need to provide further explanation. | |
23 Wind in southern plain, mostly (5) | |
SNAKE – I think this is S for south and NAKE(D). Does naked equal plain in some way? | |
25 Rag and bone (3) | |
RIB – Another double definition, rag in the sense of tease. |
Felt like a wavelength puzzle and I got on it fairly early courtesy of a few total guesses that I later realised were right.
Comps to the setter.
Only one-third done after 30m, and then the dominoes started falling. So much more enjoyable than staring vacantly at one or two pesky poorly-clued obscurities after knocking off 95% in no time
Plain ~ unadorned ~ naked
Edited at 2017-10-25 06:32 am (UTC)
Any game called GOBANG is worth a try, I’d have thought.
Too hard for me – but all done except the Vein/Eye Rhymes crossers. And I now have a nagging feeling that I’ve failed on Eye Rhymes before – feh!
Several MERs (minor eyebrow raises): is ‘returned to’ really ‘left’? Is ‘some mocking’ really ‘jeer’?
Guessed Gobang – but wordplay helpful (thanks setter). Struggled with Snake for too long.
Mostly I loved: Axis, ‘In place’, Reading Lamp – and COD to Big Toe (how cute).
Thanks brilliant setter and Pip.
And further to Lou’s example above I’d add ‘plain/naked truth’.
Edited at 2017-10-25 06:40 am (UTC)
Edited at 2017-10-25 08:26 am (UTC)
I also had a nagging DV feeling about eye rhymes.
pip
Went over the hour trying to think of a word for 18 that fitted in with EAR RHYME until I accepted that answer didn’t sound right.
Perhaps I would have done better later in the day, post-coffee. I do like puzzles this hard; being soundly thrashed by them, not so much!
Having said that there’s some very clever stuff in here so perhaps I’m just in a bit of a grumpy mood.
repartee = wit was sitting = sat containing here for present
ETA: Wait a minute, I was only looking at one branch. There’s still hope!
Edited at 2017-10-25 10:37 am (UTC)
By the way, where’s the beer at on the 4th? Can’t travel all that way*, fail dismally in the first round (pretty much guaranteed) and not partake of the post-solve refreshments.
*I understand that “all that way” to me probably pales into insignificance when compared to others. It’s not like Oxfordshire is on another planet or something. But it’s London and it scares me now I’ve got old.
Even more gutting having now seen that Verlaine dnf’d in a similar time.
Got AXIS (had to be with XI in the middle) but didn’t appreciate the subtleties till I read the comments. Well done setter!
Edited at 2017-10-25 11:16 am (UTC)
Not been there for about 20 years, was a regular lunchtime watering hole before we discovered the Firkin Ale Trail
In any case was a DNF as had to resort to aid for 3dn having been unable to think of anything better than WELL BACK at 1ac (but I did know 15dn).
Edited at 2017-10-25 01:18 pm (UTC)
P.S. Yippee. My account has been unsuspended, so I can now comment using it again.
AXIS is just brilliant
Mrs K says it’s ‘hew’ and she’s from Up North. Here they’d say ‘Monsieur Ooje.’
But in Norfolk?
Edited at 2017-10-25 03:10 pm (UTC)
Nearly superb.
In passing, I think (Chambers, more than others) dictionary editors are mischievous imps who occasionally get bored and make up words & phrases, just because they can.
Sean Bean could mould enough dough to make my pie high? (3,6)
And I would love to claim that I counted the E London stops on the Central Line first: if there really are eleven then I feel most gratified 🙂
Edited at 2017-10-25 07:06 pm (UTC)
Edited at 2017-10-25 06:21 pm (UTC)
Edited at 2017-10-25 10:32 pm (UTC)
I first heard the phrase used in the 1960s when it was reported that many of the best British-born ‘brains’ were leaving the country to live and work abroad, but in the light of recent developments the clue can be taken another way, in that some of the highly qualified migrants who settled in the UK may now be planning to move out and work elsewhere. I think that’s what Pip had in mind when he wrote about the clue being topical.
Edited at 2017-10-25 10:34 pm (UTC)
“Aruba, Jamaica, oh I want to take ya
Bermuda, Bahama, come on pretty mama
KEY LARGO, Montego, baby why don’t we go, Jamaica….”
DNF or, more truthfully, DNEGHW.