How often do we find a puzzle where most of the clues fall into place quite quickly and a few stubborn ones hold us up, even with checkers in place? For me, this was one of those, with the SE corner being slow to show up and the correct reading of 7d also a late PDM. Twenty minutes for all but those and another ten to finish. We’ll probably find though that others’ ten per cent of trickiness turns out to be different from mine; it’s all in the mind.
Oh, and there’s a less common antelope, for those who (unlike me) don’t have an encyclopaedic knowledge of four-legged lion bait; it’s a good Scrabble word, to boot.
Across |
1 Vulgar young person losing head confronts superior officer — big trouble (5)
|
HAVOC – CHAV loses its C, OC for superior officer. I know what a CHAV is but not its etymology, so looked it up. Uncertain, but I liked the non-PC idea (probably constructed afterwards, a “backronym”) that it stands for “council housed and violent”. |
4 Musicians turn out to be inadequate dilettanti (9)
|
COMPOSERS – Parsing seems a bit vague here, I think it is COM(E) = turn out, to be inadequate i.e. lose its ending; POSERS = dilettanti. |
9 The French female has to get ready for bed — she’s washing (9)
|
LAUNDRESS – A stock clue; LA = the French feminine, UNDRESS = get ready for bed. |
10 Symbol put back by weather forecasters with books (5)
|
TOTEM – Reverse MET and OT (Old Testament). |
11 A cold island off the Irish coast (6)
|
ACHILL – A, CHILL. Very nice place to visit, with empty beaches and big skies, as painted by Paul Henry. |
12 Primitive weapon has a gentle hit stopping movement (8) |
CATAPULT – Insert A TAP into CULT = movement. |
14 Faithful old individual grabbing paper is granted solitude (4,5)
|
LEFT ALONE – LEAL a Scottish dialect word for LOYAL; insert FT the paper and add ONE individual. |
16 Joyful bit of song from central Africa (3-2) |
TRA-LA – Hidden in CEN(TRAL A)FRICA. |
17 Female group run by male (5) |
HAREM – HARE = run, M. |
19 Robbers having similar drinks outside and inside? (9) |
PILLAGERS – Two similar drinks here; PILS outside LAGER. Nice work. |
21 Boss to carry player on a lap of honour? (8)
|
CHAIRMAN – I see this as a sort of weak DD; if you chair a man around the pitch, you’re be carrying him on your lap?. |
22 I may be put out by outrageous leading lady (6) |
GLENDA – It’s an anagram of LEADING without its I, indicated by ‘outrageous’. |
25 Spread the gospel but not quietly to gain influence (5) |
REACH – PREACH loses its quiet P. |
26 Savage old lover appearing with naughty erotica (9) |
EXCORIATE – EX = old lover, (EROTICA)*. Apologies, I blogged this initially but it somehow got highlighted and deleted, now restored. |
27 Is backward-looking politician exposed as a fool? (9) |
SIMPLETON – Another stock clue. IS reversed, MP, LET ON = exposed. |
28 For riser, inactivity’s ending — whence comes the dawn? (5)
|
YEAST – Y = end of inactivity, EAST = whence comes the dawn. |
Down |
1 Control the situation before laying down requirements for others at the table? (4,3,3,5)
|
HOLD ALL THE CARDS – Cryptic definition, my second one in after the long anagram at 8d. |
2 Guarantee given with very little indication of pain (5)
|
VOUCH – V = very, OUCH = little indication of pain. |
3 A linguistic sign from the Man in Black? (7)
|
CEDILLA – Thankfully we had the reference to this Liverpudlian lady recently, else it might have caused me more trouble. Insert ED = Man, into CILLA = Black. The twiddly 5 shaped thing under a French C to make it sound like S not K before an A, as in ça va. |
4 College student humoured, though denied a sign of affection (2-2)
|
CO-ED – There may be a clearer (better?) explanation than mine here: I think it is COAXED = humoured, losing its A, X where X = sign of affection. |
5 Stinky meal prepared incorrectly (10
|
MISTAKENLY – (STINKY MEAL)*. |
6 Unfashionable model gets to survive (7)
|
OUTLAST – OUT = unfashionable, LAST = model, as in cobbler’s. |
7 Train journey going on time — Euston evacuated earlier (9)
|
ENTOURAGE – I spent too long thinking of a synonym for TRAIN as in teach. It’s TRAIN as in people hanging on behind. EN = Euston evacuated, TOUR = journey, AGE = time. |
8 Commentators finally interpret a man’s rambling, not completely clear (15)
|
SEMITRANSPARENT – (S INTERPRET A MANS)*, the S being end of commentators. for some reason I saw this transparently as soon as I read the clue, my FOI. |
13 Grumble when church is seen as one being smug (10)
|
COMPLACENT – COMPLAINT would be grumble, replace the I in it by CE = church. |
15 Dynamism, as befits marines giving warning of danger (4,5)
|
FIRE ALARM – FIRE = dynamism, A LA RM = as befits marines. |
18 Officer damages room, scratching floor (7)
|
MARSHAL – MARS = damages, HAL(L) = room, scratching floor = removing the last L. |
20 Hypersensitivity of friend without some measure of work (7)
|
ALLERGY – Insert ERG = measure of work, into ALLY. Ergs are outdated these days, not being SI units, and very small (ten million ergs in a Joule). Someone with nothng better to do has calculated it’s as much work as done by a house fly bending one leg down and up. |
23 Wild animal in article about place to the north (5)
|
NYALA – [Edited later] All reversed i.e. to the north; AN = article, insert LAY = place. Quite a nice antelope, as they go, with spiral horns and stripes. |
24 Cold caught in the course of school hospital examination (4)
|
SCAN – Insert C into SAN = school hospital. |
Edited at 2017-10-04 06:37 am (UTC)
Some really neat clues, I thought. Mostly I liked: the double-lager robbers, Simpleton, For riser, Man in Black, Stinky meal, ‘church is seen as one’.
COD to 27ac – it has everything: reversal, abbreviation, one word for two, concatenation and a great surface. Top notch.
Thanks v clever setter and Pip.
PS to ‘chair’ someone is to carry them aloft as in a celebration of victory – like a lap of honour – so it made sense to me.
Edited at 2017-10-04 07:21 am (UTC)
Daily Quiz: 1. Which planet is named after the Roman god of war?
QUick Cryptic (immediately below the quiz): 5a Spoils of war personified
15×15: 18d Officer damaging room, scratching floor.
Any conspiracy theorists out there?
The winner of the Queen’s Prize at Bisley (and other target shooting events) is chaired around the camp afterwards, on a chair kept specially for the occasion.. if you google “queens prize chair” on google images, you will see what I mean..
Edited at 2017-10-04 06:57 pm (UTC)
I agree with boltonwanderer about the role of Chairman but would add using contacts to raise awareness, facilitate introductions and gain access to finance. Certainly its the CEO who should run the show day to day
Not too crazy either about the clues for Chairman and Hold all the cards, but Tra-la provided a welcome bit of light relief.
https://www.collinsdictionary.com/dictionary/english/semitransparent
Achill is Ireland’s largest isle, 57 sq. miles, off the Mayo coast, scenic but remote. I lived in Ireland for 14 years and only went there once.
Only complaint is the use of “by” in the totem clue — It makes no sense
That does make sense
I also thought CHAIRMAN was fine, as to chair a man could be to carry a player aloft.
Relatively easy, although my time of 44:16 will seem a little pathetic to most!
Mr Chumley
I agree with your comment on NYALA. Without “to the North” we have no reversal indicator, and A on its own can’t be around LAY.
When I was 5 I had a book of mammals which I read every day, and NYALA was in there so a bit of long-term knowledge there. I still have the book!
I didn’t know the required sporting meaning of ‘chair’ so I hesitated. In my world an important part of the CHAIRMAN’s role is to act as a go-between and peace-maker between us finance types and the people with a real job.
ACHILL also unknown and entered with crossed fingers.
Edited at 2017-10-04 11:13 am (UTC)
Of course I knew not ACHILL, and later checking on Google brought the predictable “did you mean Achilles?”) and to be fair it barely looks feasible.
No problem with CHAIR MAN: possibly, as others have indicated, a rather old-fashioned Oxbridge sort of celebration. But Chambers has “to carry publicly in triumph” for chair, and I’ve seen it happening in black and white movies, though not, as far as I remember, in cricket.
I thought 13d was pretty clever, though I think in recent days the replacement device has been proliferating to the extent that I’m beginning to spot it on first reading.
Well blogged, Pip, especially on the dodgier clues: FWIW, I think you’re right about CO-ED, though I think coaxed and humoured are barely kissing cousins.
COD I rather liked 28ac YEAST but it has to go to 9ac LAUNDRESS!
WOD the Irish Isle ACHILL.
The setter’s ‘stir’ was a litle lumpy! With 4ac COMPOSERS and 4dn COED particularly lumpen.
That’s quite enough of that – 42:42 for me.
Because I didn’t go with my gut feeling on that, I didn’t get 4a wither, although how COMPOSERS didn’t even occur to me I’m not sure. But again I think it is a bad clue: “come” doesn’t come close in meaning to “turn out” and “posers” isn’t really a synonym for “dilettanti”; some dilettanti may be posers, but that isn’t the definition of dilettante at all.
When I do get stuck on a clue it is most often where the setter has used a dubious synonym for the answer, and it always leaves me feeling cross 🙂
I’ve also never encountered a NYALA in veldt, dictionary or menu. The entire catalogue of antelopes seems, like cricket positions and growth-stages of salmon, to have been created solely for people who like to make up silly words.
My CoD would have been the neat HAREM if I had finished and weren’t grumpy, but I didn’t and I am so it isn’t.