It was the two Italianate clues what done me in, if I can point a finger: 10ac was very unknown so, although ROSSO seemed like a definite good bet, I wasn’t getting very far with the first part. And then 22dn is a brilliant example of the great Magoo’s number one piece of advice, don’t allow yourself to get stuck on an idea, keep on re-examining. I got so obsessed with the idea that P_E_O must be an unknown Italian detective that I just wouldn’t let myself think, hang on, perhaps there’s a *reason* you can’t think of any really famous Italian detectives? If I’d given up that tack a bit earlier and considered other ways that the clue could possibly break down, things would have gone much better for me, I reckon.
Loads of really well-constructed clues, as I said, with very few that aren’t doing something a bit cleverer or more deceptive than usual. I’ll give my COD to 9ac because I really like the definition being “element one” plus the anagram indicator being not quite where you might expect it. You wouldn’t think a clue involving an anagram of H GONE DRY for an element would give an experienced solver much bother in the normal run of things, but I think this setter may be some kind of evil genius. Thanks to the individual concerned for a really traumatic ordeal – exactly how I like to start my weekends!
ACROSS
1 An American possessing endless support you can count on? (6)
ABACUS – A US [an | American] “possessing” BAC{k} [“endless” support]
5 Going on excursion? One can, in posh car (8)
JAUNTING – UN TIN [one | can], in JAG [posh car]
9 Element one sprayed initially has gone dry (8)
HYDROGEN – (H{as} GONE DRY*) [“sprayed”]
10 Milk one loved before turning red? (6)
EXTORT – EX [one loved before] + reversed TROT [“turning” red]
11 Leaves lounge, roughly grabbing sailor (5,5)
LOLLO ROSSO – LOLL [lounge] + OR SO [roughly] “grabbing” O.S. [sailor]
13 Word in carol’s original verse is missing (4)
NOEL – NO{v}EL [original V (verse) “is missing”]
14 Notion one cherished briefly (4)
IDEA – I [one] + DEA{r} [cherished, “briefly”]
15 Dec eighth: roughly about time to join union (3,7)
GET HITCHED – (DEC EIGHTH*) [“roughly”] about T [time]
18 An alternative to the boat, perhaps, that brings riches? (5,5)
GRAVY TRAIN – humorous cryptic definition playing on GRAVY BOAT suggesting a type of transport
20 Something in the middle to cling to, tough (4)
THUG – {some}T{hing} + HUG [cling to]
21 Spot incomplete list of requirements (4)
SPEC – SPEC{k} [spot, “incomplete”]
23 Plateful demolished by army officer very fast (2,4,4)
AT FULL PELT – (PLATEFUL*) [“demolished”] by LT [army officer]
25 For greeting, bow to each side (6)
BEHIND – HI [greeting], BEND [bow] “to each side”
26 Huge college studies spoken of (4-4)
KING-SIZE – KINGS [college] + homophone of EYES [studies “spoken of”]
28 More prominent surrounds by Oriental tree (3,5)
BOX ELDER – BOLDER [more prominent] surrounds X E [by | Oriental]
29 Weak women’s sobbing has moved heart (6)
WATERY – W [women] has TE{<-A}RY [sobbing, with “moved heart”]
DOWN
2 Child prodigy’s heard to raise doubt (3,6)
BOY WONDER – homophone of BUOY [“heard” to raise] + WONDER [doubt]
3 Part of plant climbing wall, or occasionally, fences (7)
COROLLA – hidden reversed [“climbing” … “fences”] in {w}ALL OR OC{casionally}
4 Drop jaw when upset (3)
SAG – GAS reversed [jaw “when upset”]
5 German OK with students being two-faced (5)
JANUS – JA [German OK] + N.U.S. [students]. The old Roman god with two faces looking forwards and backwards into the New and Old years.
6 Choice of dishes turned one on — a lot re-served cold (11)
UNEMOTIONAL – MENU reversed [choice of dishes “turned”] + (I ON A LOT*) [“re-served”]
7 Huge current stopping at sea intact (7)
TITANIC – I [current] “stopping” (INTACT*) [“at sea”]
8 Shark appearing in harbour (5)
NURSE – double def
12 Permission given, favouring a particular side (5-6)
RIGHT-HANDED – RIGHT HANDED [permission | given]
16 What precedes do: a drink (3)
TEA – TE [what precedes do (the musical note)] + A
17 Goal perhaps of small boy in European competition? I’m not sure… (9)
EQUALIZER – AL [small boy] in E QUIZ [European | competition] + ER [I’m not sure…]
19 Short holiday viewed as sound, healthy preparation (7)
VACCINE – VAC [short holiday] + homophone of SEEN [viewed “as sound”]
20 Family firm providing work in printing house (7)
TYPESET – TYPE SET [family | firm]
22 Italian sleuth leading man out of Whitechapel? (5)
PIERO – P.I. [sleuth] + ‘ERO [leading man “out of Whitechapel”, i.e. Cockneyfied]
24 Ascetic in the distance crossing Himalayan mountain (5)
FAKIR – FAR [in the distance] “crossing” K1 [Himalayan mountain]
27 Present that’s bagged up (3)
NOW – WON reversed [bagged “up”]
Edited at 2017-09-15 08:50 am (UTC)
Edited at 2017-09-15 09:03 am (UTC)
Edited at 2017-09-15 09:20 am (UTC)
Unfortunately I was also stove in by the two Italian answers. I had both LOLLO and ROSSO in my head at various points, but as I couldn’t get “roughly” out of my head as an anagram indicator and as “sailor” looked like such good fodder for the crossers…
Also had no idea whatever that the word PIERO existed, let alone what it meant. There I wasn’t helped by not having heard of a BOX ELDER, nor being able to justify BEHIND no matter how many times I thought of it.
Quite glad I just gave up at the end of my hour, rather than pressing on, as I’m fairly sure I’d not have got there in the end. Bah.
Some great stuff but the aforesaid lollo rosso left me with a “Whatever” feeling. Not that it matters — according to today’s Guardian Dennis Rodman is all that stands between us and nuclear annihilation. I must stop reading the Guardian.
COD to 25ac – so simple when you spot which bit is the definition and summon up a word for bow (which took me too long). But prior to the PDM, baffling. Plus a meaningful, believable, grammatical surface. Well played.
I liked lots, but mostly: Hydrogen, Milk, the Leaves, Noel, Kings eyes, Boy wonder.
Gobsmacked that Lollo Rosso has held people up.
Thanks brilliant setter and V.
The leaves have stuck in my mind from an old tv ad for a well known cream cheese which had the line ‘a little lollo rosso for that continental touch’ . The junk that fills our brains!
I found this very hard, but had a lot of fun grappling with it. LOLLO ROSSO was actually an easy biff for me: my biggest problems came in the SE with THUG/TYPESET/WATERY and NE with EXTORT/NURSE/NOEL. Lots of clues (including PIERO for the same reasons as v) where I took a firm grasp of the wrong end of the stick, and several where for a long time I couldn’t see an end of the stick to grasp.
Cracking stuff. Thanks to verlaine, and congratulations on the success of your young protégé.
*actual thoughts edited in the interests of decency
Edited at 2017-09-15 08:58 am (UTC)
Edited at 2017-09-15 09:27 am (UTC)
I put in PIERO un-parsed with no great hope. I knew the expensive garnish that I normally push to the side of my plate but didn’t realise that it was named after Gina Lollobrigida.
Oh sorry, you meant the garnish?
Edited at 2017-09-15 09:44 am (UTC)
Alessandro Del Piero – Alejet/Il Pinturicchio – former Italy and Juve #10 the only Piero I knew.
Also not being UKish didn’t know Whitechapel was Cockney, vaguely thought it was south London on the Old Kent Road, from Monopoly.
Decidedly tricky crossword, same problems as others.
I never saw behind 25ac BEHIND.
28ac BOX ELDER was my LOI. FOI 21dn BOY WONDER.
COD 18ac GRAVY TRAIN
WOD Fridayitis and a DNFF!
Mood Meldrew!
Edited at 2017-09-15 11:14 am (UTC)
About 45mins with two blanks (NURSE and NOEL, should’ve persevered with those two), a mis-biffed ‘premo’ (would never have got that one), and a couple of biffs that went in ok (WATERY, EQUALIZER). Great puzzle, with some satisfying pdms. Thanks for sorting it all after your grand night out, V!
Janie
Most of the clues were brilliant and deceptive – I particularly liked ‘get hitched’ and ‘unemotional’, where just following the cryptics lead me to a completely unexpected answers.
GRAVY TRAIN was superb, even Mrs K was amused.
Edited at 2017-09-15 01:57 pm (UTC)
Edited at 2017-09-15 05:07 pm (UTC)
Can’t remember ever seeing JAUNT as a verb, so I was a bit iffy about JAUNTING.
For me, the main issue with PIERO is that he’s not your archetypal Italian in the same way Pedro, Paddy, Hans, or Fritz are for other nationalities: it’s just a (probably) Italian name, and not a particularly common one if the discussion above is anything to go on.
I too spent a long time over PIERO, and in the end decided that the ERO had to be something to do with Eros, which isn’t in Whitechapel. I also convinced myself that a PIERO was an Italian detective, and completely ignored the “leading man” bit. All of which goes to confirm what someone once said: if two wrongs don’t make a right, try three.
Failed on 11ac: what I eventually put in was nonsense, just so I could say I finished but mirabile dictu, I was half right.
Did like 13ac, 25ac and 22d. Fine clues.
Time? Fuhgeddaboudit!
Edited at 2017-09-15 07:59 pm (UTC)
Suppose I Did get lucky with box elder as it’s the name of a song by Pavement, but I was also held by a typo that took me at least a couple of minutes to spot. All up this only took me 24 minutes – same as monday’s
Edited at 2017-09-15 09:52 pm (UTC)