Sometimes having an easier puzzle at the end of the week proves a source of disgruntlement for me, but this one gets a pass because of the high quality of the construction: there are some really good surfaces in here, and I mean really good. Loved the great surface of 9dn, the simplicity of 12ac, the smoothness of “cream crackers” at 3dn and “marshalling yard” at 5dn and “German city state” at 15dn, the clever double duty of “cast off” in 17ac, “stand” in 20ac, “account” in 24ac, “free press” in 25ac and “TV” in 1dn… it takes a lot of art to make writing clues this elegant and deceptive look so easy, hats off to the setter.
I think I’ll stick with 4dn as my COD though as I just can’t get enough of crossword clues about crossword clues, as you probably know by now, self-reflexive meta-cluing as it were. Plenty of candidates to choose from though: which did you all like?
Across
1 Charles Martel’s heading for great breach (5)
CHASM – CHAS [Charles] + M{artel}
4 You no longer must wear breeches in sweaty place (8)
HOTHOUSE – THOU [you no longer] “must wear” HOSE [breeches]
8 Fancy Dublin manor’s home to Queen Elizabeth the First and Second? (7,7)
ORDINAL NUMBERS – (DUBLIN MANOR’S*) [“fancy”] “home to” ER [Queen Elizabeth]
10 Takes in food covered in spots, an unsavoury quality (9)
SEEDINESS – DINES [takes in food] “covered in” SEES [spots]
11 Characters in flamboyant unicyclist’s garment (5)
TUNIC – hidden in {flamboyan}T UNIC{yclist}
12 One in shop is helping (6)
RATION – I [one] in RAT ON [shop]
14 No more butter? Starter from Italy is meat (8)
PASTRAMI – PAST RAM [no more | butter] + I{taly}
17 Maybe Lady Macbeth‘s wrong to follow cast off (3-5)
SHE-DEVIL – EVIL [wrong] to follow SHED [cast off]
18 Queen wanting Arsenal’s sides to toughen up (6)
ANNEAL – ANNE [Queen] wanting A{rsena}L
20 Stand in line, with no trouble going to the front (5)
EASEL – L [line], with EASE [no trouble] going to the front
22 Count welcomes old partners bidding for agreement (9)
CONSENSUS – CENSUS [count] welcomes O N+S [old | partners bidding]
24 Tell alert saver to change dubious account (10,4)
TRAVELLERS TALE – (TELL ALERT SAVER*) [“to change”]
25 Pitch from US government’s leader to get free press (8)
GRIDIRON – G{overnment} “to get” RID IRON [free | press]
26 Professional leaving right and left boot out (5)
EXPEL – EXPE{rt} [professional “leaving right”] and L [left]
Down
1 Piqued person who helps actor for TV (5-7)
CROSS-DRESSER – CROSS [piqued] + DRESSER [person who helps actor]
2 Go off with clumsy gait, putting away whiskey (5)
ADDLE – {w}ADDLE [clumsy gait, “putting away W{hiskey}”]
3 Monstrous creature into cream crackers (9)
MANTICORE – (INTO CREAM*) [“crackers”]
4 Solver needing minutes to fill in gaps (6)
HOLMES – M [minutes] “to fill in” HOLES [gaps]
5 Marshalling yard shut for a time (8)
THURSDAY – (YARD SHUT*) [“marshalling…”]
6 Go round river, with notice about passing around (5)
ORBIT – R [river], with OBIT [notice about passing] around
7 Weight loss, say, from period of psychiatry? (9)
SHRINKAGE – a “period of psychiatry” could be a SHRINK AGE
9 A cold fish accepting woman’s weakness (8,4)
ACHILLES HEEL – A CHILL EEL [a | cold | fish] “accepting” SHE [woman]
13 Time firm’s restrained by stern money handler (9)
TREASURER – T [time] + SURE [firm] “restrained by” REAR [stern]
15 Figure backing East German city state (9)
TENNESSEE – TEN [figure] + reverse of E ESSEN [“backing” East | German city]
16 O is this kind of letter (8)
CIRCULAR – double def
19 Rent out cracking home for novice worker (6)
INTERN – (RENT*) [“out”] “cracking” IN [home]
21 Wild clip uncovered, short film (5)
LIVID – {c}LI{p} + VID [“short” film]
23 Quiet way to speak about a cheat (5)
SHARP – SH RP [quiet | way to speak] about A
GKQ – what creature is ‘not the same lion’.
So, Lord Galspray, you are in good company! And all in 36 minutes!
I presume TV was Tranny at 1dn CROSS-DRESSER. I was wondering about film!? But then what do I know of these things!? I’m sure Jack spotted it.
COD 4dn HOLMES but the crossers helped enormously.
WOD MINATROCE!
Edited at 2017-07-07 08:11 am (UTC)
OK Galspray … fess up!
Please don’t tell the others.
A
youth wasted on D&D and Fighting Fantasy gamebooksclassical education from Oxford left me very well equipped to write this clue straight in.I didn’t get started until the hidden at 11a, and then it was a bit of a piecemeal affair, rather than an easy flow, where I was looking for (GAIT)* with a W inside at 2d, trying to remember an odd word for a marshalling yard at 5d, and so forth, until I finally realised how the clues worked and penned them in while kicking myself, which is a difficult trick, I can tell you.
Finally finished off with the crossers at GRIDIRON and LIVID—must try to get “vid” for “short film” into my brain; it’s come up a few times—and was happy to find I’d done so within an hour, because the time felt like it was racing by. I’m with V on COD 4d: great surface and great misdirection.
Great thanks to setter and V. Now I’m off to find some painkillers.
Edited at 2017-07-07 07:57 am (UTC)
Thanks setter and V.
I was helped at 1dn by a reference that came up in a puzzle that’s under wraps until tomorrow as it immediately put me on the right track.
Edited at 2017-07-07 08:06 am (UTC)
Finished in SW, as had been trying to make MOVIE the short film at 21ac, which seemed to give something to do with a stand at EPSOM racecourse at 20ac – so needed to remember VID, making 23ac LOI.
Edited at 2017-07-07 10:57 am (UTC)
Very nice puzzle, as others have noted. Nothing outrageously difficult or obscure but it required attention to wordplay (not least to avoid the SWEETNESS trap at 10ac!).
I realized this was a very precise puzzle, and made sure I could parse each clue. On my LOI, I hesitated between ‘scamp’ and ‘sharp’, thinking quiet = ‘p’, but eventually I saw it.
‘Manticore’? It was on side 1 of Tarkus, and ELP later used it as the name of their record label.
But I can see how you got fooled. So there’s something to be said for mass-market 70s prog.
SWEETNESS was a good fit for the literal, I just rushed the parsing. Or was fooled, as some would have it.
30 mins… but with mantiroce. Hate it when I don’t have the requisite gk. Must get out more. Or maybe just take up reading D&D and Fighting Fantasy gamebooks. Whatever they are…
I am happy to report that, after yesterday’s personal best, I am now back on form and took forty minutes to beat this one into submission. TENNESSEE and ANNEAL were my LOsI, as I was trying to parse 15d at a 90-degree angle to the setter’s intention. I agree with those who have praised this puzzle’s uniformly high quality; my personal favourite was 8ac.
All good stuff though.