Solving time: 32 minutes
Although I solved this puzzle relatively quickly, I thought it was quite tricky. I didn’t know the required meanings of ‘chuggers’ and ‘calender’, and I biffed both ‘Huron’ and ‘Hampstead’ without being able to figure out how the clues worked. I also put in ‘Astor’ from the wordplay without knowing who he was. Well, at least I have heard of Karl Barth and Nehemiah.
Music: John Coltrane, Coltrane Jazz
Across | |
---|---|
1 | BOTANICAL, anagram of IN LAB COAT. |
9 | ALUMINA, A + LUM + IN + A, a compendium of crossword cliches. |
10 | RANCHED, RAN + C[attle] + HE’D. |
11 | TERCE, sounds like TERSE. |
12 | FLUMMOXED, F(LUMMOX)ED, should be a chestnut but isn’t. |
13 | EARTHED, hidden in [h]EAR THE D[eer]. |
15 | ASTOR, A STOR[y], David Astor, editor of The Observer, ignotus mihi. |
17 | SMITH, SMIT + H. |
18 | CURER, CUR + ER. |
19 | BARTH, BA(R[ome]TH, German theologian Karl Barth. |
20 | PEDICAB, B(ACID)E P, all backwards. |
23 | ORANGEADE, anagram of AGREED ON + A. |
25 | HURON, H(-e,+U)RON. A tricky letter-substitution clue. Last of those = ‘e’, watchable by all = ‘U’. |
27 | BEEFALO, BEE + OLAF backwards. I think I have seen this one before. |
28 | RECLINE, RE + C + LINE, where ‘about’ is not a containment indicator. |
29 | HAMPSTEAD, HA(MP’S TEA)D, a brilliant clue, which I totally failed to appreciate while solving. |
Down | |
1 | BEREFT, BE REF + T[he]. |
2 | TONGUE-TIED, anagram of DINE OUT + GET. |
3 | NEHEMIAH, NE(HE)M + I + A + H, where the container is an anagram of MEN. |
4 | CODEX, COD + EX. Not really an ‘ancient script’, but an ancient book with pages and a binding, as opposed to a scroll. |
5 | LAUNDERER, LA + UNDER + E.R, a very well-designed and deceptive clue. |
6 | MUTTER, M[outh] + UTTER, where ‘utter’ and ‘nothing more’ are both adjectives meaning mere, total, or complete. |
7 | PIER, PIER[rot], just biffed by me. |
8 | CALENDER, C + A LENDER, a machine with rollers used to press cloth or paper. |
12 | HARD PALATE, HARD + PAL ATE, where ‘swallowed’ is not an enclosure indicator as I first thought. |
16 | TABBOULEH, anagram of [yo]U LOATHE B&B, where the exact spelling may give some solvers difficulty. |
17 | SAPPHIRE, S(A PP)HIRE. |
18 | CHUGGERS, C + HUGGERS, UK slang for authorized and licensed beggars. |
21 | CANDID, CAN + DID. |
22 | B(YE upside-down)OND. |
24 | ALBUM, ALBUM[en]. Albumen is the white of an egg. |
26 | RACK, [c]RACK, i.e. a rack of lamb or something of the sort. |
I didn’t think much of cling for the HARD element of 12dn. Nor 18ac CURER. 6dn MUTTER was a bit nebulous – I was half way up the HUMBER!
Never heard of 18dn CHUGGERS neither has my Chambers. It was first found in print on 26 June 2002 in METRO (London)the work of Keith-Barker Maine (FhT!)
My main error was confidently entering 5dn as LAUNDRESS when LAUNDERER was required – a costly error.
COD 7dn PIER (took me while!) WOD 12ac FLUMMOXED
Vinyl you appear to have missed out 27ac BEEFALO across my LOI and a very fine clue!
Edited at 2017-06-05 02:36 am (UTC)
What exactly makes it a “technical DNF”? A lot of people use this term and I never question it for fear of offending, but you’re not such a delicate soul, so…?
OK – I did not finish but techically I was unable to definitively state what was actually correct.
As you aver, ‘not a satisfying way to solve’.
The equivalent of a technical knock-out in boxing!
I would like to have seen slightly more rigorous editing throughout.
Edited at 2017-06-05 04:32 am (UTC)
I don’t suppose it is deliberate, but you missed out 27ac. Yesterday, which I’m not allowed to talk about yet since it is Sunday, I was determined not to be fooled by “cross” and vainly sought weird animals. I was one day too early.
I also had no idea what CHUGGERS were, they are just people drinking a lot of beer to me.
COD to TABBOULEH. Always reminds me of the T Rex song in Billy Elliott.
Thanks setter and Vinyl.
I can never remember the various names for hours of prayer but TERCE came to me via the homophone once I had all the checkers in place. I also needed all the checkers before settling on what seemed the most likely placement of the remaining anagrist at 16dn, the type of clue that continually annoys me, particularly when the words or references providing the checkers are obscure, like BARTH and ASTOR clued as “famous paper editor”. CALENDER from wordplay only.
Edited at 2017-06-05 05:56 am (UTC)
Edited at 2017-06-05 08:20 am (UTC)
If this is our favourite setter of a theological disposition, I always seem to have trouble with him.
Anyway, about 22 minutes with the mistake. Roll on Tuesday, I say.
Tournament Referee.
Thanks setter and Vinyl.
We had KRAFT paper a while back, and I commented at the time that I knew it from professional encounters with the paper industry, and that I looked forward to GLASSINE appearing. Well GLASSINE is a grade of super-CALENDERed Kraft paper, so this somewhat niche knowledge of mine has served me well of late.
The very excited commentator screamed “Nehemiah was a bullfrog!”. You don’t forget lines like that.
Besides as I said even if you don’t know it I think you’ve got a good chance of getting this one, (Jeremiah, Obadiah…) and it doesn’t seem to have caused problems even for those who hadn’t heard of it.
Edited at 2017-06-05 03:41 pm (UTC)
Mind you, some “follow”s led (a bit) up the garden path: I had RUMP for the joint at 26: Joint (definition) with fracture (CRUMP) — avoid cold initially (ignore the C).
In addition, the world this inhabited turned out to be pretty much the world I inhabit but don’t expect many others to bother with, where ASTOR is an editor, BOND a spy, BARTH a theologian, NEHEMIAH a man of God, TERCE a prayer time, CODEX an antique book, more often than not a copy of the gospels, TABBOULEH a salad only my missus would eat, ORANGEADE comes on the Corona lorry and FLUMMOXED is local code for bamboozled. Mutterings from Dorset encouraged?
Edited at 2017-06-05 08:49 am (UTC)
Needed to come here to understand how ALBUM worked, to learn about Karl Barth and David Astor and to find out what a CALENDER is.
All but the top right in 30mins, then another 10 or so to finish it off.
No problem with CHUGGERS – whom I’ve grumbled about many a time – or NEHEMIAH.
Classic joke: who’s the shortest person in the Bible? Knee-high-miah.
Like K I entered NEHEMIAH on the basis of it looking a bit like Jeremiah. Tabbouleh and chuggers are well-known enough to me for them to have caused no problems. I did look at the HURON clue several times to make sure I was comfortable and I can see why others jumped the wrong way. Is this what Val Law used to call a double helix?
Judging from the presence of TERCE, BARTH, CODEX and NEHEMIAH, I’m guessing that the setter might be The Donald (no, not that one, for Pete’s sake). Anyway, my thanks to whoever it was for a pleasant start to the week.
Like Jackt I hate obscurities clued by anagrams. Tabbouwotsit is a complete NHO, (I doubt you could get it anywhere in my neck of the woods, and I don’t therefore regard referring the spell-checker as cheating.
So there!