Beyond that I thought this was a very good crossword in which nothing was *too* abstruse but which was littered by speedbumps that forced one to slow down and commit proper thought to the problem. I very much liked the two meta-clues at 30ac and 19dn, and was even more taken by what I thought were some really clever instances of logodaedal misdirection: for instance I was sure that 28ac was going to be a word for “dealer” inside a word for “cross” (something in ROOD?); in 2dn there could not be a clearer anagrind (or so I thought) than “jiggling around”; and my LOI, 10ac, held me back from hitting the submit button until a whisker before the 10 minute mark just because I had been so convinced for the entire puzzle that it was going to be a homophone. Congratulations to the setter then on his achievement. Making Crosswords Great Again!
Across
1 Return of loud and corpulent little man is concerning women (7)
DISTAFF – F FAT SID reversed [“return of” loud | corpulent | little man]
5 Act as judge when there’s problem at a higher level (3,2)
SUM UP – SUM [problem] + UP [at a higher level]
9 Feature of mountain visible in fair weather off and on (5)
ARETE – {f}A{i}R {w}E{a}T{h}E{r} [“off and on”]
10 Philosophers said to be in the clouds (9)
MORALISTS – ORAL [said] in MISTS [clouds]
11 Sultan‘s wickedness, imprisoning a boy (7)
SALADIN – SIN [wickedness] imprisoning A LAD [a boy]
12 Certain to follow fashion that’s very different from dreadlocks! (7)
TONSURE – SURE [certain] to follow TON [fashion]
13 Crocodile becoming this would double in length (6,4)
SINGLE FILE – cryptic def – we are not talking about the reptile, but the pairs of schoolchildren holding hands
15 Measure of heat needed in the absence of hot period (4)
TERM – T{h}ERM [measure of heat], absent H [hot]
18 Nerve in narrow part of body (4)
NECK – double def
20 Play informally a feature in this seminar (4,6)
MESS AROUND – {thi}S SEM{inar} has MESS “around” in it
23 Bird featured in decorations (7)
BUNTING – double def
24 Area’s cultivated to accommodate very good shrub (7)
SPIRAEA – (AREA’S*) [“cultivated”] accommodating PI [very good]
25 Customer expecting protection bellowed endlessly in Herts town (9)
WARRANTEE – RANTE{d} [bellowed “endlessly”] in WARE [Herts town]
26 Old boy about to get Palace’s recognition? That’s sweet (5)
BOMBE – O.B. reversed [old boy “about”] + MBE [Palace’s recognition]
27 Right person to give support in meeting (5)
RALLY – R ALLY [right | person to give support]
28 Cross, taken in by dealer? The reverse — not bothered (7)
RELAXED – X [cross] taken in by DEALER, reversed
Down
1 Keep talking about sport — crushing bore? (5,2)
DWELL ON – DON [sport (as in “wear”)] crushing WELL [bore]
2 Unexpected delay — sit without jiggling around (8)
STEADILY – (DELAY SIT*) [“unexpected”]
3 Persuasive chaps maybe getting maiden to enter a place of vice? (5)
ADMEN – M [maiden] to enter A DEN [a place of vice]
4 Swiss hero entering wood mostly sees ahead (9)
FORETELLS – TELL [Swiss hero William] entering FORES{t} [wood “mostly”]
5 Athenian statesman with good parting words (2,4)
SO LONG – SOLON [Athenian statesman] with G [good]
6 One’s right to get cross about bad governance (7)
MISRULE – I’S R [one’s | right] to get MULE [cross] about
7 Former drug mixture (5)
PASTE – PAST E [former | drug]
8 Old-fashioned member of the family dies (6,2)
PASSES ON – PASSE SON [old-fashioned | member of the family]
14 Soldier, about to get aboard that ship (9)
FREIGHTER – FIGHTER [soldier], RE [about] “to get on board that”
16 Broadcasters and the press, group that’s upset referees (8)
MEDIATES – MEDIA [broadcasters and the press] + SET [group], er, upset
17 Intellectual support given to receiver of emails (8)
BRAINBOX – BRA [support] given to INBOX [receiver of emails]
19 Important as he is to them (7)
CENTRAL – “he” is CENTRAL to {t}HE{m}
21 Peacekeepers dream about what they want combatants to become? (7)
UNARMED – UN [peacekeepers] + (DREAM*) [“about”]
22 Series of prayers fired up some (6)
LITANY – LIT ANY [fired up | some]
23 Hat that’s not got left in country cottage (5)
BOWER – BOW{l}ER, that’s not got L [left] in
24 About time, authorise bargain (5)
STEAL – about T [time], SEAL [authorise]
On edit V. if 2d had been “Unexpected delay – sit or not jiggling around”, I would still be trying to find the anagram now.
Edited at 2017-01-20 08:33 am (UTC)
FOI 21dn UNARMED LOI 27ac RALLY
COD BUNTING I suppose WOD SPIRAEA
Edited at 2017-01-20 08:39 am (UTC)
My solving times and completion rates degenerated over the holiday period, and have now started to improve since I’ve returned to healthier lifestyle habits. I’d be devastated to think there’s any causation there. Just tougher puzzles over the holidays, right?
A nice challenge today. SPIRAEA looked more likely than SPIEARA, but I was still relieved to have its existence confirmed.
LOI WARRANTEE after the usual panic about whether I would know the town. Thanks setter and V.
Let’s just leave it at 22 for now.
I must say I was almost convinced by V’s hermeneutics until I got to his interpretation of 11 down, where fancy clearly took flight.
Edited at 2017-01-20 10:11 am (UTC)
The dreaded shrub was almost my undoing, because AI is very good, isn’t it? Even for shrubs, SAIRAEA or SAIEARA looked unlikely, though, not to say unpronounceable, forcing a rethink.
If we’re really going all OVERLORD about this puzzle, it surely can’t be a coincidence that the middle line is (very nearly) an anagram of YOB RULE. My own position is clearly stated withing my TLS blog today: no-one’s better than TRUMP.
I think Donald Trump may be a better president than you think V. Washington has needed a good shake up for years and he may just be the guy to deliver it – we shall see. I’ll reserve judgement rather than view him through prejudiced eyes.
Edited at 2017-01-20 04:09 pm (UTC)
I’m starting to see Trump in every puzzle now … sad!
Edited at 2017-01-20 10:01 am (UTC)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bVDZ5UY_oDw
I keep out of politics on here usually but I’d only say that I’m not celebrating today, nor would I be if the other candidate were being inaugurated. The retiring one looked hopeful at the time but turned out to be a flop. Trump is his legacy.
Edited at 2017-01-20 10:03 am (UTC)
So we come to he Costa Brava for winter sun and get the first real snow in 35 years. That’s global warming for you. No wonder DT is sceptical.
Edited at 2017-01-20 10:56 am (UTC)
horryd Shanghai
Not helped by a very early “DREAM ON” (I was listening Aerosmith this morning) at 1d which made a complete standstill of the NW corner until the light finally dawned on 11a.
10a went in unparsed, and not really sure what purpose “that” was serving in (LOI) 14d
all in all though, an encouraging week, hopefully it won’t take too long to get back into the swing of things after a break Down Under.
Edited at 2017-01-20 12:16 pm (UTC)
One of my dearest university friends ranks, or did rank, “Dream On” as his favourite song. I expect it’s my favourite Aerosmith song at least…
Nothing in Crosswordland makes the old Davest heart sink more than botanical clues. Even if I had managed to select the correct version of ” very good ” from the myriad available, I could easily have spent the next fortnight trying to arrange the anagrist into SPIRAEA even with all the checkers in.
Ah well……
Time: DNF in about an hour.
Thank you to setter and blogger.
I did the puzzle the next day. Pretty easy with some nice clues. I agree with the many people who don’t go for obscure plants (or anything else) clued as anagrams. It’s not sour grapes, either, I got it right (as long as you didn’t try and get AI in there instead of PI, it had to be).
Regular visitors to this site will know that contributors frequently “burp out their “thoughts””, as you so insultingly put it, on any number of topics only loosely connected with the puzzle or the blog, such as music and sport as well as politics. Would you like to see all such asides stopped so that people stick to the matter in hand? That would make for a much duller site IMHO.
Or is the problem that the majority of the political views being expressed lately don’t coincide with your own world view?
On that note I’ll bid you proshchal’nyy privet.
horryd Shanghai
Alan
It’s an interesting viewpoint that Obama is to blame for Trump. And there was me thinking it was the stagnation that resulted from a Republican House of Representatives and a Republican Senate not wanting to cooperate in any way with the occupant of the White House.
In slight mitigation of my crimes I would say that the crosswords themselves do very often have political surfaces to their clues… though the Times is clearly less obviously partisan about that than the Guardian or the Private Eye, to name but two!
horryd – Shanghai
Nice puzzle.
GrayhamP
I agree that if you plan to stay with a cheater don’t try to find any information. However, in my case I needed it in my state in order to file for a divorce and come out of the relationship. You can’t just say I think courts want proof or you end up spending a lot of time and money to fight it out! Finding out was hard, but I was relieved that I wasn’t crazy and it’s making my divorce go a lot smoother. He would never confess; therefore, I did the best thing for me…find out, no doubt, move on!!!contact hotcyberlord@gmail.com.. or text his phone +15402277725 he’s a professional and will surely help you out,tell him from Ninah