* Superb cryptic economy, with a many of the clues weighing in at just 3-5 words;
* Clear mastery of all the tools in the setter’s toolbox – even some of the rarer devices turning up here, the Spoonerism and the &lit;
* A molecule of science, a modicum of the classics, a dash of sport, a Bible character rubbing shoulders with a cattle breed and nautical and camping terminology – all bases covered there;
* Some suitably old-fashioned-feeling (ergo Timesy) vocab without anything likely to provoke a rash of “never heard of its” in today’s comments;
* Really good definition parts, not wilfully obfuscatory but with very, very few instances of something that you can just throw in from the definition straight away. A touch of lateral thinking often required to.
In short while this didn’t strike me as a necessarily pyrotechnical puzzle, as e.g. when you sit down to an Enigmatist in other papers you know you’re in for quite a ride (for better or more infuriating), it’s definitely something I’d be happy to show anyone as an example of all the things that make our hobby clever and good. Major kudos to the setter from me, then.
I was mostly on the wavelength too today, finishing in just over 7 minutes. COD to 2dn (because I’ve still got politics on the brain), SW the toughest quadrant, near-disaster of the day at 8dn where I really wanted to bung in LELL TENT. How about you lot?
Across
1 Polish nationals losing heart (6)
FINISH – FIN{n}ISH [nationals, “losing heart”]
4 Vegetables with gel put in tin some time ago (7)
PESETAS – PEAS [vegetables] with SET [gel] put in
9 Not the sole promoter? (5)
UPPER – being all of a shoe that isn’t the sole; and an UPPER could, rather whimsically, be one who promotes (moves up) something.
10 Some licensees plan a development where trippers take the air? (9)
ESPLANADE – hidden in {license}ES PLAN A DE{velopment}
11 Nestling pigeon was apparently injured and fell out (9)
SQUABBLED – SQUAB BLED [nestling pigeon | was apparently injured]
12 Poet‘s birthplace close to harbour (5)
HOMER – HOME [birthplace] + {harbou}R [“close to…”, i.e. last letter of]
13 Speaker’s shabby appearance (4)
MIEN – homophone of MEAN [“speaker’s” shabby]
14 Hamlet’s hue troubled the old man (10)
METHUSELAH – (HAMLET’S HUE*) [“troubled”]
18 Merry, having drunk up like a champion (10)
SUPPORTIVE – SPORTIVE [merry], having “drunk” UP
20 Section of index maybe that traditionally can’t be split? (4)
ATOM – A TO M would be your “section of index”, presumably preceding N TO Z. But an atom *can* be split, you might protest! Not in Greek though, where the word literally means an “indivisible entity”. Maybe they should rename it a tom.
23 Batsmen’s primary edges? Bowlers’, more likely (5)
BRIMS – B{atsman’s} [“primary”] + RIMS [edges]. BRIMS are the edges of bowler hats.
24 On which you might overhear political policy? (5,4)
PARTY LINE – Not so much of a problem in modern telephony, but well I remember back in the day picking up the handset and getting to listen in to a complete stranger’s conversation. Would today’s children even recognise a rotary dial if they saw one?
25 Reduce pianist’s exercise from the top (5,4)
SCALE DOWN – SCALE [pianist’s exercise] + DOWN [from the top]
26 Pay for bargain (5)
TREAT – very nice double def, as in “pay for someone at lunch” and “treat with the enemy”.
27 Fly biting seabird relentlessly (7)
STERNLY SLY [fly] “biting” TERN [seabird]
28 Securing boat, this lady causes historic damage (6)
SCATHE SHE [this lady], securing CAT [boat]. Being a landlubber I assumed the CAT was probably short for CATAMARAN in some way, but in actual fact a catboat is a vessel with “a single sail and a mast carried well forward”. Not to be confused with a catbus either. Oh, and “historic” damage because we don’t really use “scathe” anymore except in well-trodden contexts, such as “scathing review” or “escaped unscathed”.
Down
1 More of us playing small golf contests (9)
FOURSOMES – (MORE OF US*) [“playing”] + S [small]
2 Ruler at sea, showing strain after rise of pound (7)
NEPTUNE – TUNE [strain] after reversed PEN [“rise of” pound]
3 Writer‘s simple dwelling in Kent perhaps? (6)
SCRIBE – CRIB [simple dwelling] in SE [Kent perhaps]. Though I bet top rappers’ “cribs” are anything but “simple dwellings”.
4 Get the better of journalist introduced by channel (5)
PIPED – PIP ED [get the better of | journalist]
5 The case sailor originally transported? (3,5)
SEA CHEST – (THE CASE S{ailor}*) [“transported”], &lit.
6 They say public transport will prove a hindrance (7)
TRAMMEL – homophone of TRAM’LL [“they say” public transport will]
7 Forecaster adopting new curl of the lip (5)
SNEER – SEER [forecaster] “adopting” N [new]
8 Spooner’s national hero inclined to provide holiday accommodation (4,4)
BELL TENT – Spoonerism of TELL BENT [(Swiss) national hero | inclined]
15 Band from Sussex hanging around (8)
HOVERING – the band from Sussex is the vaguely unsavoury-sounding HOVE RING.
16 Deformity from bash to end of nose (9)
HAMMERTOE – HAMMER [bash] + TO + {nos}E [“end of…”]
17 The Lions’ fresh source of milk? (8)
HOLSTEIN – (THE LIONS*) [“fresh”]. A Holstein cow, of course.
19 High churchman‘s strait-laced spouse missing mass (7)
PRIMATE – PRIM {m}ATE [strait-laced | spouse “missing mass”]
21 Go up to stop explosive weapon (7)
TRIDENT – RIDE [go, up] to “stop” TNT [explosive]
22 Mongolia’s first city’s strangely enigmatic (6)
MYSTIC – M{ongolia’s} [“…first”] + (CITY’S*) [“strangely”]
23 Singer touring one’s grounds (5)
BASIS – BASS [singer] “touring” I [ones]
24 Long-winded chap finally promising to follow (5)
PROSY – {cha}P [“…finally], followed by ROSY [promising]
FOI UPPER LOI ATOM WOD squab COD HOMER
I found this relatively tricky (though thankfully with a smattering of easy clues), some definitions being somewhat opaque, e.g. 4dn, 18ac, 26ac, 27ac.
Lots of nice surfaces. Cheers.
I justified the second part to myself by thinking that a football club might be ‘upped’ a league. I think the question mark is doing quite a lot of work though.
Can I recommend today’s QC and blog?
Last in were the perplexing PESETAS/PIPED pairing. PIPED is somewhat ming-bending. I spent some time looking for the definition everywhere but the right place, as no doubt the setter intended.
I really enjoyed BELL TENT — gloriously silly, as a Spoonerism should be.
Edited at 2016-11-18 09:12 am (UTC)
Never heard of a BELL TENT, but I like a spoonerism. Also enjoyed SQUABBLED and METHUSELAH.
Thanks setter and V. Have a good weekend everyone.
* on reflection and edit, how nice to be reminded of the innocent days of Dan Quayle, when the worst you could expect of a potential president was that he couldn’t spell.
Edited at 2016-11-18 09:34 am (UTC)
Edited at 2016-11-18 10:08 am (UTC)
(JerryW, not signed in)
(JerryW, not signed in)
Ah well. Thanks for the workout and the working out.
Edited at 2016-11-18 10:08 am (UTC)
then inexplicable meltdown with 15,16,21,27,28 taking a further 15.Perhaps I should have popped a 9 (another take for this light)Thanks for the blog great puzzle.
Midas
FOI 10ac ESPLANADE LOI 28ac SCATHE. CAT is short for catamaran as well as the single-sail CAT boats noted in the CAYMAN ISLANDS.
COD 11ac SQUABBLED WOD 14ac METHUSELAH
I also had PIOUS at 24d for a while but corrected it when I got STERNLY.
Trammel is a lovely word – I think V used the even lovelier untrammeled in a previous blog.
Nice puzzle, thanks all round.
Despite my grumpth, I have to concede that this was indeed a fine puzzle, as pointed out by our esteemed blogger.
Talking of AM, there was a time when 2 over par would win you all four Majors. Wanting the handicap increased! Sheer banditry…
Also, I had ‘pious’ for PROSY, so would never have got STERNLY.
Challenging puzzle, which didn’t become any easier after I’d gone away for several hours to have a think about it…
“Oh, yes. I have been looking sternly for months now!” Or is it just me?
Glad the book is finally useful for something…. 🙂
Edited at 2016-11-18 06:02 pm (UTC)
Nice to have an example that shows the words (very probably, and with a high degree of approximation) acting in very similar ways.
I think you can argue that ‘relentless’ on its own is a rather unsatisfactory definition for ‘stern’, but in the circumstances we have to take this argument to the lexicographers, not the setter.
FWIW I have great respect for the work of lexicographers: their job is like nailing jelly to a wall and they do it admirably.
However I would say that being “stern” definitely presupposes an unwillingness to “relent” in my mind. So after a small hesitation I was happy enough that it worked and pressed the submit button!
Edited at 2016-11-18 10:50 pm (UTC)
An interesting and enjoyable puzzle.
Quite tricky, but reasonably fast all the same except 24 dn where an extended alphabet trawl was needed.
Rob