For a while it seemed this puzzle too would fall foul of the dreadful curse of 2016, being a game of two halves wherein I had all but one light solved and filled in in about 8 minutes… and then spent a whole other 8 scratching my head over 5ac. The old verlaine would just have slammed in WASH UP or even LASH UP and hit submit but I’m trying to be better than that now. BASH and UP did of course occur very early on but you can’t have a clue without a definition part! And it took me an awful long time to convince myself that there really was an adequate one, hidden in plain sight. A very ingenious bit of setting, then, but the source of too much and recent pain to be in contention for my COD, methinks.
Leaving 5 aside, this was a superlatively clever puzzle, arguably too clever in a few places. I really liked 12ac, in my capacity as an employee of the music industry, for the seamless “alternative band”, but my tired brain couldn’t work out if the “as” wasn’t a superfluous word. In a similar vein, 25ac had a nice surface, but all the working out which letter goes “on” and which “near” which other letter was as fiddly and fatiguing as one of my own run-on sentences. I quibble only because in general this was brilliant stuff and, no complaints this time around, a proper Friday challenge. I’ll give my actual COD nod to 20ac for being a masterpiece of cluing economy and simplicity that nevertheless manages to conceal its answer a lot longer than you might expect.
And of course I loved that this managed to include what felt like very topical allusions to both Brexit and the US election, as well as grouping AESOP and ANDERSEN, both purveyors of tales which are also more likely on balance to contain dire warnings than happy endings, on the same row. Let’s knock half a point off out of pique for how long 5ac took me and call it 4 and a half stars overall. Bravo, whichever evil fiend was responsible, bravo!
Across
1 Please don’t panic, clumsily engaging gear (4,2,2)
PACK IT IN – (PANIC*) [“clumsily”] engaging KIT [gear]
5 Do over (4,2)
BASH UP – individually, a BASH is a “do”, and UP is “over”; taken as a whole, BASH UP means “do over”
10 Part of Europe where Parisian wears fancy winter clothes (3,3,9)
THE LOW COUNTRIES – OU [where “Parisian”, i.e. the French word for “where”] wears (WINTER CLOTHES*) [“fancy”]
11 Note principal features of European referendum: a good deal for the country (7)
GERMANY – G [note] + E{uropean} R{eferendum} [“principle features of…”] + MANY [a good deal]
12 Making comeback as alternative band recruits singular top musician (7)
MAESTRO – reverse [“making comeback”] the whole of OR TEAM [alternative | band] recruiting S [singular]
13 Producer‘s request: character should omit line (8)
BEGETTER – BEG [request] + {l}ETTER [character “omitting” L for line]
15 Medic at last probes painful scratch (5)
SCORE – {medi}C [“at last”] probes SORE [painful]
18 Fabulous writer circulating main work (5)
AESOP – reverse of SEA [“circulating” main] + OP [work]. Aesop (620-564 BCE) is famous for his fables, hence the “fabulous” here.
20 Author with Irish name (8)
ANDERSEN – AND ERSE N [with | Irish | name]
23 Distilled brandy put in wine (7)
REFINED – FINE [brandy] put in RED [wine]
25 Island on a lake, perched near area in old Gallic region (7)
ALSATIA – I [island], on A L SAT [a | lake | perched], near A [area]
26 Avoided having offer of spacious on-board accommodation? (5,1,4,5)
GIVEN A WIDE BERTH – a literalistic interpretation of the originally nautical, now clichéd phrase.
27 Shoot at wretch knocked over by cop (6)
TARGET – RAT reversed [wretch “knocked over”] + GET [cop]
28 Examiner wanted dunces to have time out of class (8)
ASSESSOR – ASSES [dunces] + SOR{t} [class, having T for time “out”]
Down
1 Soup container: boil without lid (6)
POTAGE – POT [container] + {r}AGE [boil “without lid”]
2 Depressing advice to overenthusiastic supporters? (9)
CHEERLESS – if your supporters are getting out of control, you might advise them to CHEER LESS. But not if you’re Donald Trump of course.
3 A long time redeveloping a region (4,3)
IRON AGE – (A REGION*) [“redeveloping…”]
4 Very minor leader deposed, causing sensation (5)
ITCHY – {t}ITCHY [very minor, “leader deposed”]
6 She performs on front of stage, among characters from cast (7)
ACTRESS – RE S{tage} [on | “front of” stage], among (CAST*) [“characters from…”]
7 Jack is outwardly very sexy (5)
HOIST – IS, outwardly HOT [very sexy]
8 Drink up and hang around for a piece of cake (8)
PUSHOVER – SUP reversed [drink “up”] + HOVER [hang around]
9 Spent season meandering at first on lake in south of France (8)
SUMMERED – M{eandering} [“at first”] on MERE [lake], in SUD [south “of France”]
14 Bulldoze each road in urban area (4,4)
TEAR DOWN – EA RD [each | road] in TOWN [urban area]
16 Upsets Open University, with grants being regularly cut (9)
OVERTURNS – OVERT U [Open | University] + {g}R{a}N{t}S [“being regularly cut”]
17 Political extremists fear a Republican will get in (3,5)
FAR RIGHT – FRIGHT [fear], A R [a | Republican] will get in
19 Final character expelled from Cornwall town getting punishment (7)
PENANCE – PEN{z}ANCE [Cornwall town, losing the “final character”, i.e. Z]
21 Twice jumping up when bitten by bug? That’s ludicrous (7)
RISIBLE – BIS reversed [twice “jumping up”] when bitten by RILE [bug]
22 Club attracts female swimmer (6)
BATHER – BAT [club] attracts HER [female]
24 Financier’s case containing this writer’s money (5)
FIVER – F{inancie}R [“case”] containing I’VE [this writer’s]
25 Inventive fellow in total disarray (5)
ALDIS – hidden in {tot}AL DIS{array}. Arthur Aldis invented the Aldis lamp for Morse code signalling. I read and solved this clue as “incentive fellow”, and who’s to say he wasn’t quite generous with his lamps in return for favours?
CODs to 11a and 17d just for political timing.
I now feel terrible for making light of Leonard Cohen’s “I’m ready to die” line recently. I didn’t think he meant it. RIP, indeed. I’ll second Verlaine’s praise for his literary merits. He was good.
The singer-songwriter later clarified that he was “exaggerating.” “I’ve always been into self-dramatization,” Cohen said last month. “I intend to live forever.”
Edited at 2016-11-11 12:01 pm (UTC)
Agree with V about the Nobel prize; LC seemed to me to be a better candidate and poet, but was so dreary and depressing to listen to.
I actually thought that this offering was ‘a bit vanilla’ for a Friday and made it in 35 mins. 5ac had to be BASH-UP and 20ac ANDERSEN was my COD too.
FOI 10ac THE LOW COUNTRIES LOI 21dn RISIBLE a somwhat tortured clue IMHO.
WOD ALDIS and his magic lamp
I wasn’t sure about FINE for “brandy” but vaguely remembered perhaps meeting it before. As a non-scientific person (apart from having gained a pass in O-level physics much to the surprise of my science teacher)I was pleased to remember Aldis and that he’d a lamp named after him.
Sad to hear about Leonard Cohen. I am sure that he produced many fine songs and poems since the Sixties but to me he will ever be associated with the droning Suzanne which seemed to be played endlessly by my studymate in my mid-teens.
Given the worrying instruction noted by The Toff at 5,10 and 11, what are we to make of the acknowledgement at 23, 25, 26?
I wonder what the late Leonard makes of his “Hallelujah” being by far his best known work, getting regular outings on X Factor and such. Can’t wait for Holly G’s version: “H to the A to the L to the Y to the L to the OOYAH!” (slum TV’s reference of the day).
Very sad to hear about Leonard Cohen, a musician who only really came to my attention quite recently, and partly through this very blog, among a few other coincidental mentions that piqued my interest. I shall be blasting out First We Take Manhattan as soon as I’m sure my neighbours have set off for work.
Edited at 2016-11-11 10:37 am (UTC)
“The women tear their blouses off, and the men they dance on the polka dots….”. We loved you, Leonard.
We went to see Leonard Cohen at the O2 when he resumed touring because his partner/business manager had nicked all his money. It was clear that, having decided to perform again reluctantly and out of financial necessity, he was astonished and delighted by the reception he was getting, and how much he was enjoying himself. It was an absolute delight, one of the best concerts I’ve ever been to. I have never found his music remotely depressing, but then I find Philip Larkin’s poetry cheers me up so perhaps I’m just a bit odd.
2. That Suzanne song was a dreary dirge repeated too often when I was a student, such that I never bothered to decipher its deeper meanings.
3. Can’t recall anything else by Mr Cohen.
4. Satie, Gymnopédies, on the other hand, are reflective, introspective, not depressing at all.
Just saying.
I always sang the whole of Suzanne as I went up the chair lifts as a kid – still play his songs at our folk sessions.
Sad indeed about Cohen although I confess that I don’t have much of his music and I have a lot more of Dylan’s. I’ve always thought they were both better songwriters than singers, and as evidence of that I’d cite Jennifer Warnes’ Famous Blue Raincoat album which is made up of all Cohen covers, and individual Dylan songs covered by other artists such as Mr Tambourine Man by The Byrds, All Along The Watchtower by Jimi Hendrix and I Dreamed I Saw St Augustine by Thea Gilmore.
The south was done in ten minutes, so felt on for a PB but held up by 4d where I pondered s(l)ight and then (s)light for an absolute age. The penny dropped when I got 1ac.
I was then stymied by 5ac, of which I was convinced Make Up was correct. That made 7d looking distinctly unlikely (edict, exist, evict?)
Finally saw the light on 7d, which made 5ac a write in for me, but another 30mins had elapsed, so definitely no PB.
Thanks to jackkt for explaining bis – had vaguely had this as bi twice = bis so, like Matt, another one to add to the list.
Quality crossword & enjoyed untangling the misdirections!
Edited at 2016-11-11 10:57 pm (UTC)
“ERSE! FECK! DRINK!”
Cunning, eh?
Despite that, I enjoyed this fine puzzle very much. Fortunately BASH UP didn’t take me too long. And no problem with ALDIS either, known long before Monty Python’s brief excerpt from Julius Caesar on an Aldis Lamp:
My compliments to the setter.
Martin in Bonn