Solving time : 12:22 and I felt like I wasn’t at my best, and indeed I’m the third person to have completed the puzzle and have the slowest time (and just as I go to double-check this, Verlaine is also in with five minutes faster than me).
I suspect the key would be to get the two long entries straight off, but I couldn’t unravel the anagram quickly at the top and didn’t twig what was going on at the bottom the first time through. The rest of the wordplay is solid (one minor quibble at 27), and I don’t think there’s anything too obscure in the grid.
Away we go…
Across | |
---|---|
1 | THE ELGIN MARBLES: anagram of THEMES,RING,A,BELL |
9 | STINGIEST: anagram of GETS,IN,IT’S |
10 |
VOWEL: the definition is “a, for example” – VOW(pledge) and then L |
11 | ODESSA: hidden reversed in pASSED Out |
12 | SPARE RIB: RIB(ridicule) with SPARE(free) – definition is course |
13 | FA,CIA,L |
15 | BOAT RACE: or BOA TRACE |
18 | PROPERTY: double definition |
19 | ESTEEM: definition is judge – MEETS(is introduced to),E reversed, |
21 | SPERM OIL: anagram of OR,SIMPLE |
23 | BASKET: ASK(sue, petition) inside BET |
26 | BRAWN: double definition |
27 | PREMIERED: PREMIER, ED – I have an eyebrow raised here, I’ve associated PREMIER with the leader of a state rather than a nation and not the prime minister – I was looking for the name of a PM followed by ED. Anyhoo I could be totally wrong, there’s a 475th time for everything |
28 | GOLDEN RETRIEVER: double definition with one based on Jason (spoiler alert) bringing back the golden fleece. |
 | |
Down | |
1 | TOSS OFF: another double definition with a cryptic quality for one of them – the TOSS has to happen before a cricketball match starts |
2 | ELITE: TILE reversed, E |
3 | LEG,IS,LATE |
4 | IBEX: XI(sportsball team) reversed containing BE |
5 | METAPHOR: sounds like MET A FOUR |
6 | ROVER: R, OVER(past) |
7 | LOWER CASE: LOWER(reduce), CASE(cover) |
8 |
SOLUBLE: anagram of |
14 | CLOSE CALL: CLOSE(complete), CALL(justification, as in “there was a call for this action”) |
16 | TOSCANINI: Arturo… the opera TOSCA followed by IN reversed twice |
17 | STRIPPER: double definition |
18 | POSTBAG: POST(after),BAG(appropriate) |
20 | MATADOR: DATA in ROM, all reversed |
22 |
MANSE: MAN(staff),S |
24 |
KIROV: ballet company – KIR(mixed drink), O |
25 | DEFT: D, then LEFT missing the L |
My biggest problem was looking for a shocking work of avant-garde nastiness for 1 across, only to see it when I had most of the crossing letters. On the other hand, I put in the dog immediately.
I think we’ve seen the ‘boa trace’ before, and Toscanini is always turning up. Maybe we should bring back Tiepolo?
Edited at 2016-09-22 01:50 am (UTC)
Edited at 2016-09-22 03:47 pm (UTC)
Part of the problem is doing the crossword on the computer. I would’ve got 1ac much quicker if I’d jotted the anagram letters down in traditional fashion.
Not many eye-catching clues today, though 11ac, 7dn and 25dn are good. Biff of the Day: LEGISLATE
I think PREMIER = PM, is fine, btw.
LOI 27 ac PREMIERED When I was a lad PM’s (Churcill, MacMillan)were also noted as PREMIERs but PMs appear to have became less and less special over the years.
FOI 16dn TOSCANINI and WOD
What is a META-FOR?
12ac SPARE RIB without alluding to les femmes.
COD 7dn LOWER CASE
Roll on Friday.
horryd Shanghai
Speaking of which, am I the only one to have felt slightly disturbed/excited at the appearance of TOSS OFF in The Thunderer?
37 minutes and change.
That aside, a most enjoyable solve requiring 37 of your Earth minutes with at least 10 of them spent, quite inexplicably, trying to find the answers at 14dn and 18ac. I seem to be losing my ability to finish off neatly once the end is in sight these days. Maybe it’s an age thing.
Horry mentions the rarity of having SPARE RIB without “les femmes”. I would add BOAT RACE without CRS for “face” being involved.
Edited at 2016-09-22 05:06 am (UTC)
LOI: TOSS OFF, as I too was disturbed by this appearance. Not excited, though. And SPERM OIL? Well, I’d not come across this before…
I was a bit puzzled by 8dn because I took ‘deliquescent’ (meaning something like ‘delinquent’) to be the anagrind, leaving ‘liquid’ as the definition. It was obviously the answer though so I shrugged and moved on. Now I’ve learned a new word.
The usage at 1dn must surely survive only in the form of double entendre.
Edited at 2016-09-22 07:20 am (UTC)
It doesn’t help when you type in TOSCAINNI and so spend 5 minutes staring at 27a quite bewildered. And I was mighty close to chucking in STEAM OIL for 21a, deciding at the last moment to take another look.
Any setter who uses “deliquescent” to suggest an anagram is alright with me. And thanks, George, for the memorable deliquescent / desiccant primer.
Anyway, nice crossword today. One under par for me.
I get why George queried Premier v PM. In Australia “Premier” specifically refers to the political leader of a state, but fortunately I was aware of its more generic usage.
Hard to go past TOSS OFF for COD. LOI was PROPERTY.
Thanks setter and George.
Edited at 2016-09-22 10:32 am (UTC)
Sorry about this but just testing iphone. Enjoyed this one on treeware without having a clue what SPERM OIL was or what it was for.
Edited at 2016-09-22 08:44 pm (UTC)
Edited at 2016-09-22 09:53 pm (UTC)
It’s possible that I’m missing something obvious, but I don’t really understand CALL = “justification” in 1dn. (Your example seems to point to the more familiar CALL = “demand”.)
All in all, I thought this was an agreeable and fair puzzle, though without any particular high points. And now to Friday’s…