My FOI was 14ac, a good thing probably as the splendidly ambiguous definition there gave me a strong hint about what to expect from the rest of the puzzle; also, the solution is a fun piece of vocab, a very crosswordy word, so hopefully we’re in for that kind of a grid. And, while our finchy friend is actually probably the obscurest word of the day, I was not to be disappointed: before we’re done we’ll be running into writers and historians and philosophers and chanteurs and revolutionaries and my favourite ever astronaut (one who met a very sad and singular 17dn). Which as I’ve banged on about many a time[1] is, to me, kind of what the Times Cryptic crossword is for.
And the surfaces are great, the cluing is concise, and some of the wordplay is spectacular. I’m sure “meat-packing firm” must have been done before but it’s still wonderful, “two hours before noon” is a wonderful thing, 21ac is an irreproachably obfuscated anagram clue, I loved the lift-and-separate element in “pear drop” in 9dn, how clever of 17dn to make me think the answer might be (somehow) an anagram of “designs”… and in a similar vein, my COD in the event, 5dn: hopefully I was not the only one to spend a while trying to jumble “XL corset” into anything useful, while the actual route to the solution was hiding brilliantly in plain sight.
I would have finished in 12 minutes and change if I hadn’t hesitated over 1ac as my LOI – in the end I decided that T_T_ couldn’t be anything else, and slammed the submit button at the 13 minute mark – luckily everything parsed successfully in the event, which isn’t always the case for a seat-of-the-pants solver like myself. I wouldn’t have begrudged spending a lot longer than 13 minutes on a puzzle of this quality though, and I see from the club board that many of you were so taken with it that you did. Many many thanks to the setter – I don’t see the applause for this one 17ac any time soon!
[1] Which reminds me, I didn’t mark the exact date, but I’m pretty sure I’ve been blogging the Friday puzzles for 2 years now. Happy blogday to me! Are you all sick of me yet?
Across
1 Bear’s short tail on parade (4)
TOTE – TOT [short] + {parad}E
3 Wind up watch containing large crack (3-7)
RIB-TICKLER RIB [wind up] + TICKER [watch] containing L [large]
10 Polish meat-packing firm exists (7)
CHAMOIS – HAM [meat] packing CO [firm] + IS [exists]
11 Yank I go after turns, giving thumbs-up (7)
OKAYING – (YANK I GO*)
12 Make tracks in the style of Charles Trenet? (4,6,5)
TAKE FRENCH LEAVE – cryptic definition. Charles Trenet was a French singer-songwriter who recorded an awful lot of songs; but those aren’t the type of tracks that are being made here.
13 Philosopher right to stop one abandoning use of irony (6)
SARTRE – R [right] to stop SAT{i}RE [“one abandoning” use of irony]
14 Brakes go for repair: one’s got a hefty bill (8)
GROSBEAK – (BRAKES GO*)
17 Job in kitchen cutting rabbit? (6,2)
DRYING UP – double def with drying up as in “running out of things to say”.
18 Writing two hours before noon, backing support for chairman (6)
MAOISM – reverse of MS + 10 A.M. [writing + two hours before noon]
21 No cooker being moved could go inside empty lounge (6,9)
GOLDEN DELICIOUS – (COULD GO INSIDE L{oung}E*); “no cooker” as in, not a cooking apple
23 Constables act unlawfully, holding back lunatic (7)
NUTCASE – hidden in reverse in {constabl}ES ACT UN{lawfully}
24 To travel widely perhaps in sound of interest to marine biologist? (3,4)
SEE LIFE – homophone of SEA LIFE (an interest to a marine biologist)
25 Runs to prevent encounters with strangers here? (7,3)
SINGLES BAR – SINGLES BAR [runs | to prevent]
26 Provide with old cutting device (4)
PLOY – PLY [provide] with O [old] cutting it
Down
1 Historian’s account in NT book (7)
TACITUS – AC [account] in TITUS [NT book]
2 Author, one who’s apparently broken into Flower of Scotland? (9)
THACKERAY – HACKER into TAY (a Flower as in a river, naturally…)
4 Gets taken to court, then released (6)
ISSUED – double def with IS SUED [gets taken to court]
5 XL corset adjusted, without being tucked in (3-5)
TWO-SCORE – (CORSET*), with W/O being tucked in. XL as in Roman for 40, of course.
6 Much older partner’s tips for excavator after rock sample (6-8)
CRADLE-SNATCHER – E{xcavato}R after CRADLE SNATCH [rock | sample]
7 Ultimately surreal alias protecting one early space traveller (5)
LAIKA – {surrea}L + A.K.A. [alias] protecting I [one]
8 Artist, Greek, hosting small charity event (3,4)
RAG WEEK – R.A. [artist] + GK [Greek] hosting WEE [small]
9 What several can hold pear drop in (10,4)
CONFERENCE CALL – CONFERENCE CALL [pear | drop in]
15 English girl to shelter revolutionary leader (9)
EDITORIAL – E DI TO [English | girl | to] + reverse of LAIR [shelter]
16 Summer wear? After start of September prepare for shower! (8)
SUNDRESS – S{eptember} + UNDRESS [prepare for shower]
17 Trouble with designs that can’t be drawn on any more? (3-4)
DOG-ENDS – DOG [trouble] + ENDS [designs]; drawn on as in smoked
19 Skill putting answer for first of puzzle’s unknowns (7)
MASTERY – M{y->A}STERY
20 State request in a note (6)
ALASKA – ASK [request] in A LA [a | note]
22 Mexican from city with money (5)
LATIN – L.A. [city] + TIN [money]
I spent I don’t know how long stuck on EDITORIAL / PLOY, which on reflection look like two of the easier clues. And a long time, more excusably, to twig the ‘XL’ reference.
Brilliant, if hard (for me) to love. Bit like Novak Djokovic. Thanks setter and blogger from this benighted slogger.
Only to savour the excellence of the clues (of course) I dawdled over this for a full 30 minutes. A couple of things slowed me: I biffed CONFERENCE ROOM (smaller that a hall, so suitable for “several” rather than many, and hesitated over GROSBEAK because I didn’t think this setter would lower the tone to Harry Potter. Wrong in at least two ways.
I was also puzzled over TOT for short, until I realised that short was a noun, not an adjective.
Happy blogaversary, V. When I worked as an office drone, I kept a Dilbert cartoon on my desk which showed one character receiving a mysterious text message saying “KEEP UP WRK”. This, of course, turns out to be his annual performance review; it was strikingly similar to what we got in real life, so I offer you the same sentiments.
3, 10, 15 and 18 all got ticks; 5 got two.
There was some great stuff in there – 5d was my COD – but my reaction was the opposite of our blogger’s: I thought there were more weaknesses than normal. I’m always prepared to admit if I’ve missed something, but I thought 2d was a stretch, 22d too vague, 13a weak, and I’ve marked a couple more with crosses as well.
Maybe I’m just in a bad mood because I’ve just discovered I’ve entered four incorrect Listeners already this year…
I didn’t finish it!! I’m not keen on clues where the answer is a person (my general knowledge did not stretch to Tacitus (or even Titus – had the “ac” though)). Did know of Sartre, but did not get that either. Did get Thackeray somehow, despite not even knowing what he’s written! (American novelist?)
I think one “person” is enough in a crossword.
Had never heard of Gk for Greek, but put it in anyway, and it apparently is a thing.
Agree, cradle = rock seemed dodgy, but I had enough letters to be confident. Wasn’t sure about tot = short either, but put that in. Never heard of chamois as a verb, but put that in.
Gutted I didn’t see nutcase. Couldn’t do Maoism either, but great clue.
Couldn’t see the definition for two score, but put that in anyway (yes, great clue!).
So, a very clever crossword, but for me not enjoyable as: I couldn’t finish it, and; half the ones I put in I still had queries on, so not confident about my checkers!! V stressful.
Hats off to all of you who did it!!!
Mark I
Edited at 2016-06-03 12:15 pm (UTC)
Dereklam
There are lots that could be CODs; probably my favourite is 5, with that great definition.
My only query in the end was 13, where I wasn’t wholly convinced that the cryptic syntax works as intended. Can “right to stop one abandoning use of irony” really be read to mean the same as “right to stop irony that one has abandoned”? I’ve come across the construction before and it’s always troubled me (and others with whom I’ve discussed it).
Where I draw the line would be something like ‘X that’s abandoned y’ where X becomes the grammatical focus of the clause and in that case, to me, it could only reasonably refer to x and not y
RR
Was very satisfied to finish all correct, and just inside the only target that matters (refer to Ulaca’s comment above).
Nothing to add to the deserved praise already bestowed, but my favourite was the TWO-SCORE.
Brilliant blog as well. Thanks setter and V.
My only niggle is with 2dn: I can’t see how it works. Doesn’t this require HACKER to be defined by ‘one who’s broken’?
As others have said, an absolutely cracking puzzle – one of the best in my 50+ years of solving the Times crossword. I’d dearly like to know the identity of the setter; anyway, if they’d care to tap me on the shoulder the next time we meet, I’d be delighted to buy them a drink.
A v. big thanks to setter, and to verlaine.
Thanks for the correct parsing of 1a. I got it, but the wrong way. Thought bear’s equals totes, take off the last letter giving tote, which I took to be a possible meaning of to parade (as a verb). Notwithstanding, given the degree of difficulty (to me) of this crossword, I will still take it.
Thanks again.
Barry M
In spite of that, I admire the many clever clues and the inventiveness that the setter brought to this puzzle. The only clues I had difficulty with were 1A (TOTE), 19D (MASTERY) and 26A (PLOY). There were several answers that I had to guess and then retrofit the wordplay – and in most cases I could see what the setter was getting at. 21A was an amazing and unexpected anagram that fooled me for a while.
Alan
Finding the sweet spot between clever and a bit too clever is definitely the crossword solver’s art. I’m definitely happy for them to try to push that envelope personally…
Thanks again
Alan Browne