This puzzle took a very sharp upward curve in terms of difficulty from my POV. Straight in with the nice long 1ac to give me a start, and a few other early gimmes left me thinking this was going to be a sprint like yesterday, but I found myself at walking pace by the end, as I filled in the “middle bits”, the result of all that being a time of 15:42. The setter may have carefuly planned it so that the puzzle all came together piece by piece at the end, as the trickier clues revealed themselves, or it may just have been me failing to see the wood for the trees.
(Trying to explain how this felt, I came up with the idea that some crosswords require inspiration, and others require perspiration; this one started as the former and ended as the latter. Let’s see if the collective experience matched mine.)
Across | |
---|---|
1 | STATE OF THE ART – if you see “gallery” and immediately think “Tate”, the enumeration makes this a write-in. TATE in SOFT, HEART. The definition is “contemporary”, though it makes a nice surface which calls to mind the Tate Modern on the Southbank. |
8 | REST – BREST is the port, take out the B{ritish}. |
9 | PAINKILLER – PILL swallows [A INK], followed by the hesitant ER. |
10 | START OUT – or STAR / TOUT, which would be a playful way of expressing brilliant / solicitor. |
11 | MOLEST – MOLE by ST{reet}. |
13 | COVERTURES – C{old} OVERTURES. This was one of the late ones which needed a lot of checkers before I got to grips with it, mostly because I don’t think I know the word, though it looks obviously right once you write it down. |
16 | COOP – POOC{H}rev. Once you have C_O_, it’s not as hard as it is with, say, _A_E to come up with words which might work, though COOP as “basket” didn’t really ring true at first if the only one you know is the sort which holds chickens – it turns out there is a specific, secondary, definition, which is a basket used in catching fish. |
17 | SAGO – S.A.=”sex appeal”=”it”, GO(=try). |
18 | DEMOLISHED – DEMO(=rally), {fina}L, I SHED. |
20 | TOILET – TOILE, T{emperature}. Fabrics are rather like horse-drawn carriages, in that most of my knowledge of the subtly different types comes almost entirely from crosswords. TOILE is one of them: all I can say about it is that it’s easily mistaken for TULLE. |
22 | LAME DUCK – I took a long time to parse this satisfactorily – if I hadn’t been blogging, I’d probably have said it was one of those “don’t try to over-analyse it, you can see what it’s getting at, it’s sort of cryptic” clues, and considered it…well, a bit lame. However, I know you deserve better than that, so I eventually spotted that the “game” has nothing to do with sport, but is the less common British slang – also expressed in the phrase “gammy leg”, which makes the difference between the two more abundantly clear – so it’s LAME(=game), DUCK(=no score) and it’s an &lit. That’s more like it. |
24 | LACERATION – broken down into LACE RATION, because Nottingham is a long-standing centre for the production of LACE. This may have puzzled non-UK solvers (and some UK solvers, probably). |
26 | VIEW – VIE, W{ith}. Is a view the same as a conviction? Close enough. |
27 | KITCHEN GARDEN – KIT(=supplies), then ENG{land} in C{onservative} HARDEN(=set). |
Down | |
1 | SWEET POTATO – (STEW,PATE,TOO)*. |
2 | ASTIR – reverse hidden in caR ITS Always. |
3 | EXPLOITED – ITE{m} in EX PLOD. The archetypal policeman P.C. Plod may be another peculiarly British reference which eludes overseas solvers… |
4 | FRITTER – {diete}R in FITTER. Mmmm…fritters. |
5 | HOKUM – OK(=yes) in HUM(=unpleasant smell). |
6 | ALL BLACKS – (BALL)*, LACKS(=needs). I imagine even non-rugby union fans are familiar with the repeat world champions from New Zealand. Taking it further, the best nickname in sport is the New Zealand basketball team, who are known as the Tall Blacks. |
7 | TIE – sTaInEd. |
12 | SMOKESCREEN – SMOKE=London=generally, “the big city”, SCREEN. |
14 | EMOLLIENT – gangster’s MOLL, I.E. hidden in E.N.T., your ear, nose and throat department. |
15 | SALAMANCA – if you can’t see the wordplay, and you have the final letter A, there are lots of possibilities which suggest themselves, so I toyed with Barcelona, and Tarragona, and Cartagena, which has the bonus of having a cut-off gent in it. With more checkers, I finally worked out that it’s A MAN in [A CLAS{S}]. |
19 | MULLION – MULL(=study), 1 ON. The upright bar in a window with several panes. |
21 | TEACH – A is the top grade (no such thing as A* in Crosswordland), inserted into TECH, short for Technical College. |
23 | DAVID – D{irect} A VID. Best-known, I’d say, for The Death of Marat. |
25 | AUK – A{rea}, U.K. See previous blogs for long discussions about the technical differences between Britain, Great Britain, the UK etc. etc. One of those where even I would suggest it’s overly pedantic to point out the difference, even more so to claim it’s going to stop anyone solving the clue. |
Like the Nottingham rent allowance
I had “Say Go” for starting a race at 17a.
Edited at 2015-12-15 11:47 am (UTC)
Didn’t know the particular meaning of coop and couldn’t remember what Nottingham (or Dottingham in my current state) was famous for but had a long list of things it wasn’t, such as shoes, hats, steel and seafood.
Whilst struggling with the bottom downs I paused to try and parse the previously-biffed kitchen garden to make sure it was correct but couldn’t see it and decided that “engarde” might mean “set” as in “ready… set… thrust/parry”.
I thought there were some terrifically concise clues with, on closer inspection after the event, highly plausible surfaces like those for hokum, teach, molest, sago and view.
Didn’t manage to parse LAME DUCK or LACERATION. Had no idea what was produced in Nottingham, after eliminating “nightmare Test match scenarios” as a possibility.
Nice challenging puzzle. Thanks setter and Tim.
The SE half was much more difficult, but eventually yielded when DEMOLISHED and the Spanish city revealed themselves. (As a kid I would get myself lost in Spanish City in Whitley Bay for hours at a time!).
Overall, very satisfying. Nice puzzle, nice blog.
Failed to parse ‘lame duck’, for the reason anticipated by Tim, so the sublety of the clue was wasted on me.
Thanks setter and blogger.
my LOI as I was biffed my own acronym shoving in COACH for TEACH and so took long enough to realise that woolic (or -loc or – lac) weren’t ever going to be parsable. I really enjoyed the puzzle and thought LAME DUCK excellent. No problems with 1a – it’s always nice to get a flying start. Thanks blogger and setter today!
Edited at 2015-12-15 05:37 pm (UTC)
I had a full 18 out of 27 answers written in within 10 minutes, easily my best time to date! But an hour later, I still lacked the entire bottom half: TOILET, LAME DUCK, LACERATION, TEACH, MULLION, COOP, and SMOKESCREEN. I had suspected all of these but couldn’t understand the wordplay and so (foolishy perhaps) refused to put them in.
In the end I had CART [reversal of TRAC(k)] instead of COOP, which didn’t help matters. And I was certain that ‘minimum temperature’ would involve C or K somehow — IC or OK, or something like that. Perhaps a bit far fetched but so was ‘toile’.
Thanks to topicaltim for helping me see the very many Britishisms that would have been helpful. There’s always tomorrow…
My LOI was SALAMANCA, because (a) I was very slow to parse it and (b) I was fairly certain that he was a Bond villain.
It’s taken me over 50 years to handle the Times’ crossword – I fear it will take me another 50 to get the hang of the Listener’s.
A pleasant straightforward solve. I’ve no objection to “art” appearing in 1ac and its answer. (I didn’t even notice it at the time, and in retrospect I think the clue is better with it.)