Now I apologise to the setter in advance because when I wax effusive it always provokes a backlash, but I basically loved this, didn’t mind at all that it was on the hard side when it all seemed eminently fair and there were so many examples of clever surfaces and cunning wordplay to treasure. The hidden definitions at 27ac, 28ac, 6dn are all brilliant in my book; witness the likes of 8dn and 17dn where the sentences need to be completely re-resolved from their superficial reading to make an entirely new cryptic sense; and a welter of splendidly lucid surfaces that of course have nothing to do with the ultimate answer (2dn, 21dn, 14ac). I liked the mislead in 1ac which initially looks certain to by a homophone, and despite being mostly vegan loved 18ac’s use of Hamburger – I’ll declare that to be my COD, though frankly I feel spoilt for choice.
As I say the SE held me up in the end: 20ac remained mysterious to me, despite it being obvious how the clue needed to work, until I looked up the opera afterwards (if you’d asked me yesterday, I probably would have confidently identified NABUCCO as the company who make Shredded Wheat), and likewise 17dn took forever because, while again having a good idea of what was being asked of me, I’d mentally pencilled in an E between the final two D’s. But then the 21dn penny finally dropped, 20ac couldn’t really be anything else and I finally made it home with a groan probably audible on the other side of the Thames.
Thanks again setter for a masterclass in leading me up numerous garden paths in pursuit of elusive wild geese… I just hope my fellow solvers won’t be too compensatorily unimpressed!
Across | |
1 | ORALLY – from speech: O [nothing] + RALLY [pick up] |
4 | ST MORITZ – resort: RITZ [hotel] by (MOST*) [“after refurbishment”] |
10 | A MUGS GAME – it’s futile: MUG [rob], AS GAME [when | willing] “to go without” |
11 | THORN – old letter: THO [however] + reverse of NR [near, “sent back”] |
12 | GIRASOL – colourful gemstone: GIRL [lass] “holds” A SO [a | very] |
13 | ABDOMEN – corporation: AB [rating (as in seaman)] + DO MEN [satisfy | people] |
14 | STAIR – rung: STAR [celebrity] “has ringed” I [one] |
15 | NON-EVENT – great disappointment: N [{rejectio}N “at last”] + ONE VENT [I | express] |
18 | CHOW MEIN – sort of food: H [hard] “to cut” COW [beef] + MEIN [Hamburger’s my (i.e. “my” in German)] |
20 | CUBAN – national: reverse of NABUC{co} [opera “company’s ignored” “on return”] |
23 | PAN LOAF – Scottish sandwich maker: (PAL OF AN*) [“eccentric”] |
25 | PRUSSIA – country, once: “submerged in” {propagand}A IS SURP{risingly} “backward” |
26 | RUSES – dodges: USES [customs] after R [“tip from” {office}R] |
27 | ACIDIFIED – made tart: reverse of DEIF{y} I’D I CA [turn to God “briefly” | I had | one | about] “to turn” |
28 | WINE LIST – Graves could be on this: WIN ST [land | stone] where ELI [prophet] “is buried” |
29 | AGE-OLD – antique: E [key] “to open” A GOLD [a | precious metal] |
Down | |
1 | ORANGISH – turning amber: OR [men] by H [hospital] “holding up” SIGNA{l} [signal… “almost”] |
2 | AQUARIA – tanks: A QUA R.A. [answer | as | artillery] “surrounds” I [one] |
3 | LAST STRAW – back-breaking stress (for a camel?): LASTS [carries on] over T RAW [time | untreated] |
5 | THE RAIN IN SPAIN – cryptic def based around the phrase “raining cats and dogs” |
6 | OPTED – did plump: O ED [round | boy] “set about” P.T. [training] |
7 | IRONMAN – endurance event: IRON MAN [press | staff] |
8 | ZONING – dividing into regions: ZING [energy] “saving” ON [paid for by (as in “dinner’s on me”)] |
9 | FALL ON DEAF EARS – be ignored: (OFFER N{ew} DEAL ALAS*) [“rashly”] |
16 | VACUUMING – cleaning: VAC [break] + U U [“more than once”, posh] + MING [sort of vase] |
17 | UNCANDID – not open: UNDID [opened] “sandwiches” CAN [container] |
19 | HANDS-ON – a variety of training: HAND SON [offer | youth] |
21 | BUSHIDO – code: BUS{t} [“nearly” broken] + HID O [revealed the lot, as in “hid nothing”] |
22 | UPGROW – get higher: U PG [certificates for films] + ROW [series] |
24 | OUSEL – diver: {h}OUSE [“topless”, put up] + L [L{ooks} “at first”] |
I claim foul on WINE LIST: Eli was not a prophet but a high priest, notorious for living in a time when prophecy was unknown, but bringing up the boy, and later prophet, Samuel in the temple. Maybe no-one else will notice (he’s in the Bible, after all) but I discounted the wordplay as a result and couldn’t figure anything else out. I knew GIRASOL as yesterday’s HELIOTROPE, which didn’t help.
That aside, a challenging crossword, visiting too many garden paths to be counted, great if you like such things, which I do once completed. CUBAN for me the best of a ferocious set, with the brilliant “national opera company” as misleading as it gets.
Edited at 2015-09-11 09:00 am (UTC)
Edited at 2015-09-11 09:08 am (UTC)
Or maybe it’s just a tiny, tiny slip in a highly creditable set of clues. Whichever (guess which side I’m staying on!), I’m off to get grumpy about something in the TLS.
On edit, responding to the unedited version of your second comment. This could get complicated.
Edited at 2015-09-11 09:18 am (UTC)
Strangely, I didn’t find this so hard, things like acidified went in with no crossers present.
Rob
D’oh. Still, not a mistake on my part. The young Luciano played in goal for Forno di Canale under-11s on at least two occasions*.
Perhaps I should have stayed safe with Albert Camus.
*This assertion is almost entirely without foundation, though it could be true.
Wasted a few minutes at the ned trying to squeeze rose or rosy into 12a before realizing that colourful might be part of the definition and that I knew the word, anyway.
Thanks setter, and verlaine.
Unknowns were IRONMAN (though the elementary wordplay got me over that hurdle), BUSHIDO (again helpful wordplay), GIRASOL, PAN LOAF (we had tin loaves where I come from) and rather strangely UPGROW. Best clue was for CHOW MEIN at 18ac.
Then have a go at fixing your botched clue, Mr Anonymous.
Hard to beef today.
Edited at 2015-09-11 11:35 am (UTC)
Upgrow not good- rest hard and clever. Chow Mein esp
This was my first week all complete with no errors for a while which probably presages complacency and silly mistakes next week.
My first stab at 12 was GA(ROSY)L but it didn’t look like a word and on closer inspection didn’t account for the A in the clue.
I though “paid for by” for “on” was very clever but I’ll join Verlaine in giving COD to chow mein, a great clue all round.
Thanks setter and V.
More first-class stuff today, couched in very economically worded clues: I raise my hat to the setter. And I join others in praise of “Hamburger’s my”.
With keriothe posting a very respectable time and sotira having another good day, I feel my chances of reaching the Championship Final this year are dwindling rapidly.
But why is ousel a diver? I assume we are talking about the bird? It’s (a) a blackbird, in dialect. It has a cousin called the (b) ring ousel. There is a totally unrelated bird (c) called a dipper, which used, pre-war, in distant parts of the country, to be called a water-ousel because it looks a bit like (b). This name has not been in use for generations. Anyway, because it spends some of its time feeding under the surface of streams doesn’t make it a diver (see gaviidae if you want to be literal, though I know crosswords delight in not doing so). But ousel to mean dipper is completely misleading, and years out of date. Time this one was binned. Harrumph
I defy the massed ranks of UK lexicographers to go forth into the highways and byways and find anyone now using this word in that sense. Archaic if not obsolete. They’ll be allowing ‘mavis’ or ‘laverock’ next. Yet bet you a whole fiver that no setter would dare put in ‘bonxie’, which falls readily from the lips of birders. (Shall probably find it in the Club Special now) 😉
Isn’t Bonxie actually the pseudonym of a setter for the Guardian? Which probably means it might get through. I’ve definitely seen mavis before, too, though admittedly I can’t recall laverock…
I rather chucked the bird in at the time of solving, perhaps because this was, strangely, the second OUSEL of the week (the first defined simply as “bird” in 26,197).
Edited at 2015-09-12 04:14 pm (UTC)