Solving time: 43:35
I can’t say I particularly enjoyed this one. A lot of the clues seemed very straightforward, but I was slowed down by a handful at the end, and a couple that didn’t seem to quite work for me – 3d & 24d. Not many leapt out at me as being particularly clever. Although 2d had a good lift & separate required on ‘swan song’, and 22a raised a smile (or at least a groan).
cd = cryptic def., dd = double def., rev = reversal, homophones are written in quotes, anagrams as (–)*, and removals like this
| Across | |
|---|---|
| 1 | SHORT + HAND |
| 6 | RE(C)AP |
| 9 | B(R)EAKER |
| 10 | STEAMER = S |
| 11 | ERA = alternate letters of both |
| 12 | THE GOLD RUSH – dd – An easy one for me having recently watched this as one of several Chaplin films as part of my ongoing imdb Top 250 challenge. |
| 14 | SCRUM + P |
| 15 | CE + RULE + AN – a deep blue colour, similar to that of a clear sky. Not a word I knew, but could (eventually) deduce from the wordplay. |
| 17 | NOTIONAL = NO + (INTO A)* + |
| 19 | F(L)OR + IN |
| 22 | OUT OF BOUNDS – dd – groan! |
| 23 | MAC |
| 25 | NAMIBIA = N + AMPHIBIA without the P |
| 27 | G(RAN)ITE |
| 28 | R + ACER |
| 29 | ANTIPASTO = (STATION PA)* |
| Down | |
| 1 | S |
| 2 | O + PEN + AIR – very neat use of ‘swan song’ |
| 3 | TAKE TIME OFF – I assume the idea here is to remove the T (time) from ‘it’ to leave I (one), but I can’t quite get it to work in my head. ‘How it leaves one’ would work, and ‘how t leaves it’ would work cryptically, but I’m not convinced about the wording as it stands. |
| 4 | A + G + REED – I wasn’t sure that ‘reed’ on its own could be used to describe a reed instrument, such as an oboe, but it was in my dictionary so it’s fine. |
| 5 | DISC + OVER |
| 6 | RYE = “WRY” |
| 7 | COM(PUT)E |
| 8 | PART + H + E + NON |
| 13 | DOUBLES HARP |
| 14 | SUNDOWNER = (ROUND + N/S/E/W)* – although I entered this from the definition alone, and only parsed it post-solve. |
| 16 | PAN(OR)AMA – Darien is the old name for the isthmus of Panama, so I’m not sure that perhaps is the ideal qualifier to use here, but maybe I’m just being picky. I didn’t know this until I looked it up post solve, but the answer was clear from the rest of the clue. |
| 18 | TOTEMIC = (I + MET) in COT all rev – I nearly went for TITANIC, but couldn’t make it fit the wordplay. |
| 20 | RE + MAINS |
| 21 | KNIGHT = K + (THING) – &lit, although did knights actually do much jumping? I suppose you could argue that the chesspiece jumps, so that’s presumably what the setter had in mind. |
| 24 | CRE |
| 26 | BAR |
16dn: Darien was a bit obscure I felt.
12ac: Didn’t parse this as a dd: rather as def + charade: THE GOLD (Olympic winner), RUSH (race).
21dn: Jumping thing? Well … the German is Der Springer and it’s the only piece that can jump over others during its legal move.
Edited at 2012-08-31 01:17 am (UTC)
I didn’t know CERULEAN,RACER as a snake or “Darien” but I wrote the answers in with confidence.
Re 3dn I read it as: To leave “IT” as “I”, TAKE TIME OFF. “One” in the clue not being a reference to the “I” in “IT”.
Edited at 2012-08-31 01:14 am (UTC)
Edited at 2012-08-31 01:19 am (UTC)
Edited at 2012-08-31 01:33 am (UTC)
I really enjoyed this one – enough easy clues to get you started and it was a steady solve to attack each corner in turn thereafter. 21D was a great clue.
My LOI, CERULEAN, I seem to recall from a few weeks back but I can’t find the ref.
I thought this a perfectly enjoyable puzzle. 21dn in particular is excellent.
Darien is familiar to me from Keats:
Or like stout Cortez when with eagle eyes
He star’d at the Pacific — and all his men
Look’d at each other with a wild surmise —
Silent, upon a peak in Darien.
Oh all right, actually it’s familiar to me from Bertie Wooster quoting (or misquoting) this bit of Keats.
Perhaps the limitation on such clues is that other answers can be quite believable: I had TAKE TIME OUT until the deceased marsupial, which was itself a chucklesome Uxbridge sort of clue, ruled it out.
CREDO is at the centre of the Latin Mass, perhaps these days better know from its choral settings.
Thanks to Keriothe for the Keats quote – it saved me time looking it up, but perfectly encapsulates that first sight experience. These days we have to visit far moons and planets for the same hit – the latest from Mars comes close even if it’s not the first such view. Of course, it can have unpredictable effects: Compare stout Cortez and his men with the Masters of Krikkit: “it’ll have to go”.
Edited at 2012-08-31 09:24 am (UTC)
As a golfer, Out Of Bounds raised a smile. I’ll be hoping to avoid that when I play next week.
I agree the puzzle was not great, a rather humdrum affair, although the clue for ‘knight’ was a standout.
Edited at 2012-08-31 11:58 am (UTC)
I’m wrestling over the etiquette of claiming a time in such circumstances. On the one hand, I know I would never have written OUT OF BAUNDS by hand. On the other, as Pete Biddlecombe always reminds Championship entrants, a little time checking your answers is time well spent (I’m too sloppy to bother).
KNIGHT is neat.
Logic: you correctly assert you can’t spell BOUNDS as BAUNDS by mistake.
You can’t hit an A in error for an O, separated as they are by several parsecs on the keyboard.
Therefore, you must have mispelled PANARAMA, either dyslexically putting one on PANAMA’s As in the wrong place, or else just as a blonde moment (note: both these errror mechanisms are common in my solving, though I’m no longer blonde).
So, a true error, can’t claim the time.
Isla
Not sure that scrumping is stealing from a farmer. I used to go scrumping as a boy and I grew up in the centre of London! I think of it as taking particularly windfalls from fruit trees – which could be in a back garden or an orchard.
However I still can get it totally wrong – I read 27a as GRAN being an elderly relative looked after (managed) in accommodation (home) as a break (holiday) for family with and being a suffix meaning “made of”.
And the kangaroo took ages.