Goodness me, this one gave me some problems and took me over an hour for the third consecutive day this week. Right at the outset I fell literally into a bear-trap (probably of my own making rather than one intended by the setter) and never really recovered because it put me on the wrong course for several other clues. Even when I sorted out the mess my confidence was shot to pieces. But for all that, once again this week we have a very fine puzzle. For anyone noticing that I am posting somewhat later than in recent weeks, no, I have not been struggling on this since midnight; I went to bed at a sensible hour and then got up very early.
| Across | |
|---|---|
| 1 | PARADIDDLE – A RAP (a popular music – rev) + DIDDLE (do). It’s a sequence of strokes in drumming. |
| 7 | BEAR – Double definition. ‘Hack’ = ‘bear’ as in to tolerate, manage or cope with something. Putting ‘jade’ (an alternative double definition) here as my first answer in the grid gave me endless problems q.v. 7dn. A veritable bear-trap! |
| 9 | BROKEN IN – RO |
| 10 | COWARD – RAW (not cooked – rev) inside COD. |
| 11 | SHOWER – Double definition. The one meaning ‘worthless group’ reminds me with joy of the wonderful Terry-Thomas as the Major in ‘Private’s Progress’ (1956): “You’re an absolute SHAAAR!”. |
| 13 | IDEALIST – Anagram of ‘sailed’ inside ‘it’. |
| 14 | FRONT OF HOUSE – In a theatre this is everything on the audience side of the curtain as opposed to ‘backstage’. |
| 17 | CRACKBRAINED – CRACK (go) + BRAIN (head) + ED (man on newspaper). ‘Out to lunch’ is slang for ‘unbalanced’ or ‘stupid’. |
| 20 | INVEIGLE – Anagram of ‘living’ and E |
| 21 | ARGOSY – |
| 22 | MANTUA – MA (graduate – Master of Arts) + NT (books – New Testament) + U + A. It’s a 17th century gown named from the city in Lombardy. |
| 23 | NOTIONAL – ‘National’ (citizen) with one of its As (American capital) replaced by 0 (love – tennis). |
| 25 | Double definition deliberately omitted. |
| 26 | ENTICEMENT – |
| Down | |
| 2 | AYRSHIRE – IRe (endless anger) inside anagram of ‘her say’. Last blog I had Angus cattle as the first Down answer; today it’s a different breed. |
| 3 | AUK – A+UK. Stumped me for ages! Finland, Norway, Sweden? What other countries are there in NW Europe? |
| 4 | INNER – |
| 5 | DONNISH – NNI (pub – rev) inside DOSH (money). Wasted ages trying to think if ‘mash’ might be slang for money. |
| 6 | EXCHEQUER – Sounds like ‘ex-checker’. |
| 7 | BEWILDERING – WILDER (rather extravagant) inside BEING (creature). So having convinced myself that 7ac was ‘jade’ I had J?W?????ING here and came up with ‘jawdropping’ for ‘stunning’ which seemed perfectly reasonable, give or take a hyphen, until I tried to untangle the wordplay. Many a moment was lost here. |
| 8 | I’m deliberately omitting this Down clue. |
| 12 | WINDCHEATER – WIND (turn) + C (cold) + HEATER (radiator?). |
| 15 | ORANGEADE – Anagram of ‘an edge or a’. |
| 16 | MESSIAEN – MESS (jam) + I |
| 18 | KEEPNET – TEN PEEK rev. |
| 19 | INMATE – IN (ruling, ‘in power’) + MATE (China plate – CRS). |
| 21 | ARTIC – ARTIC |
| 24 | OHM – H (Henry – unit of inductance) inside OM (high honour – Order of Merit). |
Also thought this a pretty good puzzle though scratched my head a bit over FRONT OF HOUSE until it dawned that “H” was the cryptic bit and “not just” was a kind of filler to get the surface working. Not a complaint: it’s a good clue.
LOI was BEAR (7ac) — having the checkers helped — but the “hack” = “cope” etc., took a while to see.
COD to ENTICEMENT for the hint of swinging in the clue.
Not sure I’ve ever come across CRACKBRAINED, while KEEPNET is up there with ‘longshore’ for the title of most unimaginative marine compound word. Joint CODS to ENTICEMENT and the fizzy anagram.
It would appear to be time to resurrect the thought that by and large it is not good technique to fill in 4 letter word answers without first obtaining some checking letters.
In this case 8D is an easy clue and gives an “A”. That rules out “jade” but not “nias”. 10A is easy and gives a “W” in 7D. That in turn prompts thoughts of “wild” and hence “BEWILDERING”. Now we have B?A? at 7A and only one answer is possible.
My point is just that if I did a straw poll among my acquaintance I’m pretty confident that fewer than 10% would have heard of Gigli, but I doubt that I’d find a single person who doesn’t know what a muggle is. Generally there’s a natural ageist (or rather youngist) slant in the Times crossword. I don’t mind this at all (in fact I welcome it because it means I learn stuff) but it is nice when occasionally the balance is redressed a bit.
Edited at 2012-03-09 11:44 am (UTC)
My slant here is that the question of relevance is perhaps not the key point, but there should be consideration as to whether there is too much of a taste/choice/split element. The general in general knowledge to me implies that it covers a wide cross section of the public, not necessarily a great number, nor a high quality thereof. So if only the learned knew of a fact or person, but it was the learned of many places and who were not easily linked with one connection alone, then this defines GK.
With regard to Harry Potter, it is very much a taste or choice to read this, and so may be unfair to those who havent. One reason I think the “dead” rule is a good one is that over a certain time things become historical fact and those that survive can be deemed to be GK. Time will tell whether Harry Potter does that. Clearly the Beatles (although not dead per se) have done something like that, whereas perhaps Oasis have not.
One other parallel I suggested before was that along these lines, perhaps anything overly christian may be deemed unfair since it is not reasonable to suggest that a muslim, atheist or anyone else of a non christian leaning should be familiar with the minutiae of the religion. That said, I wholly appreciate that much of the tradition has been around long enough to creep into the common psyche, but the principle I believe is still valid.
…enough now, places to go, people to see!
And of course a similar principle applies at the other end: as memory fades general knowledge becomes specialist. There is such a thing as too old, as well as too new.
More generally I welcome words I don’t know for whatever reason. Getting them from wordplay is all part of the fun.
Oh well. Add me to those who, tuning in to the obscurity of some of the cluing, wondered where the University of LE was, tried several CRACK-somethings and (I’m sure this is a group that will grow) didn’t think FRONT OF HOUSE really worked. Front of house, I suppose is the place that decides where the audience are going to sit, but…
I also decided INMATE was a sort of semi &lit – a ruling for a prisoner being in, mate!, probably in an Aussie court.
Miffed enough not to award a CoD, though BROKEN IN was nice for less than usual country.
Tricky but high-quality puzzle this. Fortunately I vaguely remembered PARADIDDLE from a brief spell trying to learn the drums as a youngster. I stopped after a few months, much to the relief of my parents.
I’ll try harder next week. I promise.
🙁
Too difficult for me today. Surrendered after getting 21/28 and resorted to Onelook to solve the rest. Most difficulties were in the NW corner where I didn’t know Paradiddle. Can’t imagine that Rap is a popular music form among TFTTers. Really should have got Inner and Broken In but couldn’t come up with any plausible words to fit ?R?K?? ?N and ??N?R.
Shower for “worthless group,” Keepnet and Mantua all new to me.
Jackkt – thanks for your blog and for explaining the “enti” part of Enticement. I didn’t understand where the E and I came from and was reading “mid-twenties” as NT.
Edited at 2012-03-09 04:36 pm (UTC)
While I have the floor, but not especially for you, Kevin, a little mnemonic may help people get a handle on Paul’s five shorter letters to the nascent churches: A, E, I, O, U (where U has to do service for Thussalonians):
Galatians, Ephesians, Phillipians, Colossians and Thessalonians.
Edited at 2012-03-10 04:40 am (UTC)
But a good crossword.
Surely anyone who hasn’t come across the word “muggle” must have been living on the Planet Zog for the last 15 years. Even if you haven’t read any of the books (and I read the first one fairly early on just to see what all the fuss was about), it would surely have been hard to miss the Nancy Stouffer court case.
As I understand it, the names of living people are excluded from the Times crossword in case they might be offended in some way. I believe there was a case many years ago when someone took umbrage because of the way their name was clued, but I can’t quote chapter and verse.
Edited at 2012-03-09 11:25 pm (UTC)