Solving time: 49:45 – Started quickly, with the northwest corner going in in about 3 or 4 minutes, but ran aground about twenty minutes later with about 10 left. These ten took as long to get as the rest of the puzzle had.
Quite a few well put together clues here. I particularly liked the disguised simplicity of 16, and the neatness of 20.
A few new words for me, today. I didn’t know BIRD OF PASSAGE, EREWHON, CHINE or WAT, but they were all gettable from the rest of the clue.
cd = cryptic def., dd = double def., rev = reversal, homophones are written in quotes, anagrams as (–)*, and removals like this
Across | |
---|---|
1 | BUTCHER – dd |
5 | C(O + MP)ARE |
9 | CO + |
10 | MUD = DUM |
11 | PAR + ROT |
12 | SHEEP RUN = (PEER)* in SHUN |
14 | LEARNING CURVE = (RUN + CLEVER GAIN)* – &lit |
17 | BIRD + OF + PASSAGE – A migratory bird, so ‘one fast disappearing’ is the definition. |
21 | UNTOWARD = ‘in East London’ is an instruction to drop initial Hs, so this is |
23 | P(RE)C + IS |
25 | A + DO |
26 | TIGHT-LIPPED = TIGHT + LIED about P |
27 | EREWHON = NOH + WE + RE all rev – I got this from the wordplay, as I’m not familiar with the novels of Samuel Butler. |
28 | ANTWERP = (WENT)* in ARP |
Down | |
1 | B |
2 | TEND + |
3 | HOT POTATO = (A TOOTH)* about POT |
4 | ROUT |
5 | CAT(CHINES)S – A chine is a ravine carved into rock by running water. Not a word I knew, so this was one of the words that held me up. |
6 | MER(G)E |
7 | A + D(M)IRER |
8 | END ANGER |
13 | SNAP + DRAG ON |
15 | C + H + AIRLIFT |
16 | OBDURATE = (ABOUT RED)* – the combination of using ‘about’ as part of the anagrist, and the ‘lift & separate’ required for ‘Red Rum’ made this deceptively simple clue quite tricky to parse. |
18 | R(AT + H |
19 | ES(CAPE)E – ‘direction’ is ESE for East-South-East, one of 8 possible 3-letter compass points. |
20 | USED UP = (SUE |
22 | WAT + CH – I didn’t know Wat meant ‘temple’, and I’m still not convinced it really does, but I’ve come across the Angkor Wat in Cambodia in the past, so I got it from that. According to Wikipedia, Wat is the Khmer form of the Pali word ‘vatthu’, meaning ‘temple grounds’. |
24 | ETNA – hidden in |
I had heard of ‘chines’, and thought of them first thing, so saved some trouble there.
I was somewhat delayed at one point because I carelessly wrote ‘used ut’ instead of ‘used up’, and couldn’t get ‘Antwerp’.
At 17ac, I think we’re dealing with the metaphorical bird of passage: a person who visits briefly and shoots through.
22dn, For WAT, NOAD has: “(in Thailand, Cambodia, and Laos) a Buddhist monastery or temple”. “Thai, from Sanskrit, vāṭa ‘enclosure’”. So I guess it’s legit. But enough eastern mysticism this week already!
I justified 8dn by thinking ‘Without the following i.e. an END (next) to ANGER, a ceasefire could be put at risk’. It sort of made sense then, at least to me. Maybe there’s a neater explanation but I suspect the question mark was added in recognition that it’s all a bit dodgy. On edit: I’ve just seen your version, mct, and I like it. But at least my version got me to the answer!
I wasn’t aware that Antwerp was particularly noted as a war-damaged city but this is down to my ignorance because I now gather that it suffered extreme bombardment by V-weapons towards the end of the war in an attempt to close the port, but most of them missed their target and fell on the city itself.
I didn’t know this meaning of CHINES and according to COED its use is specific to the IOW and Dorset areas so Jimbo should be strolling in the park this morning.
Edited at 2012-02-17 09:16 am (UTC)
COD.. OBDURATE
Jack, Samuel Butler intended his book title to represent ‘nowhere’ backwards, but he switched the middle consonants, presumably because he didn’t want people thinking he had written his Utopian satire about Wales!
Edited at 2012-02-17 03:30 am (UTC)
Using Dodo to clue bird, given its metaphorical associations, was nicely misleading – I favour the fleeting visitor idea as the better interpretation of the definition.
Mctext’s take on ENDANGER elevates it from a somewhat ho-hum clue to a decent one – I didn’t see “cease(f)ire” while solving.
CoD TENDRIL, but I also liked ‘UNT’OWARD for the giggle and OBDURATE for the anagram hidden in plain sight.
I didn’t understand 8dn. The best I could do was taking “without the following” to be an instruction to separate END from ANGER. On this interpretation it’s a weak clue. On mctext’s surely correct interpretation it’s a very good one.
Obviously knew “chines”, Bournemouth is full of them. Also “wat” from Mephisto puzzles. Not convinced that 14 quite works and a bit of a train crash as far as surface wording is concerned. Had seen the Butler stuff before. Liked 16, OBDURATE
I like McText’s explanation of 8 which I didn’t spot whilst solving, using the starting E and definition to get the answer
Fairly quick time for this one, ending with the (unlikely) EREWHON, put in from wordplay (lookedmore likely than etewhon or emewhon, but only just). Spent some time with ‘rite’ OF PASSAGE in, and trying to figure out an anagram of ‘cease(f)ire’, but all went in ok in the end.
Hadn’t heard of CHINES, and was a bit dubious about SHUN=duck, but it had to be.
Had written OBDURATE in the margin long before I realised the neat anagram. For that it gets my COD.
Have a good w/e, everyone, and see y’all next week!
By the way, aren’t coincidences in crosswords unsettling? My scientific head explains them away rationally, but they always leave me slightly spooked. This morning, just before I read the clue for ANTWERP, an air-raid siren went off across the valley. Not heard one for years and don’t know why it sounded; keep expecting to hear the low, pulsating beats of a Heinkel He111 overhead.
Took me about 25 minutes with a short break looking for enemy aircraft.
Well done for keeping calm and carrying on.
Thank you, setter.