Solving time: 1:07:26.
And even then, a couple of parsings I’m not sure of: 6dn and 24dn. A miserable morning all round. But it’s a darned clever piece of work for all that.
| Across |
| 1 |
S,NAPPY. |
| 4 |
AGITPROP. A GI (An American serving), T (time), PRO (for), P{eddle}. |
| 10 |
DI(SA)P,PEAR. AS (like) reversed in DIP (sauce) and PEAR (fruit). |
| 11 |
AMIGO. Second letters (reversed) in ‘lOnG fIlM hAs’. |
| 12 |
KEY GRIP. KEY (one turned to open) + GRIP (bag). |
| 13 |
YAKKING. The def is ‘going on’. Anagram: kinky, a, g{uide}. |
| 14 |
CORAL. COR (gracious!), reversal of LA{dy}. |
| 15 |
TEA TRAYS. TEAT + RAYS. |
| 18 |
WHIP HAND. WHIP (pinch), HAND (collection from dealer). |
| 20 |
{or}BITER. |
| 23 |
ROB,OTIC. |
| 25 |
RAILMAN. Anagram: in alarm. |
| 26 |
FIT IN. F{emale}, I, TIN (can). |
| 27 |
EINDHOVEN. Anagram: H{ospital} in E Devon. |
| 28 |
BE(E,FC)AKE. The container is ‘beake{r}’. |
| 29 |
AD,HERE. AD (promotion), HERE (present). |
| Down |
| 1 |
SIDE,KICK. |
| 2 |
AS,SAY,ER. As are the top grades. Middle of tERm. |
| 3 |
PAPER CLIP. P{hoto}, APER (copier), CLIP (extract). A trombone if you’re French. |
| 5 |
GERRYMANDERING. Anagram: RRR, engaged in my. |
| 6 |
TRACK? Last letter of ‘stretcheR’? Don’t understand the container. See rosselliot‘s comment. It’s the last letter of ‘casT’ + RACK (stretcher). My thanks to him. |
| 7 |
RA(IS)INY. Def = ‘filled with dried fruit’. |
| 8 |
P,L,OUGH{t}. |
| 9 |
PERPETUAL CHECK. Anagram: peer up, chalk etc. |
| 16 |
RU(BB,I)SHED. The def is ‘did discount’. |
| 17 |
OR,D(N)ANCE. O{live}R; DANCE (by example, twist). |
| 19 |
H(A,BIT)UÉ. |
| 21 |
TV MOVIE. Cryptic def. |
| 22 |
PRE,FAB. |
| 24 |
TUNIC. TUC (an organisation that includes women?) See rosselliot‘s comment. It’s TU (for the union) + NIC{k} (run in … short). Thanks again Ross. |
There were some very clever clues. Anyone who thinks ‘books’ must = ‘NT’ or ‘OT’ will never get ‘rubbished’. And ‘Eindhoven’ – how often does that come up in conversation, and who knows how to spell it?
However, the ‘rob otic’ clue was at least amusing.
24 dn = TU NIC(k).
Made a miserable mess of this with my mandatory thumbling of a couple of clues. Inevitably mangle the entry of a down clue, taking out a perfectly good across one at the same time.
My compliments to the setter.
Starting in the NE progress throughout was on the slow side but just for once things flowed steadily and I was able to complete each quarter before moving onto the next.
An excellent puzzle that contained enough tricky stuff so that I felt really satisfied when I finished it without aids and fully understood nearly all the clues as I wrote the answers in.
I knew EINDHOVEN because I went through it once on a train and remember it as the home of Philips.
Last in was BEEFCAKE which I left until I had all the checkers because I thought it would involve a foreign soccer team that I never heard of.
My last in was TRACK, and I failed to parse it, so thanks to rosselliot for that. And thanks to the setter for a real treat.
I had a complete 15 minute hiatus about halfway through all because I had RAISINS. Once spotted (it HAS to be TEA TRAYS, doesn’t it?) there was a sudden rush until the 17 20 21 trio in the bottom right.
Virtually every clue (discounting TV MOVIE which was kind of annoying) would have a chance of CoD in any normal crossword, but I’ll give it to AGITPROP for a mini novel of a surface and as an early indicator of the cluing standards and challenges. Bravo setter, and any finalist who got this in any kind of time!
Great puzzle. 45 minutes of real enjoyment. Once again lost in admiration for those who solve these in far less time. Well done setter – absolutely first class. And well done McText – great effort.
Luckily, TEA TRAYS was one of my first in which took the raisins off the table. EINDHOVEN was familiar enough from the PSV football club.
Last in: PLOUGH
Lots of clever wordplay. I particularly like ORDNANCE, BITER & ROBOTIC.
In the case of TV it’s an abbreviation for a single word and I wouldn’t expect it to be shown as 1,1 any more than I would for ST if the answer were to be ST GEORGE, for example.
.
great puzzle and super blog thank you!
I got as far as rob=deprive of but can’t see where otic comes from. Can somebody put me out of my misery and I’ll just go back to lurking again. Thanks AS
As I understand it, the rationale for enumerating TV MOVIE as (2,5) is that’s exactly how you write it. For it to be (1,1,5), it would have to be written T V MOVIE. Similarly HMS VICTORY would be enumerated as (3,7).