Solving time : 19 minutes – and I was held up by the long ones in this case, last in was the anagram at 13 down that I was sure was going to be AEDROSAMTLN or something like that. With a lot of the long ones requiring wordplay to work everything out, I was in for a struggle here. But everything checks out in the end (I hope).
I think this was a really good, but challenging puzzle. I have a stand-up show tonight so I won’t be checking in for a while, but any fluffs or questions will be answered in due time.
Away we go…
Across | |
---|---|
1 | SUSTAINED: (AS,N,DUTIES)* – one of several tricky anagrams today |
6 | H, |
9 | PARAPET: double def, one cryptic for the PARA PET |
10 | MUTABLE: TAB(flap) in MULE(cross, dbe fans feel free to weigh in here) |
11 | our omission from the acrosses |
12 | ASCERTAINED: (CENTRE,SAID,A)* – another tricky anagram |
14 | N,UTTER |
15 | VENDETTA: tricky wordplay – TA(army) but before that, have END(demise) in VET(surgeon) |
17 | EAU-DE-NIL: Nile green and one I had to get from wordplay – AUDEN is the poet in LIE(be relaxed) reversed |
19 | T,RIFLE: the T comes from the end of shooT |
22 | ZARASTHUSTRA: take a deep breath – Z(unknown),A,RA(artist), THUS(so), then ART reversed. I had the ART reversed part before the rest of it. Spiritual leader of the Zoroastrians, and Strauss took his name to write Ric Flair’s entrance music |
23 |
|
25 | COGNATE: this took a while to get – TANGO reversed in CE |
27 | FITTING: double definition |
28 | EA,TUP: REPLACED here is leading to PUT BACK which is TUP. Not sure I’ve seen this kind of double cryptic used in the Times (there is a question mark after it – I got it from the definition) |
29 | TRAINBAND: A band of citizens from the 16th-18th century who bore arms apparently – regular definition and cryptic one of a band that would play on a train |
Down | |
1 | SUPER: P in SUER(one tacking court action) |
2 | SURFEIT: F in(staying – strange containment indicator) SURE,IT |
3 | APPEASEMENT: APPEARS without the R then MEN in that old staple of a film for us, E.T. |
4 | NOTICE: double definition – if you give NOTICE you say how long you’re going to work until you’re out of there. And what a great feeling it is. The other definition, NOTICE for BILL works in showbiz |
5 | DUMFRIES: (FIRM)* in DUES |
6 |
|
7 | CAB,I,NET |
8 | S,HELD,RAKE: needed the wordplay to get this |
13 | ALDERMASTON: (MODERN,ATLAS)* – my last in and I had to pore over the letters to make them fit into a plausible-looking place name |
14 | NIETZSCHE: (ZEST)* in NICHE. I got this before ZARATHUSTRA and was wondering if I had spelled it correctly zeeing the Z as a checking letter |
16 | VIRULENT: liked this clue a lot – I RULE(order) NT(books) after V |
18 | UPRIGHT: double definition – an UPRIGHT is a part of a goal in American football |
20 | FLORIDA: LO in FRIDA |
21 | STAFFA: hidden – got this from wordplay, caves in the Hebrides |
24 | R,AGED |
26 | let’s leave this one out of the downs |
When I got ‘Nietzsche’ and ‘Zarathustra’ early on, I was hoping for a themed puzzle, but not so. It’s strange the setter would put answers so closely related right next to each other.
I was amused by the ‘trainband’ clue – perhaps they might rouse some of our commuter solvers to greater efforts, or at least play a fanfare when they complete the puzzle.
Not to mention NUTTER and HOCUS.
B. Russell’s chapter on Nietzsche (Hist. of W. Phil) is a hoot if anyone’s interested. The pop version is here:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HZXQ3jQltbA
Another great puzzle following yesterday’s: 47 minutes going anticlockwise from the top left and finding most trouble in the last quadrant.
Didn’t see any DBE in 10ac: a mule, the animal (answer) is one instance of a cross (clue), not vice versa. So OK in my book — and I’m getting a bit more relaxed about DBEs in general. There’s also a horticulutal sense in which ‘mule’ is identical with ‘hybrid’.
My main complaint would be the vagueness of ‘community’ = DUMFRIES; but the cryptic gets you there if you’re not looking for ‘firm’ = CO.
Super puzzle, where I think only one (FLORIDA) went in on the definition alone. SUPER, DUMFRIES, ALDERMASTON and VENDETTA all worthy of COD nominations, with the award going to the Scottish town on account of the fond memories I have of the 2009 ‘Tom Watson’ Open at Turnberry, which involved my daughter and me in an hour and a half commute twice a day from the Travelodge in said town.
‘Imph’m! Quite the dump, to tell the truth,’ as Dorothy Sayers might have written in her book set in the locality.
Don’t think I’d have ever have got some of these ones… so very different from yesterday’s where, though it took ages, I always knew I was going to get somewhere.
ALDERMASTON was my last in.
Like vinyl1 (nice to see you get a mention in today’s clues, btw) I also failed to recognise TRAINBAND immediately on first thinking of it. We met it previously as recently as 30th August. And like mct, I thought the DUMFRIES clue was a bit dubious and suggests that any place in the world might now be defined by ‘community’ without further qualification.
Nobody has mentioned Fingal’s cave on STAFFA celebrated by Mendelssohn in his ‘Hebrides’overture. But for that I doubt the place would be famous enough to be included:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fingal%27s_Cave
For us Times/Guardian solvers I think from memory that mule as cross has come up 3 times on the bounce in various forms.
As tough as yesterday but without the joy.
Jung would have liked the synchronicity: serendipitous listening to Radio 4 yesterday made TRAINBAND a stand-out word today – spooky.
Otherwise lots of clever anti-cliché clues: the poet was not Poe, the garden tool was not a hoe, and the firm was not co. I also quite liked the military style of the vet, TA animals, for the use of.
CoD to the pairing of Python’s favourite philosopher (it’s got an S in it) and ZARATHUSTRA just for recklessly word-playing both.
http://times-xwd-times.livejournal.com/2009/09/18/
Where’s Sabine these days?
I’m not sure I’ve ever come across HOCUS without an attendant pocus, and EAU DE NIL was new to me. Like ulaca I put in EAU DE VIE but fortunately I paused for long enough to see that it didn’t work so I was able to correct it.
It’s helpful when a word like TRAINBAND comes up twice in such quick succession: now I have a fighting chance (boom boom) of remembering it.
Like some others, I didn’t care for ‘Community’ as a definition in 5, but otherwise it was a good clue with a convincing surface. I thought the clues fairly good in general, particularly those for VENDETTA, SUPER, ALDERMASTON.
After about 40 mins I bunged in ALRIGHT and ERA LE VIE out of pure frustration even though vie is clearly feminine! Double DNF here
I thought NOTICE was a triple def since “time one’s given” could be one and “work out” could be another as in ‘work out the pattern in these figures’
Spent a long time looking for a philiosopher beginning with O since I had invented the word OUTREE for issue. Only having got 14d right did the easy correct answer arrive!
I make it that the five letters – t,z,s,c,h – can be arranged 120 different ways. I think I tried them all. Is there any sort of aide-mémoire for spelling Nietzsche correctly? It gets me every time.
My next solving of the Times of London will be in London. Flying tonight, as Kenneth Williams nearly said. Anyone wishing to leave the country should hurry!
I should have mentioned that I had no idea how the literal for DUMFRIES worked, just that it fitted the wordplay exceptionally well so I figured it was a society somewhere. I’ll also withdraw the dbe criticism (at least in this comment).
However I fail to understand why 13dn Has “Start of the marches…” since surely that is where they finished?