Solving time: 95 minutes
If you are startled by the time, I completed all but two clues in 25 minutes. I did find the last two rather tough, and the answers turned out to
Music: Schubert, Lieder, Judith Nelson/Jorg Demus
Across | |
---|---|
1 | TACTIC, T + ACT I + C[lubs]. It’s nice to start with an easy one. |
5 | COCKATOO, COCK AT + OO, which are ducks in England, but not over here. |
9 | MONETARIST, MONET + AR(IS)T. If you thought ‘artist’ = ‘RA’, you will be stuck for a while. |
10 | Omitted, you’ll end up with the answer. |
11 | ADORABLE, A[rea] + DO(R)ABLE. I thought the answer was going to be some sort of witch’s magic circle, but not so. |
12 | PEAHEN, PE(A HE)N, where a ‘pen’ is a female swan, and ‘a male’ is not ‘am’. |
13 | LAOS, a rather weak double definition I didn’t much care for. |
15 | ELLIPSIS, hidden backwards in [drink]S I SPILLE[d]. If you wondered why there is no ‘….’ at the beginning of the next clue, that’s the literal you’re looking at. |
18 | TSAREVNA, anagram of A SERVANT, and a quite obscure compared to the well-known ‘tsarina’ and ‘tsaravich’ |
19 | ORYX, O(RY)X. Not hard, and I still nearly put ‘onyx’. |
21 | WRITER, W + RITE + R. Quite a tricky clue, where I was expecting obscure vocabulary rather than indirection in the literal, which refers to Jack. |
23 | TRADE OFF, anagram D + EFFORT, a starter clue for most solvers. |
25 | PLAN, PLAN[t] or PLAN[e] or PLAN[k]…..all right, already! |
26 | AIRMANSHIP, anagram of MARINA + SHIP. The setter does well to get you thinking about the wrong kind of pilot. |
27 | PANCREAS, [St] PANCR(E)AS, better known to some as a railroad station. There were two saints of that name; it was the second one who had all the places named after him. |
28 | MURPHY, double definition, where a ‘King Edward’ is a breed of potato, but Edward Murphy is the lawmaker. Simple, elegant, and quite difficult if you can’t see it, my last in. |
Down | |
2 | Omitted, but you won’t find this space empty. |
3 | THEORISER, THE + O(RISE)R. No, ‘upturn’ is not an inversion indicator, just a definition. |
4 | CRABBE, RC backwards + ABBE, pretty obvious unless you are weak on 18th-century poets. |
5 | CHINESE LANTERN, a double definition, one jocular. |
6 | CATAPULT, C(A TAP)ULT. Quite a clever clue, avoiding the cliched ‘cat’ approach. |
7 | ALPHA, double definition |
8 | OBSCENITY, anagram of SECTION BY. I needed the first letter to see this obvious one. |
14 | AUSTRALIA, A(US + ART backwards)LIA. The Latin ‘alia’ is known from the phrase ‘inter alia’, and does mean ‘others’. |
16 | PROFESSOR, PROF[it]. A rather clever cryptic that took me a long time to see. |
17 | OVERRATE, double definition, one a jocular cricket statistic. |
20 | SALAAM, SALA[d] + [h]AM. For a long time, I wanted this to be ‘salami’, but I couldn’t get it to work – wrong end of the stick. |
22 | TONIC, TON + I C, where the ‘ton’ is a rate of speed also called the ‘century’, highly illegal in nearly all countries. |
24 | FAITH, FA(I)T + H. |
Be interested to know which two clues held you up, Vinyl. My Lack Of Intelligence was LAOS. Also couldn’t see the cryptic for PROFESSOR — despite writing “PROF(IT) / essor?” in the margin. (It’s always the closest things I can’t see — don’t get me started on the times I’ve missed SMART ALEC(K)!!)
15ac: Koro would have had something more to say about the single set of ellipses, I’m sure. Might even have been pleased to find an instance where one was enough?
18ac: … mistreated a servant … presumably in shabby TAVERNAS?
Edited at 2011-09-12 08:33 am (UTC)
Pure coincidence no doubt, but CHINESE LANTERNS fits very well on Mid-Autumn Festival. As does AUSTRALIA on the day Sam Stosur showed what sport is all about.
I’d heard of CRABBE vaguely but didn’t know TSAREVNA. I should have guessed this from the anagrist left over when the checkers were all in place, however I never considered T as a starter so I picked ESTRAVNA as more likely than ASTREVNA.
This puzzle was too difficult for a Monday when I am still suffering from sleep deprivation during the US Open.
Also still clueless as to professor, regarding the essor bit.
I found most of this easy but after 15 minutes I was missing PROFESSOR, MURPHY and SALAAM. I didn’t help myself by putting in SALAMI, but I had a feeling it might be wrong. Unfortunately I didn’t understand the cryptic for PROFESSOR so I had a feeling that might be wrong too so only had ????H? for 28ac. Eventually something clicked and I got it from the law.
So a real struggle this morning in spite of only two unknowns (TSAREVNA and of course the plant).
I thought LAOS was a decent clue, and credited solvers with a knowledge of basic Greek, but perhaps not a clue for οἱ πολλοί.
I did this on real Times paper, where the ELLIPSIS slipped a line and was barely noticeable – online (I checked) it was more obvious. Even when I had SALAAM right (not knowing any words that went I?R?H?) MURPHY had to be parked in the mental undergrowth for a while to register – a fine clue inviting an an admission that you hadn’t concentrated enough in History. I could only remember Warwick the Kingmaker.
CoD though to last in MONETARIST
Thanks vinyl for an excellent blog.
Most of it very easy but with too many literary references and no balancing entries from the world of science. 13A LAOS is just awful. Got MURPHY from checkers and “King Edward say”. 20 minutes to solve.
A MONETARIST is an adherent to a particular doctrine rather rather than an expert. Anyway, is there such a thing as an “economic expert”? Isn’t economics the subject where they set the same exam questions every year but change the answers?
The Greek version is how I solved the clue, anyway – perhaps we should allow for a little γνῶσις and allow a little more κῦδος to the setter’s Σοφíα. And accept that the solvers should be credited with more νοῦς than the complaints would suggest.
Footnote: that’s (in order) laos, Zeus, gnosis, kudos, sophia and nous.
Found this ok, but was sure “Laos” was just too weak to be correct.
Also, add me to the camp that does not like Laos, monetarist or Professor. I thought a number of these clues were rather ramshackle, arts-centred, or just a bit too clever for their own good. Sorry.
Despite Keriothe’s comment, I am none the wiser.
Barbara
“Briefly prof” here means basically “briefly expressed as prof”.
Any clearer!?
What is the “briefly” doing in PROFESSOR (or are returns PROFITS, “briefly” removing the S before IT is dropped explicitly)?
My searches for the man called Sod who coined another expression with a similar meaning have so far drawn a blank.
And while a TON = 100 mph might be an illegal speed to drive in most countries, I reckon a century would be legal in more than 200 countries… 100 kph is not so fast.
Rob