By and large this was quite straightforward, and I made steady progress, getting all but 3 in about 25 minutes. GLADSOME fell about 10 minutes later, and I resorted to aids to get NOVELESE and VILLETTE in order to get the blog done after another fruitless 20 minutes or so. I think I could have stared at these all night and not got them. After submitting I discovered I had gone wrong at 23. I’d heard of AD INITIUM as a Latin phrase so went with AD INITIO without deciphering the wordplay properly.
I was helped at the start by getting 5d quite quickly, closely followed by 5a, which opened the right hand side up very nicely. I did like the wordplay in 21 so that gets my COD.
cd = cryptic def., dd = double def., rev = reversal, homophones are written in quotes, anagrams as (–)*, and removals like this
| Across | |
|---|---|
| 1 | Deliberately omitted |
| 5 | IN + F(L)IGHT |
| 9 | TABLE(MA)T |
| 10 | E |
| 11 | NOVELESE – But I can’t work out the wordplay. I’m sure someone will come to my rescue. Apparently it’s NOVE |
| 12 | GOSSIP = GP about (OS + IS rev) – Os is the Latin name for bone. |
| 13 | TRINIDAD = TRIAD about DIN rev |
| 15 | hidden word |
| 17 | I might as well omit this one as all the letters are checked and the wordplay is pretty clear. |
| 19 | TRUST + |
| 20 | RUEFUL = RU |
| 21 | P(EAR DR.)OP |
| 22 | NIACIN = (IN CAN)* about I |
| 23 | A + B + IN + IT + I + O |
| 24 | ATE after EDEN + |
| 25 | NIGHTS = NIGH + ST rev |
| Down | |
| 2 | RE(AS + ONE)D – got into debt = in the RED |
| 3 | VILLETTE is a novel by Charlotte Brontë. I don’t get the wordplay though. Is it also an old word for a small town? I think it’s just a word that sounds like it should be a little ville or french town, although that seems pretty lame. |
| 4 | SOMMELIER = L in (MEMORIES)* – I just finished watching Service, Michel Roux’s apprentice TV show for waiters, so this word was already in the forefront of my mind. |
| 5 | IN THE FIRST PLACE = (THIN FRITES)* + “PLAICE” – My first one in. |
| 6 | LASS + OED |
| 7 | G(LADS)O + ME – It took me an unaccountably long time to see this one. |
| 8 |
|
| 14 | A + GI + |
| 15 | IN + FRINGE – These days, the Edinburgh Festival Fringe is the most famous part of the festival, and is the largest arts festival in the world. |
| 16 | L + ACE + RATE |
| 17 | BRIDLING |
| 18 | ARSONIST = (ASSERTION)* without the |
| 19 | TOURIST = TT (races) about OUR IS. |
Reassured to see that my own failings and weaknesses aren’t always mine alone and that most of you experts also resort to external sources when eventually up against a wall.
Solving time for me is not the main point since my efforts are often interrupted by a nap.
I suspect that another reason for his inclusion is that compilers might reasonably expect solvers to have a hazy memory of poems met in children’s anthologies; and November, irrespective of its literary merit or lack of it, is certainly memorable. Is it really any more obscure than those herds of arcane antelopes or crews of mysterious matelots?
I am prepared to take your word for it but otherwise I would find it hard to believe that either of the clues in question could ever be regarded as ‘trivially easy’.
I tend to be on the other side of this argument: I did not have the benefit of a classical education (no Latin or Greek for me), but I accept that some basic knowledge of latin and classical mythology is required for this crossword. And very glad I am too, because it’s one of the principal reasons I know half this stuff. And what an edentate is. Plants still annoy me a bit I will admit.
In any event, there comes a time when frankly dreadful poems by (to quote my learned friend) half-remembered poets pass from an acceptable part of what might be considered general knowledge to obscurity.
Personally I’d put Villette in the same category but I suppose three novelists in one family (and women to boot!) makes for a certain notoriety.
Incidentally Tony I’m as ever in awe of your time, and I did get a kick out of your “pretty pathetic” comment yesterday!
But I *do* object to the continual failure to include what I think of as half of life, or more, on anything like the same terms. And tossing in an occasional vitamin from a cornflakes packet hardly counts!
I observe from the biog. on the Crossword Club website that our illustrious Editor has a first in classics, and I suspect that the background of some or all of the setters is similar.. I suppose all the scientists have better things to do with their time 😉
Still, I suppose honest ignorance of science is better than the pernicious nonsense perpetrated by the post-modernists; I recommend Sokal & Bricmont’s ‘Intellectual Impostures’ (in the US, ‘Fashionable Nonsense’).
I particularly enjoyed Richard Dawkins’s assessment:
“a philosopher who is caught equating the erectile organ to the square root of minus one has, for my money, blown his credentials when it comes to things that I don’t know anything about”