Solving time: 75mins
Mushy brain syndrome persists in Australia, in my mind and in those of its cricketers (what was Ricky thinking?). At almost every step of the solving process I thought I’d never get there, having seemingly intractable clues crossing each other at every corner, but I persevered, hoping to avoid complete ignominy. Some seriously devious and smooth clues in this one, he says, hoping others will agree.
Across |
1 |
AUGUR = A GURU with the second u jumping ahead three places. Augury originally involved interpreting messages brought from the gods by birds. The History Channel tells the story of how the mechanical singing birds developed by Hero(n) of Alexandria later played a role in it. Augurs could disengage the mechanism of the birds they controlled and so the bird would either sing or not when they turned the handle; thereby indicating yes or no to a specific question put to the augur by a paying supplicant. A nice little earner. |
4 |
TUBEROSES = TUBE + ROSES (as in shower roses), fragrant flowers. |
9 |
PUNCTILIO = (UNPOLITIC)*, as in punctilious to a fault. I couldn’t fit violoncello in despite my best procrustean attempts. |
10 |
CAMEO = “came to nothing” (“to” in the sense of “next to”) |
11 |
ATTACH = A.C. (for alternating current) in (THAT)* |
12 |
ADORABLE = BAR reversed in A DOLE. |
14 |
DET (“debt”) + O for old + NATION = DETONATION, “needs” being a link word? |
16 |
DECK, a double definition. Deck the halls and all that. |
19 |
DIRE = DIREctor
|
20 |
(NEED MEN OUT)* = DENOUEMENT, all the strings being pulled together (like a marionette doing a back flip?) |
22 |
CHASTITY = C[HAS T]ITY. My last in. I was thinking it was some Midlands town, wasn’t I. |
23 |
SCOTCH, double definition. |
26 |
ACORN = A + CORN. Somewhat incongruously, I can see a mighty oak from where I sit, but no snow decorates its branches. If I want to see snow, I have to look at a Christmas card. |
27 |
REPLETION = REP (as in repertory theatre) + LET I[O]N, being in a state of fullness |
28 |
GRANDADDY = GRAN + DADDY |
28 |
THE + IRe = THEIR |
Down |
1 |
(A DUD APPLE)* = APPLAUDED |
2 |
GEN + E.T. = GENET, not Jean but a spotted cat mostly found in Africa, although there is a European one. |
3 |
RETICENT = RE[IT rev.]CENT |
4 |
Deliberately withheld. Ask if you can’t see it. |
5 |
BLOOD (as in young blood) + DON + O.R. = BLOOD DONOR |
6 |
RECORD, a double definition, the second cryptic. |
7 |
SEMIBREVE = SE[VERB I’M rev.]E, or, somewhat paradoxically, a whole note; the longest note now in general use. It’s half a double note or breve. I hope that’s clear. Have I explained my system of musical notation involving six line staves? It’s probably best I don’t at this point. |
8 |
STOKE, double definition, the first referring to Stoke-On-Trent and not Stoke Potters. That map of the UK showing all the industries that we were forced to learn in primary school (in Australia!) comes in handy from time to time. It’s a much simpler map these days, I suppose. Do they still make carpets in Kidderminster? |
13 |
STREET CRED = CT (for court) reversed in (DESERTER)*, with the setters’ favourite nounal anagrind “criminal”. |
15 |
TARRAGON + A = TARRAGONA, a city in Catalonia. New Year’s resolution: make a list of Spanish cities. Tarragon, on the other hand, is my favourite herb. It’s difficult to get hold of the French variety in Australia, because it can only be grown from cuttings and quarantine restrictions forbid imports. |
17 |
KITCHENER = KIT + CHE[N for north]ER, for this army officer with a very recognisable image. |
18 |
TEACHEST = TEA CHEST, the definition being “art master” as in “thou teachest”. Needless to say, this clue meant little to me on the first forty reads, but on the forty-first, the penny dropped. A Remove, as those of you with a good Public School education would know, is a form or division within the school (cue Billy Bunter). |
21 |
ONE inside DTS (for Delirium Tremens) reversed = STONED &lit. “Recurrent” in the cryptic reading is in the sense of Anatomy. turned back so as to run in a reverse direction, as a nerve, artery, branch, etc.. Exceedingly clever and devious. For more than a while I wondered if there was another meaning of S.T.D. relating to chronic alcohol abuse. |
22 |
I’ll leave this one for the gang to the explain, if required. |
24 |
TRIP + E = TRIPE |
26 |
YAPS rev. = SPAY |
Paul S.
There are two clues here that don’t work for me. The second definition of RECORD is weak in my view but relatively unimportant. TEACHEST I really don’t like. In the end I put in TEA-CHEST based upon “seen in the REMOVE” which is itself weak. Tea-chests are seen during a “removal” or during “a move” not “in the remove”. The equating of “(thou) art master” to “(thou) teachest” is too much of a stretch. Its an unsigned archaic construction which should correctly be “(thou) art a master”. This is one the editor should have knocked on the head as far as I’m concerned.
The rest of it is standard stuff with nothing particularly worthy of mention.
But I agree that “the remove” is dodgy
The full paradox with semibreve is that a “breve” was a short note (variant of brief/brevis) as opposed to a “long”.
Sorry, forgot to say: solving time 6:54
Edited at 2010-01-04 10:58 am (UTC)
Edited at 2010-01-04 12:43 pm (UTC)
I was stuck in the ‘tuberoses’, ‘blood donor’, ‘record’ corner. My failure to get ‘record’ quickly was very annoying for obvious reasons. At least I had never heard of ‘tuberoses’.
Then I was left with ‘teachest’. I saw that the answer was about the only English word that would fit the crossing letters, but for the longest time I didn’t get it.
Apart from teachest and stoned I did not understand the wordplay for augur. Therein lay my downfall. I misspelt the answer as the homophonic carpenter’s boring tool.
I was brought up in Stoke, surrounded by coal-fired bottle ovens. Sadly today’s clue is somewhat anachronistic. Present-day Stoke is home to pottery museums rather than potteries.
I’m ok with the ‘tea chest’ and ‘remove’ bit, but I find the ‘teachest’ and ‘art master’ bit unsatisfactory.
Still, it was the best time this year.
Got off to a good start with eight solved cold on the first run through.
I’ve resolved not to criticise clues that defeat me – it’s like failing to climb Everest and then declaring it to be a bit rubbish as mountains go. So I shan’t do that. Mind you, I think it was Mark Twain who described resolutions as cheques drawn on a bank where we have no account, so I don’t know how long this one will hold up.
Not a promising start to the new year here: two regular puzzles, two DNFs.
I hate entering an answer mainly because nothing else will fit and not being clear on why it might be right or wrong. All I could see was a vague connection between tea-chests and removals. Having read the comments above I am still of the opinion that the clue is highly unsatisfactory. I don’t think it is technically correct, either, because I don’t see the link between “art master” and “teachest” as being strictly accurate. “thou teachest” might just suffice.
Mark